Re:The time has come to stand up for the GPL
by pmontra on Friday March 06, 2015 @12:50PM
(#9158370)
I think it's difficult to draw a line between improvements and derivative work (what your "entire work") could be. The GPL plays safe and requires redistribution of everything. I'd play safe too, with BSD I could end up seeing a company getting rich starting with my code and locking me outside of any improvements. I'm not so generous.
I agree with the principle that if you make improvements to the original work you MUST contribute those improvements back, and I like the fact that the GPL protects and enforces this principle.
But other restrictions leaves much to be desired because they seem too idealistic to be feasible (ex. distributing your entire work under the GPL).
I don't condone breaking the GPL if you disagree with it, but I believe that free and non-free software should not be mutually exclusive as the GPL intends to be; real life is not black and white.