News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The time has come to stand up for the GPL by esaym on Friday March 06, 2015 @09:26AM (#9157079)
So many people hate on the GPL. I personally like. It will protect your freedom as an open source developer. It is a good thing.
Re:The time has come to stand up for the GPL by spopejoy on Friday March 06, 2015 @10:25AM (#9157428)
Agreed. I can't help but be depressed that anti-GPL FUD dominates convos on HN. I mean, my own work has been disrupted by GPL being "inconvenient" but I will still defend it. My life has been enriched by the great software written under it, and the fact that it continues to thrive under this terrific license.
Re:The time has come to stand up for the GPL by Karunamon on Friday March 06, 2015 @11:39AM (#9157921)
Is that a function of the software, or of the license? (And more importantly, can that difference be quantified?)

BSD/MIT is pretty well thriving, too. You probably use OpenSSH every day :)

The more permissive licenses always seemed the way to go, to me. I'd rather people contribute out of personal desire to, rather than legal obligation. That, and the GPL always seemed a bit too communist (in the sense of implying that other people have a moral right to your work) for my taste.

Re:The time has come to stand up for the GPL by bad_user on Friday March 06, 2015 @11:56AM (#9158032)
Does it really matter?

If a software author wants for people to use/distribute his software under a specific license, that's his prerogative.

And the GPL is a truly free and open source license, it does allow you to use it commercially and for whatever reason, it does allow you to create derivates, all it asks is that in case you redistribute a derivate, you must also give the source-code on request. It's not even an EULA, it's just a copyright license.

And btw, compared to BSD/MIT, the GPL also contains a patents grant (implicit but powerful enough for version 2, explicit for version 3). And unfortunately in this universe, the big companies contributing to open-source also have really big patents portfolios, therefore I always look suspiciously at code licensed with BSD/MIT. And unfortunately patent trolls are a reality.

If you prefer more permissive licenses, then go for the Apache 2.0 ;-)

Re:The time has come to stand up for the GPL by Karunamon on Friday March 06, 2015 @12:02PM (#9158074)
If a software author wants for people to use/distribute his software under a specific license, that's his prerogative.

We're discussing the merits of particular licenses, particularly their impact on the software world, so this is kind of tautological, don't you think?

In any case, I was not aware of that difference between Apache and BSD, so you have my sincere thanks for pointing that out. I've got a few things on Github to modify methinks...

Re:The time has come to stand up for the GPL by bad_user on Friday March 06, 2015 @12:50PM (#9158371)
Well, I wanted to point out that as far as open-source goes, it has a pretty good definition and in the larger scheme of things, the actual open-source license used does not matter, all that matters is to get people to contribute.

But people contribute when they've got reasons to do so and many people believe in copyleft. And the GPL is an interesting case, because it happened because its author hated copyright, so he decided to turn it on its head and use it to his advantage. And in a world in which copyright (and other IP laws) keep getting worse, copyleft gets even more relevant.

To the issue of whether copyleft did any good versus MIT/BSD, well, would have Apple open-sourced WebKit if it wasn't for KHTML's LGPL license? I'm inclined towards no, but truth is, we'll never know.

On GCC on the other hand, its authors not only used GPL, but actually made it hard in the actual code for proprietary extensions to happen. This might have been good 15-20 years ago, when the landscape was dominated by proprietary compilers, but now I consider that we're better off with LLVM taking off.

Re:The time has come to stand up for the GPL by zak_mc_kracken on Friday March 06, 2015 @08:49PM (#9160633)
> Does it really matter?

Yes, it does. You set up a pretty big straw man there, allow me to illustrate:

  "Smoking is bad"

  "I don't know, I have very good friends who smoke."
There is undoubtedly great software that was shipped under the GPL but they became successful because they are great software, not because of the license they use.
Re:The time has come to stand up for the GPL by marrs on Sunday March 08, 2015 @05:41PM (#9167399)
The only straw man I see in this thread is the one you just set up.

If encouraging your project's success is secondary to preserving the freedom to scrutinise, modify, or redistribute its code, then GPL should be considered. Windows is successful by many metrics, but a failure where those freedoms are concerned. Obviously this is a good trade-off for Microsoft. It's not a good trade-off for Linux.

Where derivation is concerned, MIT & BSD guarantee diametrically opposed freedoms to the GPL. Which freedoms are more important depends on the intentions of the author, and the nature of the project.

Re:The time has come to stand up for the GPL by Karunamon on Tuesday March 10, 2015 @02:44PM (#9179726)
Freeness is a terrible metric to measure success - who cares if it's freely available if nobody uses it?
Re:The time has come to stand up for the GPL by marrs on Wednesday March 11, 2015 @11:00AM (#9184388)
That depends on what you're trying to succeed at. If the primary goal is to be free then freeness is the primary measure of success and popularity comes second.

The question here is about the choice of licence affecting the success of free software.

My argument is that, if success is more likely under an MIT style licence, this still may not be enough to sway me if I want a guarantee that users of my software are able to scrutinize the source code, or that derivatives of my software will remain free.

Re:The time has come to stand up for the GPL by Karunamon on Monday March 16, 2015 @03:55PM (#9213938)
Freeness in of itself is not a goal. Dirt is free. Air is free.

I can put a "hello world" app out there and release it under GPL, but is it useful? Does it actually solve any problems?

Re:The time has come to stand up for the GPL by marrs on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @12:35PM (#9219140)
Surely "hello world" is useful only if you release it under a copyleft licence since its purpose is to teach you how to get started with the language it demonstrates.

In any case, freeness is a goal for me as a user of software. I choose Gimp over Photoshop, for example, because I care more about still being able to access my photos in 20 years time than I do about having access to certain feature sets.

Re:The time has come to stand up for the GPL by Karunamon on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @03:39PM (#9220726)
That is a practical concern, not a political one.

The purely political stance I rail against is, in effect, "X fits my use case and is objectively better in every way, but Y is free, so I'll use Y."

For what it's worth, I can still open PSD's created way back in the 90's, and the format is well documented.[1] Adobe could disappear in a puff of logic tomorrow and their format wouldn't become unreadable.

    [1]: https://www.adobe.com/devnet-apps/photoshop/fileformatashtml/
Re:The time has come to stand up for the GPL by dragonwriter on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @12:41PM (#9219193)
> Surely "hello world" is useful only if you release it under a copyleft licence since its purpose is to teach you how to get started with the language it demonstrates.

I would argue that "hello world" is useful only if you release it under a very permissive non-copyleft free software license or, better, as public domain, for exactly that reason. Copyleft is excessively restrictive for this purpose.

Re:The time has come to stand up for the GPL by rdtsc on Friday March 06, 2015 @12:52PM (#9158388)
> BSD/MIT is pretty well thriving, too. You probably use OpenSSH every day :)

I believe that BSD/MIT is thriving because GPL was there. Google, Facebook, Microsoft open sourcing their products. Free compilers, free operating systems all of this stems and started from GPL being there.

> I'd rather people contribute out of personal desire to, rather than legal obligation.

Sure, that why you as an author (or your company as the owner of your work) can choose how to distribute your work. You can pick any license you want. You can still use GPL and dual license it. I've bought dual license GPL-ed code and was glad to do it.

> That, and the GPL always seemed a bit too communist (in the sense of implying that other people have a moral right to your work) for my taste.

Communism really? Well thanks to communism then we have Linux, Android devices, free compilers, and probably the reason we have free and open source software today.

Re:The time has come to stand up for the GPL by cliffbean on Friday March 06, 2015 @12:02PM (#9158066)
I take a pragmatic approach. I'm cool with BSD license for most of user-level application code, because if someone wants to make a binary-only application, I usually have options I can choose from. But in kernel space, a binary-only driver or kernel means that open source of any kind is locked out of the hardware, because it's hard to write drivers without specs. In that space, the GPL is one of our few tools for getting device makers to give us what we need.
Re:The time has come to stand up for the GPL by Karunamon on Friday March 06, 2015 @12:05PM (#9158092)
Has that really worked, though? It seems like, in the case of things like video cards, the GPL means that we have the full-performance, 3d accelerated, proprietary and closed driver, which is the one you're going to use unless you have a moral stance against it, and the objectively inferior (slower, at least) Libre version of the same thing to talk to the same hardware.

What if a working computer is your primary concern, not the political status of the code?

Re:The time has come to stand up for the GPL by TuringTest on Friday March 06, 2015 @12:37PM (#9158293)
If you care about more than the short term, such "political status of the code" should matter to you. The purpose of the GPL is not (or should not be) being able to say "my code is holier than yours", nor necessarily about having the best working implementation.

No, its main purpose is guaranteeing that all users can understand how the device works, even if they don't belong to the company that builds it. Other FLOSS licenses don't guarantee that in the same way than the GPL does, as they allow modifications to be kept secret. We could say that the GPL is "knowledge-friendly".

In the case of video cards, the alternative would be having only the proprietary closed driver and no open source version. It's incredibly hard to know of such closed systems work by reverse-engineering them; an open source driver, even if limited and less perfect, provides a full specification of the device.

Re:The time has come to stand up for the GPL by marrs on Sunday March 08, 2015 @05:54PM (#9167451)
Then you are able to use the proprietary driver so long as you agree to its licensing terms.

I suppose that you are arguing that an OSS driver licensed under more permissive terms would encourage GPU manufacturers to contribute more back to the original driver. Maybe it would and maybe it wouldn't. It certainly wouldn't discourage them from not contributing back.

Somehow I think that if they wanted parts of their drivers to be OSS they would have licensed them that way in the first place.

Re:The time has come to stand up for the GPL by rdtsc on Friday March 06, 2015 @12:35PM (#9158278)
Same here.

I think most people don't realize what the world was like before open source and free software.

Just using someone's code or sharing code for free was pretty radical. Now it seems obvious that you can use a free compiler. A free Unix-like OS. That was not the case. And people forget that.

I think GPL, GNU toolkit, Linux are a big part of that. I think this is a much better and interesting world than it was before. That is why I support it.

Re:The time has come to stand up for the GPL by marrs on Sunday March 08, 2015 @05:55PM (#9167460)
It taught me how to code.
Re:The time has come to stand up for the GPL by sanderjd on Friday March 06, 2015 @11:05AM (#9157713)
For me, it's a matter of goals. I think the GPL makes a lot of sense for creating a free software ecosystem, like GNU and Linux have done. But when I consider creating an open source project, that is just not usually my goal. Rather, I want my solution to whatever problem to be useful to as many people as possible, whether they're building something open or proprietary. Perhaps one day I'll create something that I envision fostering an ecosystem of derived works and many contributors, and I may well choose GPL for it, but until then, the more permissive licenses are more in line with my goals.
Re:The time has come to stand up for the GPL by rayiner on Friday March 06, 2015 @11:08AM (#9157733)
The GPL is useful when you want to build a community of open source code, but not useful when you want to work for someone else for free. Arguably, that's the whole point.
Re:The time has come to stand up for the GPL by sanderjd on Friday March 06, 2015 @11:27AM (#9157835)
I'm not sure if you were summarizing or disagreeing with me, but I mostly agree with you, except that I think the "work for someone else for free" part is spin. It's not totally inaccurate, it just mischaracterizes the goals and practicalities of the work. The goal isn't to make something useful to commercial entities, it's to make something useful to anybody (or, more likely in my case, nobody). Working for someone also implies that they control the design and direction of the work, but one of the huge draws of open source work is that you are able to design and direct it however you want. If someone likes your design and direction, they can use it, but they can't tell you what to do.
Re:The time has come to stand up for the GPL by tbrownaw on Friday March 06, 2015 @11:53AM (#9158018)
Postgres seems to be doing alright wrt "community", and they're not GPL: http://www.postgresql.org/about/licence/
Re:The time has come to stand up for the GPL by halostatue on Friday March 06, 2015 @11:28AM (#9157843)
Sometimes it’s also about being able to reuse work that you’ve done elsewhere for other employers. My current employer is friendly to the idea of me open sourcing a lot of the ancillary work that I’ve done that may be useful to other projects.

Using the GNU GPL family of licenses would not even be on our radar. (It isn’t core code, and if we accepted contributions from elsewhere, it would then start to have the ability to taint our code.)

Re:The time has come to stand up for the GPL by marrs on Sunday March 08, 2015 @06:09PM (#9167537)
For me it's a matter of principles, and the free software ecosystem is a natural consequence of the adherence to (at least some of) those principles.

I think the GPL is most useful at keeping us honest, or if it fails to do that, at least it provides a definition of what honesty is.

In an age in which we are hugely dependent on software, this is a human rights issue.

Re:The time has come to stand up for the GPL by Rusky on Friday March 06, 2015 @10:59AM (#9157667)
What I don't get about this thread is why people who dislike the GPL would want it to fail here. I'm not the GPL's biggest fan, but why would we want to weaken copyright in this way?
Re:The time has come to stand up for the GPL by justincormack on Friday March 06, 2015 @12:12PM (#9158131)
It is not about weakening copyright. It is about reducing uncertainty about what the GPL means. GPLv2 is not very well drafted in terms of linking and derived works, and v3 is not much better. And software like Linux is stuck with GPLv2 pretty much forever.
Re:The time has come to stand up for the GPL by Rusky on Friday March 06, 2015 @12:50PM (#9158364)
Right, it's not immediately about copyright, per se. But the GPL relies entirely on copyright and if this ends up setting a precedent that you can't use copyright to enforce the (unfortunately vague?) terms of the GPL, that weakens copyright.
Re:The time has come to stand up for the GPL by nymisunderrated on Saturday March 07, 2015 @08:20PM (#9164003)
It's a good question if it does "weaken copyright". That would be a good thing, and a primer in thirty+ years, because it would equally reduce its breadth from proprietary applications.

By what I see now (from old and new, but cursory public information), most likely, VMWare has too big resources for a long protracted legal battle, and I don't know if Conservancy can stand to it. That's not the same thing at all.

Re:The time has come to stand up for the GPL by Argorak on Friday March 06, 2015 @09:37AM (#9157128)
Especially, it protects your right as an open source user, which I feel is a perspective rarely taken.
Re:The time has come to stand up for the GPL by digi_owl on Friday March 06, 2015 @10:01AM (#9157274)
Frankly i find that the GPL do not distinguish between the two. Any user is a potential developer, given time and access to tools.
Re:The time has come to stand up for the GPL by Argorak on Friday March 06, 2015 @10:40AM (#9157513)
Hm, I would make the distinction, but I do see the point you are making. It ensures people can even become developers.
Re:The time has come to stand up for the GPL by jordigh on Friday March 06, 2015 @09:43AM (#9157159)
As a free-software user. Or a free software-user, take your pick. :-)
Re:The time has come to stand up for the GPL by Radim on Friday March 06, 2015 @11:27AM (#9157840)
I generally find that the GPL hatred comes a lot from academic circles. Lots of university-produced software prefers BSD or MIT, and looks down on GPL/LGPL.

I guess when you're paid from other people's taxes, you don't care as much about perceived "fairness", or that businesses don't take advantage of your work. It may even be the right thing to do.

In fact, companies using your "free", no-strings-attached SW may be a bonus in that situation. It looks good on academic grant applications.

Of course, the word "free" here means "paid for by other people", as it often does.

Re:The time has come to stand up for the GPL by halostatue on Friday March 06, 2015 @11:39AM (#9157922)
I’m not an academic. I do not use the GNU GPL for my code (unless required to by other licences because I am deriving my work from someone else) and I do what I can to discourage people from choosing it “by default”. My dislike for the GNU GPL comes mostly from the dishonest marketing (“free”, “freedom”) and dissembling about the licence (it is “viral” and that’s a feature). I also do not particularly care to replicate the FSF’s peculiar political rant when I distribute software.

However, if you want to enforce “share-alike” semantics for what you write, and you want the widest composability of your software with other “share-alike” software, by all means choose the GNU GPL (prefer locked to v2 unless you really care about “TiVo”-isation, then lock to v3—never choose the “at your discretion, a later version” clause). If you want to discourage SaaS companies from forming around your software, choose the GNU AGPL. If you want to enforce limited “share-alike” semantics at the link boundary, choose the GNU LGPL•.

• Warning to people using GNU LGPL software, though: it doesn’t mean what you think it means. You still have to provide recipients of your combined software the means to relink your software with modified versions of the GNU LGPL libraries.

If, however, you write software to scratch your own itch and don’t care what people do with it after you’ve written it? Pick a different licence: MIT, BSD, Apache, Artistic, whatever. You can even pick the GNU GPL family of licences if you really want that, but at least know why you’re picking it.

Re:The time has come to stand up for the GPL by scott_s on Friday March 06, 2015 @11:55AM (#9158026)
I have not seen "GPL hatred" from academic circles; in my time in academia, I did not hear anyone disparage the GPL. In fact, I don't think most academics had a deep understanding of the difference between open source licenses. That luxury is possible when you're not running a business.

I do, however, associate GPL resistance (not "hatred") from for-profit businesses.

Re:The time has come to stand up for the GPL by Radim on Friday March 06, 2015 @12:57PM (#9158410)
Fair point. "Hatred" is too strong a word.

Confusion about "why on earth would somebody NOT want to give away their software for free, for any use whatsoever?" is better. (Hey, it works for them!)

Re:The time has come to stand up for the GPL by BrainInAJar on Friday March 06, 2015 @11:53AM (#9158015)
MPL will protect your code's openness as well, but still play nicely with other open source (eg, FreeBSD can pull in your code.) GPL serves to prevent anyone with other ideas on what open source means from collaborating with you
Re:The time has come to stand up for the GPL by mlinksva on Friday March 06, 2015 @12:59PM (#9158419)
Interesting, I didn't realize FreeBSD will take MPL code. Do you have a reference or example of this policy? (I did a naive search and couldn't find.)
Re:The time has come to stand up for the GPL by BrainInAJar on Friday March 06, 2015 @02:15PM (#9158909)
ZFS & DTrace are under a MPL-like license (CDDL), they ship with FreeBSD, and are in a "third party, probably violates the GPL" ghetto on Linux
Re:The time has come to stand up for the GPL by Aldo_MX on Friday March 06, 2015 @12:22PM (#9158196)
I'll be honest, the GPL as-is is too obtuse to the extent it fails it's own premise of "This program is distributed in the hope that it will be useful".

I agree with the principle that if you make improvements to the original work you MUST contribute those improvements back, and I like the fact that the GPL protects and enforces this principle.

But other restrictions leaves much to be desired because they seem too idealistic to be feasible (ex. distributing your entire work under the GPL).

I don't condone breaking the GPL if you disagree with it, but I believe that free and non-free software should not be mutually exclusive as the GPL intends to be; real life is not black and white.

Re:The time has come to stand up for the GPL by pmontra on Friday March 06, 2015 @12:50PM (#9158370)
I think it's difficult to draw a line between improvements and derivative work (what your "entire work") could be. The GPL plays safe and requires redistribution of everything. I'd play safe too, with BSD I could end up seeing a company getting rich starting with my code and locking me outside of any improvements. I'm not so generous.
Re:The time has come to stand up for the GPL by the_mitsuhiko on Friday March 06, 2015 @11:54AM (#9158022)
> It will protect your freedom as an open source developer.

It protects your freedom as a free software developer maybe. People that do not release under the GPL do not really benefit from it.