Re:Is Most of Our DNA Garbage?
by Animats on Thursday March 05, 2015 @04:44PM
(#9154027)
Flowering plants have huge amounts of DNA, 1-2 orders of magnitude more than mammals. It's like they haven't evolved subroutines or macros or something comparable.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Plants are an interesting case. It's a pretty simple theory - plants need more DNA because they can't change their location. If conditions change around them, they can't just get up and move like an animal. Instead, they have to have dormant DNA that doesn't get activated unless the environment changes. They can't change their locations, so they have to change themselves.
Plants tend to be polyployd[1], sometimes to a rather ridiculous amount. 6x or 8x (or more) full copies of the genome is common, compared to the two copies ("dipooid") in most animals. This has been going on for a long time[2], so some of the older duplicate copies separated over time leaving "near duplicates" in the genome that now serve new purposes.
Maintaining these "extra copies" of the genome costs energy (lowering survivability), but you get something very loosely like RAID mirroring allowing the genome to survive more errors. Having more than a single backup copy also allows a single plant species to have a lot more variation, as alternative genotypes can be saved across generations in the "backup copies".
The idea that nature may have evolved coding design patterns to make "cleaner more efficient" code is amazing.
Are flowering plants just written in a language that doesn't have "for loops" so everything is just written out line by line?
No. The compactness of the DNA "program" is an evolutionary trade off, just like in the engineering. For some species to have a significantly more compact code now there should have existed some evolutionary benefit among the ancestors for that.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genome_size#Genome_reduction_in...
Interesting, and from the same page, Drake's rule says that similarly to programming, the larger the "codebase", the slower the mutation (new feature launch) rate.
I'm excited to see the headline "Nature's usage of macros in insect DNA" appear on hacker news next week.
You might get a kick out of insect patterning based upon morphogen protein concentration gradients then...