Re:"Ayn Rand's Revenge" - NYTimes Book Review of new Rand bi...
by tptacek on Saturday October 31, 2009 @03:32PM
(#913921)
He didn't say anything about her beliefs. He said the book sucked. For all you know, he's a libertarian.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:"Ayn Rand's Revenge" - NYTimes Book Review of new Rand bi...
by adriand on Saturday October 31, 2009 @08:53PM
(#914462)
I'm not a libertarian, but your point stands - it wasn't her philosophy that bothered me, it's the book and how poorly it is written. To use an example from the book I mentioned, The Name of the Rose has long sections where people argue over obscure religious matters (such as whether or not God has a sense of humour). As an atheist, if I reacted to books simply on the basis of my beliefs, I'd hate it, since what's more pointless than reading dialogue about a non-existent entity?
But I found it fascinating, because it's well done, well-written, and intellectually rigorous.
That said, the quality of her writing did impact my opinion of her philosophy. I was open-minded about Rand and her ideas until I started reading Atlas Shrugged, at which point I decided that if her writing was that poor, I really didn't see how I could embrace her ideas, especially since so many of her supporters seem to think it's a really fine novel.
Re:"Ayn Rand's Revenge" - NYTimes Book Review of new Rand bi...
by xenophanes on Saturday October 31, 2009 @03:37PM
(#913932)
I have performed a side-channels attack on the original comment, and have determined it is unintentionally leaking information about the author's political views. It turns out he's not a libertarian.
Re:"Ayn Rand's Revenge" - NYTimes Book Review of new Rand bi...
by tptacek on Saturday October 31, 2009 @04:04PM
(#913984)
We're now talking about the author of the comment and not the comment itself. Can we stop?
Re:"Ayn Rand's Revenge" - NYTimes Book Review of new Rand bi...
by xenophanes on Saturday October 31, 2009 @04:07PM
(#913991)
Maybe you were. I was talking about how comments contain inexplicit information, and drawing an analogy to the computer security field (which I figured is more on topic).
It's also a field which, IIRC, you know a lot more about than I do. Perhaps you can improve the analogy.