Re:"Ayn Rand's Revenge" - NYTimes Book Review of new Rand bi...
by rauljara on Saturday October 31, 2009 @03:06PM
(#913885)
Rand herself was famous for being insulting and dismissive, which I think is the main reason people react so strongly against her. In the introduction to anthem, she basically states that if you don't agree with her views on capitalism, then you are in favor of gulags and concentration camps. She, herself, leaves no room for middle ground, nuance, or civilized discussion. That isn't an excuse to resort to insults when talking about her, but if you are honestly wondering why people react so emotionally against her, it might have something to do with her assaulting other people's beliefs on such an emotional level.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:"Ayn Rand's Revenge" - NYTimes Book Review of new Rand bi...
by tptacek on Saturday October 31, 2009 @03:32PM
(#913921)
He didn't say anything about her beliefs. He said the book sucked. For all you know, he's a libertarian.
Re:"Ayn Rand's Revenge" - NYTimes Book Review of new Rand bi...
by adriand on Saturday October 31, 2009 @08:53PM
(#914462)
I'm not a libertarian, but your point stands - it wasn't her philosophy that bothered me, it's the book and how poorly it is written. To use an example from the book I mentioned, The Name of the Rose has long sections where people argue over obscure religious matters (such as whether or not God has a sense of humour). As an atheist, if I reacted to books simply on the basis of my beliefs, I'd hate it, since what's more pointless than reading dialogue about a non-existent entity?
But I found it fascinating, because it's well done, well-written, and intellectually rigorous.
That said, the quality of her writing did impact my opinion of her philosophy. I was open-minded about Rand and her ideas until I started reading Atlas Shrugged, at which point I decided that if her writing was that poor, I really didn't see how I could embrace her ideas, especially since so many of her supporters seem to think it's a really fine novel.
Re:"Ayn Rand's Revenge" - NYTimes Book Review of new Rand bi...
by xenophanes on Saturday October 31, 2009 @03:37PM
(#913932)
I have performed a side-channels attack on the original comment, and have determined it is unintentionally leaking information about the author's political views. It turns out he's not a libertarian.
Re:"Ayn Rand's Revenge" - NYTimes Book Review of new Rand bi...
by tptacek on Saturday October 31, 2009 @04:04PM
(#913984)
We're now talking about the author of the comment and not the comment itself. Can we stop?
Re:"Ayn Rand's Revenge" - NYTimes Book Review of new Rand bi...
by xenophanes on Saturday October 31, 2009 @04:07PM
(#913991)
Maybe you were. I was talking about how comments contain inexplicit information, and drawing an analogy to the computer security field (which I figured is more on topic).
It's also a field which, IIRC, you know a lot more about than I do. Perhaps you can improve the analogy.