Re:Dropbox starts using POST, and why this is poor API design
by treve on Monday March 02, 2015 @06:42PM
(#9135185)
REPORT definitely still has the linking problem. REPORT only solves the issue that POST is unsafe/non-idempotent. This is just a marginal improvement, and would not qualify as restful.
The 'creating a query resource' would be an option for those that do want a linkable resource.
Why linking is important? I don't think I can quickly sum that up in a comment, or properly do it justice. If you're genuinely interested I would be happy to look for and suggest a few resources that do a much better job than I ever could.
Regardless, I don't believe that HATEOAS/RESTful design is the be-all and end-all. I think certain web api's are particularly well-suited for it, but it's a type of design that is not appropriate for every problem.
There's a strong case for taking advantage of every technology at your disposable to deliver the most compelling value and end-user experience possible, as-is the trait/focus of successful companies (ala DropBox).
And how exactly is REPORT better for linkability? Why is being able to link a 8kb QueryString more important and worth sacrificing over all other end-user features/qualities for? and what are other examples of "breaking the web"?