News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bitcoin is not for goverment. Bitcoin is digital currency... by sj4nz on Saturday February 28, 2015 @05:57PM (#9125369)
This slides in the assumption that you need a national currency.

No traditional nation-state will _really adopt_ a crypto-currency unless it bakes in some ability to seize or inflate it's subject's currency. If that exists in their desired crypto-currency then, of course, no one will ever use it without the threat of violence. Catch-22 for modern nation-states.

Re:Bitcoin is not for goverment. Bitcoin is digital currency... by anigbrowl on Saturday February 28, 2015 @06:03PM (#9125385)
By that logic, private ownership of gold should be forbidden. That did happen once, during the Great Depression, but that policy was abandoned in the 1960s and nobody has made any attempt to reinstate it since.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gold_Reserve_Act

Re:Bitcoin is not for goverment. Bitcoin is digital currency... by oafitupa on Saturday February 28, 2015 @06:55PM (#9125510)
In many countries it's forbidden. Eg: Argentina, Venezuela, etc. The government doesn't like it when their people find ways of escaping inflation.
Re:Bitcoin is not for goverment. Bitcoin is digital currency... by kiba on Saturday February 28, 2015 @06:23PM (#9125428)
Nothing prevent nation-states from adopting their own altcoin and altering the supply as they like.
Re:Bitcoin is not for goverment. Bitcoin is digital currency... by oafitupa on Saturday February 28, 2015 @06:51PM (#9125502)
Except they would have to also create their own mining industry to secure it, or enemy countries could easily attack it.
Re:Bitcoin is not for goverment. Bitcoin is digital currency... by sliverstorm on Saturday February 28, 2015 @07:26PM (#9125583)
Why would they allow other actors to be part of their mining?
Re:Bitcoin is not for goverment. Bitcoin is digital currency... by oafitupa on Saturday February 28, 2015 @08:45PM (#9125719)
The real question is why would a government use a Bitcoin clone, instead of either traditional fiat or just Bitcoin.
Re:Bitcoin is not for goverment. Bitcoin is digital currency... by Frondo on Saturday February 28, 2015 @06:39PM (#9125473)
What threat of violence are you describing?
Re:Bitcoin is not for goverment. Bitcoin is digital currency... by krapp on Saturday February 28, 2015 @07:03PM (#9125521)
Re:Bitcoin is not for goverment. Bitcoin is digital currency... by PhasmaFelis on Saturday February 28, 2015 @07:03PM (#9125526)
Some very silly people have concluded that, since ultimately no rule or law can be enforced against the unwilling without some sort of ability to exercise power over them, making a law is logically equivalent to saying that anyone who breaks it should be shot; and, therefore, people who make laws against any but the most extreme crimes are violent thugs.

And thus it naturally follows that you shouldn't have to pay taxes. Isn't that convenient?

(I think this formulation was originally conceived by anarchists, where it is at least logically consistent, but tax protestors and some libertarians have adopted and deformed it into a convenient catch-all for "anything the government does that I don't like is ZOMGviolence.")

Re:Bitcoin is not for goverment. Bitcoin is digital currency... by TeMPOraL on Saturday February 28, 2015 @08:16PM (#9125666)
AFAIK libertarians have this "principle of non-aggression" which basically defines "anything I don't like" as an attack, and thus pretty much anything that government does becomes violence.

But in general, "monopoly on violence" is a legitimate concept and I think it's a requirement for a state-sized group of people to live in (a relative) harmony. You need to have some means to enforce coordination or else people get trapped in various destructive behaviours.

Re:Bitcoin is not for goverment. Bitcoin is digital currency... by skilesare on Sunday March 01, 2015 @10:18AM (#9127297)
They also have a tendency to put capitalism up on a pedestal even though it requires the charging of economic rent. Apparently extracting taxes is a crime but extracting economic rent is to be lauded.
Re:Bitcoin is not for goverment. Bitcoin is digital currency... by TeMPOraL on Sunday March 01, 2015 @10:29AM (#9127353)
That's why I love that 'cstross quote from [0].

"Libertarianism is like Leninism: a fascinating, internally consistent political theory with some good underlying points that, regrettably, makes prescriptions about how to run human society that can only work if we replace real messy human beings with frictionless spherical humanoids of uniform density"

This holds for other political and economical ideologies as well - they may have some good and important points (that's why they gain followers), but ultimately pure theoretical models rarely work well when applied to the complexities of the real world. One needs to remember that and see places where tradeoffs are needed to be made.

[0] - http://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/2013/12/why-i-wa...

Re:Bitcoin is not for goverment. Bitcoin is digital currency... by dredmorbius on Sunday March 01, 2015 @12:49AM (#9126180)
They also very conveniently ignore a staggering (and bloody) history of corporate violence, whether against workers, the public at large, colonial states, arms and other sales, unsafe products, unsafe working conditions, and far too many more to enumerate.

Power exists. Violence exists. Both are independent of whether or not they're manifested in a state. Arguments to the contrary collapse into tautologies.

Re:Bitcoin is not for goverment. Bitcoin is digital currency... by leereeves on Saturday February 28, 2015 @06:40PM (#9125478)
Taxes.
Re:Bitcoin is not for goverment. Bitcoin is digital currency... by megoah on Saturday February 28, 2015 @06:19PM (#9125421)
This is the same reason that no government allows or encourages the large-scale ownership of property, land, minerals, gold, or anything else.

Except that they do. All the time.

Because governments are not evil machines that only want to steal your money. That's just a Dunning-Kreuger / nutjob interpretation of reality that is often repeated by a certain kind of broken individual.

Re:Bitcoin is not for goverment. Bitcoin is digital currency... by sj4nz on Sunday March 01, 2015 @11:14AM (#9127582)
Nice DH1 you've got there.

Governments are not evil machines. They're machines staffed by people and people do what people often do: follow the laws blindly because "it's their duty", exploit the existing laws to their advantage "because it's legal", and craft new laws to monkey-patch the flaws in older laws "because it's their job." When two opposing groups of people disagree with each other, they resort to theatrics and name-calling and the machine kind of idles in its current state. The machinery isn't evil and the people aren't evil. This is just how the machine works. If the people operating the machine decide it needs more of a resource, they'll try to get it by any any available means to keep the machine running. Their job, and belief in the machine depend on it. Whether or not the machine gives the world "a better place" is a coincidental side-effect of the machine that happens often, but not always.

Adopting a crypto-currency would give this machine less control over resources because it would either have too much transparency (no black budgets or quid-pro-quos) or perfect opacity (no ability to seize funds from victims or punish criminals financially).

Elections do not change the machine except in the sense of an oil-change--to optimize its continuous operation. The machine is never replaced. And people who do not believe in the machine are always attacked by the operators with a vested interest in the machine... a certain kind of broken individual.

Re:Bitcoin is not for goverment. Bitcoin is digital currency... by entrop13 on Saturday February 28, 2015 @06:30PM (#9125448)
those arn't liquid assets. who's suffering from dunning-kreuger effects now? nice puppet account you got there with 1 karma. also land and property are taxed so... yea