You're body tries very hard to make sure you have enough nutrition. It increases hunger and reduces will power, and most long term research on diet based obesity/diabetes intervention shows that they have terrible effectiveness rates.
*not everyone, of course.
"Just eat less" is not a very helpful answer, it's incredibly frustrating to hear, believe me.
When your blood sugar is in the 60s or 50s range from trying like hell to do your diet all day, reason goes out the window and 'mere' will power is not enough.
It takes a lot of effort, lots of planning (preparing food, planning what, where and when to eat, snacks, etc) and a LOT of information (nutrition, insulin effects on the body, pros and cons of current 'fad' diets, etc) which takes a while to collect, also, lots of trial an error.
It doesn't help that most doctors, are clueless regarding healthy eating.
This is the most ridiculous thing I've ever read on this site. Fresh, healthy, affordable food has never been more accessible to any society.
>"Just eat less" is not a very helpful answer, it's incredibly frustrating to hear, believe me.
Eating less is the only thing that works. You only find this advice unhelpful because it's hard. But the reason it's hard is because you've trained yourself to overeat and now you have to break that habit, a habit that has its psychological and physiological meathooks in you. People who haven't lived their entire lives stuffing themselves to the bursting point have no problems autoregulating. I mean, shit, my cat can manage it.
>It takes a lot of effort, lots of planning (preparing food, planning what, where and when to eat, snacks, etc) and a LOT of information (nutrition, insulin effects on the body, pros and cons of current 'fad' diets, etc) which takes a while to collect, also, lots of trial an error.
You sound like a pathetic whiny snot who has embraced a life of learned helplessness.
I'm trying to change my circumstances the 'hacker way': learning, experimenting and trying my best, even if it is a hard problem for me to resolve.
For me, staying healthy, slim and fit is incredibly hard, it seems that for you it is not.
A guy I went to high school with was an all-star center on our (American) football team at six feet tall and 294 lbs. He had always been "the fat guy" from the time we were children. Between the end of one football season and the start of the next school year, he dropped to 160 lbs. When he spoke on the topic of his change, he always first answered the "how" question with this response: "I just decided I was tired of being fat." For him, the particulars involved introducing heaping servings of fibrous vegetables (to help satiety) and running. But those things were of secondary importance.
Look at this guy: http://www.reddit.com/r/Fitness/comments/2xczpt/6_month_prog...
45 years and old and resigned to being dumpy and hypertensive. Then he decided "fuck this" and changed his life. This is how it always works. You have to become sufficiently fed up to no longer accept the status quo. No one can do that for you nor will it appear in any study, book, or other "how-to-be-fit" advice.
This is why I no longer talk to people in real life about this topic. I can give them an endless supply of information on nutrition & programming but not the one thing without which they are doomed to failure.
I can only think that people who have this kind of experience must be suffering from self-deception or dissonance between what they believe they want and what they really do want. Like the student who tries his damnedest on exam day but has not spent any time familiarizing himself with the course material. What we want is revealed by our behavior, not what we think. What I actually am is what I do.
As to the particular topic at hand, it is a core value of mine to keep my body as able as possible for as long as possible. My body is the vessel that conveys my existence through time-space and getting the most out of that existence requires optimizing my fitness. If I were to wake up one day twenty pounds overweight and pre-hypertensive, remedying that situation would shoot up my priority list. It would become an emergency situation that would simply have to be dealt with as expeditiously as possible. So when I hear people talk about how much they "really want" to lose weight but then present no behavioral evidence to support that statement, I can only conclude they they are either simply lying for the sake of garnering social approval or are deluding themselves as to their true desires.
I think when people say they want to lose weight, they mean that they wish they didn't have that extreme compulsion to eat that overwhelms their rational processes. Or that they could overcome it.
What bugs me is that people view it as a simple matter of self control, when it's actually about self control versus strength of desire. If your desires aren't that strong, it's easy to look like you have an iron will.
That, or you're lying through your teeth.
A single small trial isn't something to base medical advice around.
Americans eat so much they think overeating is normal. Bariatric patients (morbidly obese people getting their stomach essentially amputated, see Roux-en-Y) are generally told to fast for 24 hours prior to surgery. Their glucose levels before surgery are often normal, for the first time in decades.
The association between food intake and obesity is far, far stronger than cigarettes and lung cancer, even stronger than Hep B and hepatocellular carcinoma.
Asserting that eating less (and I do mean significantly less) needs to be studied more is like saying we should hold off on parachute use until more studies are done.
It can be used in both, and can use science, but that doesn't make it the same thing.
P.S. http://europepmc.org/abstract/med/1524537 is a study on parachute effectiveness
What I learned from those many years of being fat is that my experience is not the same as everyone else's. Just because I find it simple to not drink doesn't mean it's the same for an alcoholic. Just because I'm a completer-finisher type doesn't mean it's easy for someone else to slog through writing their thesis. Just because being happy is a default state of mind for me, doesn't mean a depressive can just flip a switch like that.
I might, if asked, tell an alcoholic that they need to stop drinking, or a fat person that they need to lose weight, or a procrastinator that they need to finish their work - but I'll try not to be arrogant enough to tell them that the solution is obvious, that it's easy. How the hell would I know what's easy for them?
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-13887909
An extreme eight-week diet of 600 calories a day can reverse Type 2 diabetes in people newly diagnosed with the disease.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/dme.12722
In people with Type 2 diabetes of more than 8 years' duration, a therapeutic trial of a very-low-calorie diet may be undertaken with a 50% chance of achieving non-diabetic fasting glucose levels, with all other antidiabetic therapies discontinued.