But, since getting a Nexus 7 on sale (partly because I wanted to tinker with making mobile apps and wanted to have a tablet sized device to test on) I've found a number of use cases that I didn't realize I had.
The best, most useful, thing is that I use it to work on my Spanish language learning. For the first time in my life, I practice my Spanish every day; for a few minutes before sleep, for a few minutes after waking up, and it replaces my Kindle for restroom visits. I've found my reading comprehension is better than it's ever been, even better than when I spent two years in Spanish class in high school and when I spent more than a month traveling deep in Mexico (where nobody speaks English) after just a short time. Duolingo and Memrise are great tools...so great that in a few more months, when I'm confident in my Spanish, I plan to focus on French. You can use both tools on a laptop, but I don't take my laptop to bed or to the restroom. And, the phone is just a little too small to be effective for this purpose, IMHO.
Likewise, I've found more time for doing online classes...the screen is big enough for videos, but switching between tabs or apps is tedious enough that I don't get distracted the way I do on my laptop or desktop. Again, a use case I discovered after getting the tablet.
I am a bit slow to adopt new stuff like this (but an early adopter of other things; I had a pager for years after everyone else has switched to cell phones, but then got a Sidekick very early in the smart phone story, because there was finally a thing I would want to use a phone for: Browsing the Internet and reading mail), so I dunno what that means for the general case, but I really like my tablet. It gets more use than my phone (because I literally hate phone calls, so my tablet does everything the phone does only better, except fit in my pocket and work without wifi).
"Eventually they end up on the nightstand, and used for reading news and looking at pictures in bed at night, before falling asleep"
Which is a pretty good use case, too. I won't buy a new Kindle when my current one dies (if it ever dies...my first Kindle lasted five+ years before I dropped it on the tile bathroom floor one too many times and cracked the screen), because a tablet works just as well for that use case and has many other uses.
I have actually delegated my Kindle and my Nexus 7 to specific roles. The Kindle is for reading literature, exclusively. The Nexus is for everything else. It even helps me distinguish between leisure time and work/study time (kinda like that rule for addressing insomnia of "don't do anything in bed other than sleep and sex").
Why not? Why wouldn't you choose the device which best counteracts your tendency to get distracted?
I honestly think the issue is that mobile OSes are not useful in a tablet form factor. Microsoft, although not getting the delivery perfect with Windows 8, were at least pushing in the right direction.
Still, the tradeoff is worth it for many people depending on what's more important to them--battery/weight or power/flexibility.
I'm amazed at the loss we're facing. Something is odd. In the 80s game developers created their own tools from scratch. Now it seems people lost the desire to take advantage of computers. If it's not a desktop then you can't edit a video or compose music, etc, etc ...
- For whatever reason, the iPad does not do the thing normal computer screens do when reading papers, which is to make my eyes slide right off them. So while not content creation, it's way nicer than hauling around a stack of journals. I use Papers for this.
- I use either iA Writer or Pages to actually write content, and cut away all the distractions of working on a laptop (like say, Hacker News...). Usually commentaries, discussion sections, introductions - things that need more writing and less clever table formatting. I also use this to write posts for my blog (www.variancehammer.com) which is about Warhammer 40K and my mostly data-driven musings on the game.
- iSSH for SSH access to the cluster, and the sweet, sweet computational power that follows. There's something thrilling about launching cluster jobs from my bedside.
- Keynote for presentations
- PythonMath and Textastic for some musing and prototyping.
- TouchDraw for brainstorming model flow diagrams and the like and having them on-hand later.
I also like Papers on the iPad.
My reading mode for academic papers, using the dedicated app on the iPad, is different than on my laptop (or the laptop tethered to the big monitor). I'm better able to deeply read on the iPad because it's dedicated to that one task.
I probably spend about equal clock-time reading papers on both platforms -- on the laptop I read 2 pages from each of 20 papers, and on the iPad I read 15 pages from each of 4 papers.
But I have to note: I don't create content there, I consume it.
No thanks.
I won't ask people to grow internal and external skills as refined as actual musicianship, but with proper understanding of human memory and tactile sense, I'm sure one can find an interaction paradigm that will turn a tablet into another kind of bicycle for the mind.
This argument may have been true 3 years ago but they're all vastly easier to carry around in one hand without getting fatigued now. The iPad Air is incredibly light for its size and I was able to use it for hours at a time without wanting to put it down like the older iPads. The retina Mini I have is even lighter.
I agree with everything else you say though. They're great for consuming web content, but I barely use mine for anything else now. If I actually got a phablet like the iPhone 6 Plus, I would probably end up selling my mini altogether because everything I do on my iPad I could do on my iPhone with a larger screen.
I've found that I moved most things to the iPad mini when I first got it. Dropbox + editorial (Python scripting!) + workflow and an updated IFTTT has me rarely reaching for my MacBook pro or heading to the iMac or Mac Pro.
Also Procreate (absolutely awesome app) has me sketching and painting again, now that I don't have to carve out space in my life for an easel and paint gear.
Hmm, this I guess has expanded beyond your comment and into being a bit of a reply to the no content creation mantra in a comment below, but there it is.
Although, if you really want one that bad, get a Nexus 7 tablet with data, and run a VoIP number on it.
The N7 is easier to type on, and the one arcade game I play (emulator called Pinball Arcade) works so much better on the slightly larger device. So now I just play pinball a lot less.
VoIP isn't a real option. For instance, yesterday I had to reactivate one SIM at the airport, and could only do it by making a real phone call on the SIM. Google intentionally disabled this on the N7, and even people that hacked up the ROM couldn't get it working. And many times when I want a phone/SMS, for "emergencies", I don't want to hope my data is working well enough.
> with great batteries
A phablet with a big battery plus not-ultraHD screen would solve the abysmal battery life problems of modern phones... it's likely thinness suffers though?
The problem is that Huawei ships a terrible, messed up version of 4.3. Complete with a button to accidentally force close all programs (and boast about memory "freed"). And a shiny button bar, instead of just black. And bits of Engrish, which would otherwise be endearing, on the custom apps. It sucks. But if I could run Cyanogen on it, it'd be the best phone ever.
There's also the Blu Energy with a 5000mAh battery, but I don't know how good the phone is yet (it's only $150). Blu seems to ship mostly stock Android. The problem is they have many dozens of models (most under $200, a few around the $100 point), so it's hard to figure out what's what. They seem to be targeting Latam with cheap-but-nice devices, like Vivo Air. If they'd focus on a couple of top models, they could easily become the dev phone of choice. Not sure what the unlocking situation is.
I know I'm in the minority, but I don't mind writing long texts on a touchscreen. For me, the Windows 8 keyboard worked much better than the iPad keyboard though -- I'm not exactly sure why, but the layout and visual style were more suitable for my habits.
I think part of the reason why I like to write fiction on a tablet is that it's a different typing experience from my day job. It switches off the code-typing habit and forces me to write differently.
Realized they are just oversized smart phones that can't make cell phone calls, can't be held easily with one hand, but can't be used for creating content like a laptop, or typing emails, and they look silly when used for taking pictures.
Eventually they end up on the nightstand, and used for reading news and looking at pictures in bed at night, before falling asleep or given to kids as babysitting devices.