News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:London's poor fetish: commodifying working class culture by l33tbro on Thursday February 26, 2015 @04:51PM (#9115784)
The worst thing about this article is how hilariously smug and self-assured the tone is.

Seriously, what gives the author the right to blanketly declare the lives of the middle class to be souless, meaningless, and that their jobs are bullshit? How does he not realize that he is projecting his own insecurity and outdated ideas about "authenticity" on to these people.

Honestly, I've found that most people don't really give a shit about doing something truly meaningful and soul-fulfilling in their work. I may, you probably do too. But most people are fine with showing up, doing what they have to do, then getting out and spending time with the people that they love. What is so wrong with that?

Sure, we get it, the visual signifiers of the exotic have changed over the last 10 years. Once upon a time in the UK it was Superclubs and being part of something fancy and opulent. Now, the iconography of the working-class has been appropriated - and people want to buy into that, probably based on the tail-end of the skeuomorphic thing - where we were desiring to feel connected to nostalgia based aesthetics.

But what the author doesn't get is that people are deeply social. Sure, the economic and cultural environment will shift things the modes of interactions - but people will continue forming relationships with friends, relaying experiences, dancing to dumb songs with their friends. The artcile had some great observations, but maybe rethink framing this as "a problem" and stick to the description of culture (which was actually interesting).

Re:London's poor fetish: commodifying working class culture by brainpan on Thursday February 26, 2015 @05:27PM (#9115995)
> what gives the author the right to blanketly declare the lives of the middle class to be souless, meaningless, and that their jobs are bullshit?

Well, that's what modern life is under the TINA regime[1]. A whole society of people who've sold out every heroic ideal humans have ever conceived, in order to live as cells inside corporate organs of a hyper-capitalistic organism that would collapse if it stopped expanding. Money is god (it's about equal in power to law, at least), and money is created in a Ponzi between central banks and governments, and between private financial corporations and private enterprises/individuals, all on the promise that there will be even more money next year to pay back the debts of this year, and give "good enough or better" returns on large capital pools invested. We consume natural resources in an unsustainable way in exchange for this money, and for a cellular role in the organs and the organism, and it will last in this way until the last day comes, when we starve to death on our own planetary stripmine.

We could be taking a new course right now, to live in idealistic ways, in sustainable ways, in heroic ways. But we all just quit that notion before we start, because it's just too hard, and we distract ourselves with the greatest media spectacle of entertaining diversions and political issues every conceived.

Welcome to life in hell. You can get defensive and self-righteous when people point out the mass hypocrisy and delusion and error in all our lives, but it doesn't change the truth that we are all living in an awful state, as cowards and lapdogs of the hyper-capitalist system that gives us life today, even as it guarantees death in the future.

I figure that a not-yet born post-human super-predator will take the best of human intelligence and anti-entropic principles and incorporate them, and destroy the rest. Or some already-existing higher powers will swoop in at some point in the future to harvest the best of our anti-entropic principles, and destroy the rest of us.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/There_is_no_alternative

Re:London's poor fetish: commodifying working class culture by ashark on Thursday February 26, 2015 @05:54PM (#9116143)
Oh my, have you been following the same bread-crumb trail of reading from HN that I have?

http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/07/30/meditations-on-moloch/

Starts off iffy, gets really good.

Incidentally, that page led me to this by the same author:

http://raikoth.net/libertarian.html

Which is very much like something I'd been meaning to write for some time, though better-done (and certainly longer) than mine probably would have been. Strictly separating the practical and moral sides of the arguments was, in particular, a great idea. I do wish someone would send him more rebuttals, since I like reading take-downs of things I agree with and the only one linked there is really poor, even by the not-especially-rigorous standards of the original.

Re:London's poor fetish: commodifying working class culture by joeperks on Thursday February 26, 2015 @09:02PM (#9116768)
I find "Meditations on Moloch" intensely interesting. Thank you so much for posting this.
Re:London's poor fetish: commodifying working class culture by orbifold on Thursday February 26, 2015 @07:13PM (#9116447)
I believe the sentiment you express is shared by a large number of people, even more in the past. Maybe the Hacker community that spawned the Free Software movement is particularly aware of alternative means of production. Except for labor the amount of captital needed for software development is essentially zero, so that you do not have to attempt to reorganize ownership of capital to be successful. Already today the production of most physical things requires in many cases next to no labor, which in turn means their price should approach the manufacturing cost. In those sectors cooperative invention together with shared means of production should take over (makerspaces), because it is unprofitable for businesses to compete in those domains. The problem is that unless landownership and resource distribution is not tackled at the same time all that will probably not happen because larger parts of the population will either be deemed unnecessary or be engaged in unproductive financial games.
Re:London's poor fetish: commodifying working class culture by vacri on Thursday February 26, 2015 @09:13PM (#9116796)
Welcome to life in hell. You can get defensive and self-righteous when people point out the mass hypocrisy and delusion and error in all our lives, but it doesn't change the truth that we are all living in an awful state, as cowards and lapdogs of the hyper-capitalist system that gives us life today, even as it guarantees death in the future.

Rousing rhetoric, but it doesn't change the fact that while it's shit to be poor, it's still better to be poor now than at pretty much any previous time in known history.

A whole society of people who've sold out every heroic ideal humans have ever conceived

Which again sounds like nice and tasty demagoguery, but isn't true. We continually progress and improve on civil rights, for example.

Re:London's poor fetish: commodifying working class culture by amagumori on Friday February 27, 2015 @12:30AM (#9117330)
oh, the "$1/day is better than slavery, you should be happy!" guy. of course.
Re:London's poor fetish: commodifying working class culture by vacri on Friday February 27, 2015 @03:34AM (#9117824)
If only there was a middle-ground between the GP's grandiose demagoguery and your clumsy strawmanning, there might be some discussion that helps find a solution instead of just lobbing insults at those whom you assume are your opponents.
Re:London's poor fetish: commodifying working class culture by Retric on Thursday February 26, 2015 @06:57PM (#9116398)
Assuming that was not intended as a parity.

Capitalism does not require net growth. People, things, culture and organisations decay. People get old, Teens in 2016 are not going to dress the same, listen to the same songs, or even read the same books from the 2015. The is a long cycle of banks flat out failing in good times and in bad. Clothing, Houses, Bridges, and Roads need to be replaced etc.

Sure, in steady state economy's there is a different balance and fewer people get to retire early. However, lower returns and later retirements does not break capitalism. Just look at Japan's falling GDP.

Re:London's poor fetish: commodifying working class culture by ForHackernews on Thursday February 26, 2015 @09:37PM (#9116874)
> parity

You probably mean "parody" (they are pronounced very similarly)

Re:London's poor fetish: commodifying working class culture by semi-extrinsic on Thursday February 26, 2015 @07:03PM (#9116420)
I, for one, believe that continued economic growth needs continued growth in global energy production, and that we will be unable to maintain this growth over the next century for thermodynamic reasons. This will be the big shit-hits-the-fan moment of the coming years, not climate change or wars. We literally have to throw centuries of economics out the window.
Re:London's poor fetish: commodifying working class culture by ForHackernews on Thursday February 26, 2015 @09:43PM (#9116898)
Solar energy is essentially untapped today (relative to output from fossil fuels), and we are in no danger of exhausting the supply of nuclear fuel in the near term.[0]

Eventually global energy production will taper off, but I would bet strongly against it being within the next century.

[0] http://www.world-nuclear.org/info/Nuclear-Fuel-Cycle/Uranium...

Re:London's poor fetish: commodifying working class culture by darkmighty on Thursday February 26, 2015 @10:50PM (#9117067)
Yea, there is no "thermodynamic reason" for a limited supply of energy. Even if we started expending too much energy in the atmosphere (say if we found an efficient way to fusion), we could pump this excess heat to space, if it would ever come to such an extreme.
Re:London's poor fetish: commodifying working class culture by semi-extrinsic on Friday February 27, 2015 @08:20AM (#9118653)
I see that none of you have heard of Carnot efficiency, or even the second law of thermodynamics. Even if we were to get electric energy from magical pink unicorns that produced no heat, the usage of that energy would produce waste heat. And no, you can't just pump heat into space; if we could that would easily solve global warming.
Re:London's poor fetish: commodifying working class culture by darkmighty on Friday February 27, 2015 @10:17AM (#9119249)
Yes you can...

Constructive proof: build a large suspended reflector (mirror), put you power source on it and pump heat from earth to a sphere of any material, which radiates heat into space.

No, this of course can't easily solve global warming due to enormous cost it would have and ludicrous efficiency. It's way cheaper to just absorb less heat from the sun (less CO2).

Re:London's poor fetish: commodifying working class culture by semi-extrinsic on Friday February 27, 2015 @04:41PM (#9121536)
Sometimes it's best to do the math before claiming stuff. Now, using thermal radiation from a metal puts your emission spectrum at blackbody radiation around or below 2000 Kelvin, and in that band around 50% of your emitted energy will be absorbed by the atmosphere (thus will not leave earth). Your heat pump going from 293 K to 2000 K will have a laughably low Carnot efficiency (the highest efficiency allowed by thermodynamics): for every Joule of heat you pump from the earth to the sphere, you have to use more than 20 Joules from our magical unicorns. Of these 20 Joules, 10 will be absorbed by the atmosphere and heat the earth. But you have only removed one Joule of heat from the earth. Thus your apparatus is not able to cool the earth, in fact it will be heating the earth by a lot.
Re:London's poor fetish: commodifying working class culture by darkmighty on Friday February 27, 2015 @05:31PM (#9121790)
Who says the apparatus has to be in the low atmosphere?

What you cite are technical reasons, not thermodynamic. Thermodynamics doesn't disallow the situation, only technical reasons make it difficult.

> Sometimes it's best to do the math before claiming stuff

> I see that none of you have heard of Carnot efficiency

Sometimes it's best to get off your high horse.

Re:London's poor fetish: commodifying working class culture by semi-extrinsic on Friday February 27, 2015 @06:48PM (#9122110)
Alright, thermodynamics + not requiring magic (except the unicorns) then. Thermodynamics has everything to do with it; if it were not for the Carnot limit on heat pump efficiency, your proposed scheme for heat removal would work fine. If it were not for the Carnot limit, we would have no problem growing global energy consumption at 2-3% per year (i.e. exponentially) for a hundred more years.

So, if you put your apparatus anywhere but in the low atmosphere, how do you expect it to pump heat from the low atmosphere (where the heat is)?

I'm not on any high horse, but I'm surprised at how quickly people dismiss this problem as absurd. It's quite obvious if you know some engineering thermodynamics. I think people dismiss it out of cognitive dissonance, since they don't want another unfixable world problem.

Re:London's poor fetish: commodifying working class culture by darkmighty on Friday February 27, 2015 @09:52PM (#9122604)
> I'm not on any high horse

> people dismiss it out of cognitive dissonance

Ok then.

You are making a few claims:

1) Thermodynamics imposes a finite limit on the energy consumption on Earth;

Sure, it might be necessary to build a fleet of titanic cooling towers to cool the atmosphere, I don't think we will ever need to do that; but thermodynamics doesn't forbid cooling Earth, hence your claim is false.

That out of the way

2) The direct thermal output of power sources/uses is going to be a problem in the near future

I claim that's also false. In fact, the burden of the proof should be yours when you make such a claim, but let me show why I believe otherwise: (approximate figure from wiki [1])

142 PWh of energy was used worldwide. Solar irradiance is 340000 PWh. It would take almost 200 years of steady 3% growth (or a 240x increase in consumption) to even reach 1% of solar irradiance as internal heat. Even then, the impact of greenhouse gases massively overshadows that.

On top of that, there's no activity requiring exponentially more energy, or evidence that we may continue expanding energy demand for hundreds or years. In fact, if you look at per capita energy consumption vs GDP [2], you can clearly see a saturation of energy needs. Once the developing nations reach this, it seems demand growth is going to slow down. Nothing physical ever maintains an exponential growth for too long.

[1] http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/b/bb/The-NASA-...

[2] http://www.withouthotair.com/c30/figure242.png

Re:London's poor fetish: commodifying working class culture by amagumori on Friday February 27, 2015 @12:29AM (#9117329)
LOL, "thermodynamic reasons". citation needed
Re:London's poor fetish: commodifying working class culture by eli_gottlieb on Friday February 27, 2015 @05:27AM (#9118127)
>We could be taking a new course right now, to live in idealistic ways, in sustainable ways, in heroic ways. But we all just quit that notion before we start, because it's just too hard, and we distract ourselves with the greatest media spectacle of entertaining diversions and political issues every conceived.

Oh. You quit?

>Welcome to life in hell. You can get defensive and self-righteous when people point out the mass hypocrisy and delusion and error in all our lives, but it doesn't change the truth that we are all living in an awful state, as cowards and lapdogs of the hyper-capitalist system that gives us life today, even as it guarantees death in the future.

No, the working classes are actually revolting, because the system has guaranteed them death today.

All kinds of things are actually happening around the world to deal with humanity's problems, and here you're complaining instead of contributing.

Get back to work!

>I figure that a not-yet born post-human super-predator will take the best of human intelligence and anti-entropic principles and incorporate them, and destroy the rest. Or some already-existing higher powers will swoop in at some point in the future to harvest the best of our anti-entropic principles, and destroy the rest of us.

I'm right here, and it really boggles me why people like you keep thinking people like me would destroy you ;-).

Re:London's poor fetish: commodifying working class culture by ripb on Thursday February 26, 2015 @05:34PM (#9116031)
You've hit the nail on the head, brainpan.

>But we all just quit that notion before we start

Don't forget we also denounce and ridicule anyone who tries to live outside the system we have constructed and rely on.

Re:London's poor fetish: commodifying working class culture by littletimmy on Thursday February 26, 2015 @06:58PM (#9116402)
I find what you wrote interesting yet it sounds very alien. It is probably just my indoctrinated brain. Can you recommend any good books or readings that echo these thoughts in more depth?
Re:London's poor fetish: commodifying working class culture by ForHackernews on Thursday February 26, 2015 @09:38PM (#9116882)
Re:London's poor fetish: commodifying working class culture by JimboOmega on Thursday February 26, 2015 @06:15PM (#9116232)
I have to agree with you on the success of it as a description of culture.

People will also keep chasing what's cool and play the social signaling game, especially young, single people. When I view the article as an examination of how this evolved in an anti-consumerist era, it's actually pretty interesting.

When I view it as a critique of "work" as "showing up, doing what they have to do, then getting out and spending time with the people that they love." - or something that is not culturally, spiritually, etc, uplifting on its own, it's OKAY. Saying that pursuing faux-lower class experiences is motivated by that is kind of a touchy proposition, but it's worth examining, I suppose.

But then it ends with the derail into "the poor poor people" It almost feels like the author has to dive into the political argument at the very end, because this site has as its subtitle "reflections on a revolution".

It's an ill supported point. How does spending $10 on a cocktail in a mason jar hurt people, exactly? Maybe it's pointless, or part of an elaborate social signaling game, but it's not exploitative. Much less so than classic consumerism, I'd argue.

Re:London's poor fetish: commodifying working class culture by SideburnsOfDoom on Thursday February 26, 2015 @04:57PM (#9115823)
> Sure, we get it, the visual signifiers of the exotic have changed over the last 10 years.

Yep, and are still changing and always will. Has the author even kept up? I mean, Red Stripe? Get lost, it's craft IPA or nothing!

Re:London's poor fetish: commodifying working class culture by pjc50 on Friday February 27, 2015 @05:18AM (#9118108)
blanketly declare the lives of the middle class to be souless, meaningless, and that their jobs are bullshit

This is a traditional part of the British class system from at least the 60s onwards. There's an entire pundit industry in stating this in lifestyle supplements, pop science, and inoffensive indie music. It's something that we recite, not something actionable. It's like going to church to top up your existential guilt.

Re:London's poor fetish: commodifying working class culture by goodnights on Thursday February 26, 2015 @07:13PM (#9116452)
"What is so wrong with that?"

Ask the people that are desperately trying to convince us otherwise. I see this a lot in "tech". That new library, language or company by "hackers" that are going to change everything. Start asking about security, practicality or why they sold and you're ignored at best. Not everyone expects you to do that, so if you're actually honest your projects gets no attention.

Re:London's poor fetish: commodifying working class culture by gcb0 on Thursday February 26, 2015 @05:36PM (#9116050)
that's what an op ed should be about... it's not an academic white paper.