Every time I see this in regards to email, I'm puzzled. Carnivore was known about in the 90s. Then there was the AT&T Room 641A in the 200s. So I don't know how people were unaware that state level actors could tap connections and record email.
Second, for this threat model, just forcing and validating TLS on SMTP gets you pretty far, does it not? You're then mostly trusting your email provider. And without trusting them, we get into user-unfriendly stuff like not being able to forget your password. (Barring some sort of breakthrough ideas.)
Seriously, has there been any good proposals that provide strong privacy (say, no one but the user can read the message) but aren't complicated or require users to do things they aren't gonna do: validate keys? PGPFone and ZRTP are great because you already have an "out-of-band" key auth mechanism in place, and it's fairly straightforward to check.
Nobody should trust their email provider if they are concerned about the privacy of their email. The Job To Be Done, by an email provider such as gmail/yahoo/hotmail is to act as a mail store, and mta. A user should be able to rely on a local MUA for confidentiality. Admittedly, that shifts the level of trust from the Email Provider to the provider of the MUA software and the Local Hardware, which is why things like OpenBSD/Linux and (hopefully not firmware-tweaked) commodity hardware is so important.
I'm hoping someone comes up with a breakthrough idea here, something fantastic that enables real privacy with no inconvenience. But in 20 years, there's been essentially zero progress on that front. All proposals either violate Most Users' required features, or boil down to offloading trust to the email provider.
It can be very hard to know whether you have the right public key, especially for people that you know only from online activity. And it's not uncommon to find multiple unrevoked keys, with the same email address.
But check out https://keybase.io/mirimir. You can easily get a GnuPG key that signed proofs in my profile here, on GitHub, and on reddit. Also, the email address in my key is linked to a Gravatar that StackExchange and other sites use. So whoever I am, you can be confident that I control that GnuPG key.
Private keys are obviously an issue, but I don't really get why passwords are considered so important.
I like to use GPG when I can for communicating with people, but most of the things I put on it are less private than what you would get if you got my computer.
I don't think passwords protect you if the attacker can install a keylogger (correct me if I'm wrong), so anyone with hardware access or malware isn't going to be stopped. You are only protecting against people that can read files from your computer but not install hardware/software.
I think for the average user the password provides little extra security while having a high UI cost.
If you had to open an app on your phone at each login you'd get crazy real fast :)
I do like your analogy tho. Digital music is a breeze to buy nowadays. Moxie seems to appear as covertly saying its misguided to donate money to GnuPG so that it finally gets good, because, you know, not-moxie-made.
The.. what was it called? Redphone? Whisper? and various other projects - while very cool - didnt achieve even as much popularity as GnuPG (which in itself is far from greatly useable).
I know of one tech that has a chance right now and thats U2F/Fido. It allows for building a framework (being GnuPG or otherwise) around it that's both secure and works for everyone. Why? Because fucking gmail supports it that why. It has nothing to do with the actual tech. It has to do with support. It has to do with my iphone, android, whatever, working with it seamlessly. It a lot to do with "slapping a GUI" at the right places.
The Axolotl protocol that was created for Whisper System's TextSecure is now used, by default, by Cyanogenmod (10 million users) and the Android version of WhatsApp (more than 500 million installs from the play store).
I'd say Moxie's tech has been pretty widely adopted.
If the only "usable" implementation is on a hard-to-physically-secure mobile device that uses a tonne of different uncontrolled network access points a day -- that's not really an option now, is it?
What, Gmail? Yahoo? They exist only because they can read your plain-text email and serve ads against it. Most people get their email through free webmail providers, who have every reason not to make encryption easy.
Arguably it was easier to use GPG back then than it is now. Pine was my MUA and I had an easy to find public key. Now I have an iPhone, don't use Linux on my laptop anymore, and make heavy use of messaging products.
Here's what I have now that I didn't have then, 2FA. There's an app on my phone that makes it super easy so I use it. If I had to still carry around a separate RSA code generator I probably wouldn't.
Surely we can figure out a way to make encrypted email nearly transparently easy with the major mail providers, and the default mail apps on our laptops and and phones. Surely we can figure out a way to make a trustworthy distributed keystore.
Perhaps this will all change because before Snowden we were blissfully unaware and GPG was a cool toy unless your life was in real danger, post Snowden we're residents of a vast internet police state and my Mom knows how Target was hacked.
I have a strong suspicion we will figure this out, and soon. I wonder, are VC's are looking into funding easy to use consumer encryption?