Re:Clef Offers Two-Factor Authentication Without All the Codes
by jessepollak on Friday February 20, 2015 @12:41AM
(#9079126)
Clef actually doesn't require internet on the secondary device. We just shipped offline mode a few weeks ago: it's not as seamless as the primary flow, but it works well and solves the problem. Turn on airplane mode, sync the wave and let me know what you think.
Re:Clef Offers Two-Factor Authentication Without All the Codes
by harshreality on Friday February 20, 2015 @01:11AM
(#9079192)
So in that mode it's a proprietary alternative to FIDO that requires a camera to image the phone's screen?
A lot of work has gone into the FIDO spec to make sure it can be used across a wide range of environments. I don't see the utility of buying into a proprietary 2-factor system that seems to be solving the same problem. If you added u2f-hid support to eliminate the hack of transmitting data via pictures and cameras, wouldn't your system behave exactly like FIDO?
Isn't the natural progression for a company like Duo or Clef to pivot to being a managed FIDO 2-factor service, for organizations that want central management of 2-factor auth without creating their own management system?
Re:Clef Offers Two-Factor Authentication Without All the Codes
by G650 on Friday February 20, 2015 @01:51AM
(#9079298)
Good stuff Jesse. Excited to see where this goes.
I don't want my ability to use a system conditioned on whether my phone can connect to the internet, or whether I have a laptop with internet connectivity and a camera that can take a picture of my phone's screen. TOTP 2-factor and FIDO* are better for that reason.
Clef sounds almost exactly like a software (totally app-based) FIDO implementation without a separate password other than the PIN you'd enter into the FIDO app. FIDO needs browser support, though; Clef can't do it that way, so it requires a data back-channel to Clef servers.
* (once it catches on... tokens exist, and Chrome/chromium 39 and above supports it, but MS has only announced it for Win10, FF hasn't implemented it yet, and hardly any major sites support it other than Google)