On second reading Chomsky's quote doesn't seem as hand-wavy about the Fibonacci Sequence as it initially appeared. It's one of those topics that has such a myriad of falsehoods perpetuated around it, that perhaps I was too primed to see it here.
>Some call pseudo-science "magical" due to ignorance.
This was the sense in which I used magical, although you are right. "Magical" can be used to evoke either the vision of pseudo-scientific nonsense or "magical" in the sense of "insufficiently understood, complex, and thus awe-inspiring."
>If you haven't already read it, I think this is a pretty interesting take on it (in a sense):
I devoured A New Kind of Science when it was released because I was fascinated by emergent systems and cellular automata at the time, and have read it again about a year ago, and found it didn't hold up as well. Nevertheless excellent book, if a bit bold in its claims.
I haven't seem the follow ups, but thanks for pointing me toward them! I'll be sure to give them a read.
Apologizes if I pushed back a little hard, but rest assured my only grudge here is with misuse of the Golden Spiral, not with Prof. Chomsky and certainly not with you.
I see your point, but I'm not sure Chomsky was espousing anything magical (as in pseudo-science) by saying the Fibonacci sequence is found in nature and isn't well understood why. Present company excepted, perhaps.
I also try to keep in mind that the term "magical" is often rather amorphously applied.
Some call pseudo-science "magical" due to ignorance.
Some call some science "magical" due to ignorance.
However, some call certain science "magical" not due to ignorance, but as a respectful nod towards the vast complexities involved that we still don't know (and perhaps never will) that surround the complex "nature"[0] of science.
If you haven't already read it, I think this is a pretty interesting take on it (in a sense):
http://www.amazon.com/New-Kind-Science-Stephen-Wolfram/dp/15...
Series of followups 10 years later:
http://blog.stephenwolfram.com/2012/05/its-been-10-years-wha...
[0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Bo3R3LBjDek (Love And Rockets - "No New Tale To Tell")