News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Worst Way to Fire Someone: I Was There by choppaface on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @11:48PM (#9067026)
Is there a good way to fire people? A nice severance package and some decency are desirable. The fired employee will likely never receive what's most valuable: a thorough and actionable analysis about what went wrong. In this case the company failed, and the laid off employees will probably never thoroughly understand why. In my own experience, I've seen several engineers fired because they were mis-hired into roles that were obviously bad matches (often intentionally to meet the VP's head count goals). Those engineers weren't really given enough info to reconstruct what happened to them.

I guess the message of the article here is that Tim Armstrong dumped the full weight of failure on his team-- undesirable in the view of almost any philosophy of management. Furthermore, in light of Armstrong's experience, his acts were reckless as well.

Re:The Worst Way to Fire Someone: I Was There by tsotha on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @02:12AM (#9067368)
>The fired employee will likely never receive what's most valuable: a thorough and actionable analysis about what went wrong.

Your use of the word "actionable" is pretty appropriate here. When I was managing people my biggest frustration was not being able to sit someone down over a beer and discuss the situation honestly. Nobody gets "fired" any more. Unless you commit a felony or break one of the PC rules you get "laid off", as in "We had a good quarter, and yes we're buying lots of stuff and hiring people, but we ran out of money to pay you."

As a manager I can't very well come along later and say "Here's the real reason we let you go." Because the lawsuits would start to fly. The over-litigious employment environment (at least in the US) prevents people from learning how to be better employees. I've had people call me up months after we let them go and essentially beg me to tell them the truth. But I couldn't take that risk.

I don't manage people any more, and good riddance to that shit.

Re:The Worst Way to Fire Someone: I Was There by phkahler on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @10:03AM (#9068830)
>> As a manager I can't very well come along later and say "Here's the real reason we let you go." Because the lawsuits would start to fly.

As a manager, it's your job to do that BEFORE you have to can them. There is no reason you can't take a person aside and have a discussion. Is anything wrong? Are you OK? In my opinion your performance is lacking in area x,y,z. It's your job and it sucks to have those conversations, but don't feel bad after the fact for slacking off until it's too late. Nobody should be fired for poor performance and not have a clue as to what went wrong.

Re:The Worst Way to Fire Someone: I Was There by stickfigure on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @02:18PM (#9070384)
It doesn't always work like this. I once took over a team that had an extraordinarily unprepared developer - of the "tough time with fizzbuzz" variety. He was a nice guy, and I felt bad cutting him loose. My predecessor (who had hired him) didn't understand software development and had no way of giving him the kind of feedback that would have prepared him for this. I don't think the guy was totally surprised, and years later (when I met him randomly at a party) he said he had no hard feelings about the incident. But he sure looked disappointed at the time.
Re:The Worst Way to Fire Someone: I Was There by tsotha on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @06:24PM (#9071573)
Friend of mine took over a team which had a guy with the opposite problem (though he was a pretty nice guy too). He had the skills to do the job. Indeed, he'd been doing it for three or four years. Then one day he just decided he didn't like software development any more.

Now, a normal person would have gone one of two ways. Either they'd start looking around and find something they thought would be more interesting and then leave for whatever that was, or they'd grit their teeth and keep doing the job they didn't like because they need the paycheck and couldn't find anything that paid enough (guys with families, mostly).

This guy, though, figured the things he liked paid less, so there was no hurry to leave. But he didn't have enough personal integrity to actually do the work while he was still drawing a paycheck. So he just stopped working. He'd show up for work every day and surf the web, listen to ball games, talk on the phone, etc.

It took some time, but eventually my buddy sat him down and said "Look, you need to start actually working instead of just showing up to the office," to which the guy replied "No. You're going to have to fire me".

He made my friend grind through all the paperwork to actually fire him. It's a big company, so it took awhile. They gave him verbal warnings, written warnings, put him on a "performance plan", and eventually he was fired. It took months. He wasn't disappointed or resentful or anything. He just took his couple months of free money and waited around for the paperwork to go through.

Re:The Worst Way to Fire Someone: I Was There by tsotha on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @03:01PM (#9070607)
>As a manager, it's your job to do that BEFORE you have to can them.

Absolutely. And I did so in every case. The problem is the sort of person who's clueless enough to actually get fired is the sort of person who going to ignore what you're saying, either because they think your real problem with them is that their a woman/black/gay/old/whatever or they have a big ego that won't allow them to consider they might be doing something wrong or because they figure they have a lot more slack than they really do between "you need to shape up" and "here's a box for your stuff".

If you're actually going to fire someone for cause you need to need to have a paper trail, which would make that all official. But. If you establish a paper trail and then try to pretend you're getting rid of them because there's no money you're going to get sued. So companies usually don't go the "for cause" route at all.

Re:The Worst Way to Fire Someone: I Was There by phkahler on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @04:05PM (#9070933)
>> If you establish a paper trail and then try to pretend you're getting rid of them because there's no money you're going to get sued.

Wait what? I know you can get sued for all sorts of things, but what is the reasoning here? Is it that the given reason is money, but there is evidence that the reason is something else? So what? Would they claim you lied because you don't really have a strong case for the real reason? I'm just confused by this.

Re:The Worst Way to Fire Someone: I Was There by tsotha on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @05:30PM (#9071402)
First off put the thought that the law makes sense out of your mind. It doesn't.

Basically the outline of the suit is going to be "You always wanted to fire me because I'm black/Latino/gay/old/fat/thin/sick/whatever, so you tried to pretend I was doing a bad job. But then when it became clear I was such a good employee you couldn't do that you pretended it was an economic decision."

Now, this may or may not fly in court, but from the company's perspective it's a crap shoot, since you never know what a jury is going to do. They'll settle if they can. Which means lots of people will sue just looking for free money, even if they know it's all bullshit.

Re:The Worst Way to Fire Someone: I Was There by yuhong on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @06:36PM (#9071617)
I think anti-discrimination laws are probably fundamentally flawed. I think they should be killed, but with an exception allowing the EEOC, anti-trust or similar to order particular sets of companies to stop discrimination for a period of time if necessary.
Re:The Worst Way to Fire Someone: I Was There by kyleashipley on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @09:16AM (#9068571)
Is it possible to have the employee waive his right to a wrongful termination lawsuit? A waiver seems to be a condition of many severance packages, although I'm not sure how enforceable it is. Could thorough and actionable analysis be treated as a form of severance?

It's not a perfect solution, but I'd prefer the option if I were in that situation. The expected value of a wrongful termination suit might be less than good career advice.

Re:The Worst Way to Fire Someone: I Was There by AdmiralAsshat on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @12:01PM (#9069535)
This would likely become the employment equivalent of those fine-print "Buy ordering from our website, you agree to not write disparaging reviews of our products." policies on various web outlets. By all accounts non-enforceable, but more than likely would just be used as a bullying tactic against people who lack the funding to take it to court.
Re:The Worst Way to Fire Someone: I Was There by Someone1234 on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @10:49AM (#9069094)
Can you imagine bringing that up?

Hi, you're fired, but here sign this legally binding contract so I can tell you why you are a terrible employee.

Re:The Worst Way to Fire Someone: I Was There by john_other_john on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @11:07AM (#9069195)
long ago, when I had just a tiny company and we were essentially a friendly lot, we'd do skits once a month, competing to come up with the best reasons to fire each other, for prizes and forfeits. It was a game, but it helped among other things to relieve a lot of internal tension that might otherwise have politicized us.

About that time, or rather a few years later, reflecting on those skits, I told my cofounder, "Dude, I have come to the conclusion that lately if I worked for myself i'd have quit, and if I hired myself i'd have fired myself. What went wrong?" as a result I stepped out of management for a while, and hit the proverbial drawing board.

I can imagine now that someone would sue for this sort of thing being bullying at work, or some such rot, but the skits gave us often too much insight into the real effective personalities at our work, often in the "too much information" category, but almost invariably in good humor.

Just thought the exercise might yet benefit somebody else, still, for the mention.

Re:The Worst Way to Fire Someone: I Was There by njloof on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @05:42AM (#9067834)
What if they ask "Do you have any suggestions for how I could perform better at my next job?" That opens the door to nonspecific advice that could touch on those issues.
Re:The Worst Way to Fire Someone: I Was There by pja on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @06:28AM (#9067951)
Not really, if the fear is being sued for wrongful dismissal. If the advice is so non specific that it doesn't contain anything actionable, then it's probably not specific enough to be helpful.

Essentially, if you give the ex-employee anything concrete to work on ("You could improve on skill X"), then the fear is that they'll demand clear evidence that they were deficient in that area at your workplace, which you probably don't have. Now you've weakened your case should the employee bring a wrongful dismissal lawsuit (under whatever laws apply in your state/country). Hence the reluctance to say anything at all.

It's not right (morally), but it's understandable.

Re:The Worst Way to Fire Someone: I Was There by mkr-hn on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @09:43AM (#9068712)
This is why I'm skeptical of the value of things like ENDA. Without some higher level data collection to see trends in hiring and firing at a company, it would be hard to prove someone was fired for something other than performance since no one will even hint at a reason. Those demographic checkboxes on applications don't help if the people most likely to be targeted don't trust an employer to use it properly.
Re:The Worst Way to Fire Someone: I Was There by shit_parade on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @09:31AM (#9068650)
Reminds me of a friend who used to manage a fast food outlet, it was corporate policy to never fire anyone, they simply would schedule the person 0 hours week after week until they quit.
Re:The Worst Way to Fire Someone: I Was There by ptaipale on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @03:01AM (#9067477)
That's so true, and it's not just the US. Also, and perhaps even more so, Western Europe.
Re:The Worst Way to Fire Someone: I Was There by yuhong on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @04:22AM (#9067650)
I have been saying that the CA employee defamation laws has to be changed since Yishan Wong's comment on Reddit.
Re:The Worst Way to Fire Someone: I Was There by bphogan on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @11:42AM (#9069408)
The book Corporate Confidential talks about how this works in large companies. It states that, generally, people who get laid off are the ones who have clashes with the managers. They disagree too much, complain, gossip, etc. Has nothing to do with work performance. Always comes down to if your boss likes you. If your boss doesn't like you, you make a layoff list so the next time the company needs to downsize, you go away. Solves any issues of wrongful termination because many places are "at-will" anyway, and they can simply say "sorry, we have more people than we have work" and not ever tell you the reason why.

I recommend that book highly. As I have seen the mistakes I've made over the years and have taken steps to correct that behavior. :)

Re:The Worst Way to Fire Someone: I Was There by louischatriot on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @03:04AM (#9067483)
It doesn't have to be the case, at least not from my experience managing startup teams. The most usual case I've seen is that you have to let the employee go for performance reasons but you still have a good relationship with him and it's pretty natural to help by a) telling what was wrong and what he could improve in his new job and b) offering help to find a new job/talk to his prospective employers about what he did do right. I would even argue that even the most selfish managers should still proceed that way, since ending a relationship on a (as much as possible) positive note decreases the risk of a lawsuit afterwards.
Re:The Worst Way to Fire Someone: I Was There by ptaipale on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @04:50AM (#9067728)
I don't think there's a good way that would everywhere, in all cases, be perceived by the person in question as good. Everyone's an individual.

But some managers have more charisma, or capability to reflect compassion, or whatever it is, so that when they do the firing, it does not feel as bad. Some managers are clumsy and behave among other people's emotions like an elephant in a porcelain shop. Some are just awkward.

And then there is methodology. Corporations often have guidelines for how to do this. For instance, in the processes where I have been involved, there's been a training and emphasis on how things are done: deliver a paper of this format, do it in a personal discussion if possible, with some rehearsed phrases to get around the awkwardness. If you have to do it via mail or deliver the message otherwise, do this and that.

The bottom line is, both the personalities and consistent professional ways to do things have an impact. Still, it's often horrible. There is no guaranteed good way.

Re:The Worst Way to Fire Someone: I Was There by Terr_ on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @01:28AM (#9067279)
Very true, alas, the ways which are good for people are, regrettably, not the ways that are good for the company lawyers. In addition to the emotional/honesty difficulty of a good postmortem, there's the fear that somebody will say something to trigger a lawsuit, spurious or otherwise.
Re:The Worst Way to Fire Someone: I Was There by cookiecaper on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @05:23AM (#9067792)
It's not just about lawyers. The lawyers don't get involved until someone comes along and suggests that there may be a complaint; i.e., the people involved get alienated and offended before the lawyers enter the picture.

Most people do not take criticism well at all and in all honesty, most people don't want a big, honest list of their infractions, even if they claim they do.

Consider also that many times employment decisions are entirely petty and done just because someone in the chain of command doesn't like the "laid off" individual. There are various terms that are corpo-speak for this. Employment in an organization is really professional likeability management, which is a tricky, fickle field.

Re:The Worst Way to Fire Someone: I Was There by fnordfnordfnord on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @09:31AM (#9068648)
>The lawyers don't get involved until someone comes along and suggests that there may be a complaint

Lawyers are involved from the very beginning of a layoff. They make the template.

>most people don't want a big, honest list of their infractions, even if they claim they do.

If one's immediate supervisor is doing their job, the employee will already know what would be on the list.

Re:The Worst Way to Fire Someone: I Was There by cookiecaper on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @12:24PM (#9069692)
>Lawyers are involved from the very beginning of a layoff. They make the template.

Right, I guess I meant that lawyers don't (or maybe, didn't) become a concern until someone was disgruntled enough to make spurious legal claims. They're involved now as a preventative measure, which I acknowledge in other comments, but what I'm saying is that if people were able to take a list of infractions in stride and improve on them, companies would be much less worried about the potential legal liability incurred by given honest feedback to employees.

Re:The Worst Way to Fire Someone: I Was There by bphogan on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @11:45AM (#9069426)
This. And if you check the credentials of people in HR, you'll probably find someone there with a JD.
Re:The Worst Way to Fire Someone: I Was There by VLM on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @07:45AM (#9068191)
"somebody will say something to trigger a lawsuit"

Two topics not discussed are leaks and rationalization.

Say someone's getting fired for not being the right race, or being a woman in a mans field, or not being a bro, or not going out drinking with the boys enough after work, she wouldn't date the boss, or being too old, or too gay, or too jewish, or whatever. "Sorry its a budget thing combined with different direction of company and best of luck to you" is legally extremely safe. Happens ALL the time. But if the boss has some deep personal conversation and it leaks out that he doesn't like most black people but he hired you anyway so its clearly not race, he doth protest too much, or how it doesn't matter that she wouldn't date him despite him asking her a couple times it really was something else... Or the rationalization thing, where lets face it, he was fired because he is gay and the boss is a republican, if the boss is smart enough not to leak that topic, but sufficiently dumb enough, in a long personal conversation out will come ridiculous rationalizations about the guys LoC or bug report / fix rates or attendance as a distractor for the boss to avoid talking about homophobia, unfortunately the rationalized metrics can actually be measured and open the company to wrongful termination lawsuits. "Your honor he said the only reason was my attendance wasn't very good, but my documents prove it was the best in the office, note the only day I was gone was a scheduled vacation day for the pride parade and he's out of the office continually attending fund raisers for anti-gay marriage republican candidates" etc etc. Usually that kind of stuff is settled expensively out of court with non-disparagement clauses so future employees can't avoid predatory bosses, which is another problem.

You can pretty much assume if "they" won't tell you why you're fired, and you can't obviously figure it out, then it was some illegal thing like above and they're smart enough not to provide lawsuit fodder on a platter.

Ya gotta realize that half of management is by definition below median, and that half of the population can create very expensive lawsuits.

Re:The Worst Way to Fire Someone: I Was There by travisby on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @08:30AM (#9068362)
Ya gotta realize that half of employees are by definition below median. You missed the possibility that the employee is too prideful, or lacks the intelligence to 'obviously figure it out.'

Please don't generalize about a group of people (either managers, or republicans). Employees can be bad, too.

Re:The Worst Way to Fire Someone: I Was There by VLM on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @08:39AM (#9068405)
"Ya gotta realize that half of employees are by definition below median."

Nah, we only hire Rockstar Ninjas who are a perfect cultural fit only 4.0+ GPAs and only ivy league grads need apply. And they need 10 years experience in some library where the github repo is only 3 years old. Everyone hires like that and complains there's no workers.

Management aren't hired to standards as high, so yeah, half are going to be below median.

Re:The Worst Way to Fire Someone: I Was There by tsotha on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @03:19PM (#9070698)
>You can pretty much assume if "they" won't tell you why you're fired, and you can't obviously figure it out, then it was some illegal thing like above and they're smart enough not to provide lawsuit fodder on a platter.

If you ever had any experience managing people you'd know this isn't true. Employment law is a minefield, and managers aren't usually lawyers. If you're a manager and it's time to cut someone loose your boss will tell you "don't say anything beyond x, y, and z", as in "tell them we're having layoffs and they're out. Tell them their remaining vacation time will get cashed out. Tell them about COBRA. If they ask anything about performance, reiterate they're being laid off because the company is downsizing, and nobody should assume performance is involved."

This is true no matter what the situation is, from there being a real shortage of money to performance problems.

>...he was fired because he is gay and the boss is a republican...

I always wonder what's wrong with people that they can write something like this. I'm a Republican and I've had gay people work for me. There are probably millions of gay people working for Republicans who aren't scheming to fire them at this very moment.

As a manager, I figure your sexuality is none of my business unless you force the people around you to deal with it. And that's true no matter how you're oriented.