News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Software Revolution by enraged_camel on Monday February 16, 2015 @01:56PM (#9058491)
>>While I doubt this would happen to me as a software engineer, I would certainly rather work and have my dignity than sit on my ass, collect basic income, and feel worthless.

Actually, you say that because you are a software engineer: it's quite a dignified job. Digging ditches out in the desert is not.

Re:The Software Revolution by HeyLaughingBoy on Monday February 16, 2015 @02:36PM (#9058752)
I assure you this is not a troll, I'm trying to figure out your thought process.

How is one dignified and the other not?

Re:The Software Revolution by yellowapple on Monday February 16, 2015 @05:16PM (#9059395)
Because the latter is pointless when there already exist tools better suited to that task?

The efforts of those road workers are effectively meaningless. Worthless. Moot. Their efforts would be better expended elsewhere - service jobs, creative occupations, the like - yet here they are, digging ditches for subsistence wages (at best) instead of doing something properly meaningful with their time on Earth and their energy.

The idea in places like India that manual labor takes precedent is a symptom - I'd argue - of exposure to the lingering remnants of a very long-lived caste system; instead of pushing these laborers into more useful fields, there's a preference to relegate them to menial, worthless work under the guise of "public service" or "charity" in order to reinforce that system, whether deliberately or perhaps unconsciously. I can assure you that, of the many reasons to emphasize such manual labor, "dignity" of the laborers is not one of them in this case.