News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:6to5 (ES6 transpiler) is now renamed Babel by sebastianmck on Sunday February 15, 2015 @08:40AM (#9052567)
See https://github.com/babel/babel/issues/568 for why this name change happened.
Re:6to5 (ES6 transpiler) is now renamed Babel by wildpeaks on Sunday February 15, 2015 @07:56AM (#9052485)
The website still points to https://github.com/6to5/6to5 yet the link now redirects to https://github.com/babel/babel.

Good move because even if it started with ES6, it now supports more (e.g. some ES7 features and JSX) so the name didn't fit anymore.

Re:6to5 (ES6 transpiler) is now renamed Babel by sebastianmck on Sunday February 15, 2015 @08:31AM (#9052553)
Haven't finished the rename yet.
Re:6to5 (ES6 transpiler) is now renamed Babel by fermigier on Sunday February 15, 2015 @08:17AM (#9052521)
There's a well-known, widely used, Python project called Babel (http://babel.pocoo.org/).

I find it quite annoying when people name their project without consideration for other people in the open source community.

Other historical examples include Mozilla Firebird, which was renamed to Thunderbird after loud complains of the Firebird database community, or Twitter's Fabric, which clashes with Fabric (http://www.fabfile.org/), another Python project.

Re:6to5 (ES6 transpiler) is now renamed Babel by sgentle on Sunday February 15, 2015 @08:37AM (#9052563)
I don't think it's as inconsiderate as you imply. Babel (as in tower of) is a fairly well known biblical reference that I'd expect to find used in all sorts of project names related to translation.

Indeed, a quick googling shows there's a Python Babel, an Eclipse Babel, an Emacs Babel, a TeX Babel, a Babel language, and an Open Babel for chemistry. I'm sure the addition of this new JS Babel won't inconvenience anyone too much.

If anything, I think the real issue is open source projects overplaying their hand and insisting they own certain words or ideas that they have no real claim to, particularly when there isn't any actual chance of confusion. The Firebird renaming wasn't so much sensible precedent as a good example of a Mozilla saying "okay please stop yelling, we'll do whatever you want".

Re:6to5 (ES6 transpiler) is now renamed Babel by rspeer on Sunday February 15, 2015 @09:49AM (#9052714)
I recall there have been multiple, incompatible tools for managing gettext-style translation files called "Rosetta".
Re:6to5 (ES6 transpiler) is now renamed Babel by fermigier on Sunday February 15, 2015 @08:57AM (#9052600)
1) "I'd expect to find used in all sorts of project names related to translation."

Indeed, except that this project has nothing to do with i18n like (most of) the other projects you are citing. This is a compiler project, not a multilinguistic project.

2) There is nothing called "Python Babel", it's just called "Babel".

Eclipse Babel (https://eclipse.org/babel/) is called "Eclipse Babel" so there is no name clash.

For some of the other projects, you have a (minor) point.

3) "The Firebird renaming wasn't so much sensible precedent as a good example of a Mozilla saying "okay please stop yelling, we'll do whatever you want"."

Mozilla had a much stronger reason to comply than just goodwill and being fair: the other party had a trademark (see: http://www.firebirdsql.org/en/firebird-brand-faq/ ).

4) The considerate thing to do would have been to call the project "Babeljs".

Re:6to5 (ES6 transpiler) is now renamed Babel by sebastianmck on Sunday February 15, 2015 @08:39AM (#9052566)
Not really true. Babel is a generic term for translation/languages and the Python and JavaScript world are very different so confusion about a translation library and a JavaScript transpiler is extremely unlikely.
Re:6to5 (ES6 transpiler) is now renamed Babel by hk__2 on Sunday February 15, 2015 @09:35AM (#9052690)
It becomes confusing if you use Python and JavaScript in the same project, which is common in Web applications.
Re:6to5 (ES6 transpiler) is now renamed Babel by mg74 on Sunday February 15, 2015 @11:09AM (#9052965)
Hardly, 6to5 isn't a library that you include in your own code. Its a tool that you use indirectly through Gulp/Browserify/WebPack.
Re:6to5 (ES6 transpiler) is now renamed Babel by petepete on Sunday February 15, 2015 @09:30AM (#9052674)
Firebird was actually renamed to Firefox and was previously known as Phoenix.
Re:6to5 (ES6 transpiler) is now renamed Babel by jarcane on Sunday February 15, 2015 @08:31AM (#9052551)
I was wondering about this today; it makes sense to change the name eventually anyway. Once ES6 starts being implemented more widely by actual browsers, the old remit is likely to be obsolete.
Re:6to5 (ES6 transpiler) is now renamed Babel by norswap on Sunday February 15, 2015 @09:24AM (#9052660)
2015 most original project name award.
Re:6to5 (ES6 transpiler) is now renamed Babel by albeva on Sunday February 15, 2015 @08:24AM (#9052540)
so how is this different from say TypeScript?
Re:6to5 (ES6 transpiler) is now renamed Babel by thomasfoster96 on Sunday February 15, 2015 @08:31AM (#9052552)
Typescript is a language that compiles to javascript, adding some features.

6to5 (now Babel) compiles javascript with Ecmascript 6 and 7 features (poorly supported) to JavaScript code that only uses Ecmascript 5 features (which all major browsers since 2011 have supported).

Re:6to5 (ES6 transpiler) is now renamed Babel by itsbits on Sunday February 15, 2015 @08:29AM (#9052546)
once browsers/JS engines supports ES6/ES7, we don't need babel. But thats not the case with Typescript. But we never know. Babel may start supporting ES8. It can be never ending process.
Re:6to5 (ES6 transpiler) is now renamed Babel by stupidcar on Sunday February 15, 2015 @10:27AM (#9052837)
I'm sure Babel will be supporting ES8 and beyond. The rename wasn't just about ES6/ES7 confusion, I believe, but to reflect the expanded ambition of the project to be a general transpiler from the edge ES version to the version with the widest browser and Node.js/io.js support.

However, TypeScript's goals aren't as different as you might think. It is a strict superset of JavaScript, and although it adds features that are not yet on the standards track, there are proposals to add optional static typing via annotations to JS. Given that Google are also interested in such a capability, given Dart and AtScript, it seems probable that types will eventually become part of the language.

Re:6to5 (ES6 transpiler) is now renamed Babel by itsbits on Sunday February 15, 2015 @10:48AM (#9052902)
agreed. But don't think Dart will last long considering Angular community went for a new AtScript over Dart...Also I am preferring to use Babel is in future I can remove that dependency which not the case with TypeScript or AtScript..