Re:How I Taught My Computer to Write Its Own Music
by cturner on Saturday February 14, 2015 @05:38AM
(#9049305)
It is not just western audiences. Pentatonic is cross-cultural.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jpvfSOP2slk
A good way to find new ideas for music that people will care about listening to is to go back to the pentatonic system, and find new variations to take from there.
Re:How I Taught My Computer to Write Its Own Music
by bane on Sunday February 15, 2015 @01:13PM
(#9053409)
A particularly beautiful example Mr. McFerrin does with various audiences.
To me, while the project seemed interesting to work on, and most people would call the music beautiful, it doesn't really amount to what it's purported to represent.
Another (to me) important point: a lot of the compositions, with some notable exceptions, don't stray far from the pentatonic scale – or the individual elements are pentatonic in relation to themselves. The pentatonic scale is 5 notes that, to western audiences, always sound relatively pleasing in relation to the other 4. You could play something literally completely random in a pentatonic scale (perhaps with certain broad rhythmic restrictions), and western audiences would enjoy it. If anything, I think this is just evidence that the process was actually carefully shaped at every step of the way by human tastes and intuition. The computer was truly more of a servant than a collaborator.