The Nest appears to only be a photoelectric smoke detector based on a quick googling right now.
In my house, I have 5 photoelectric alarms that are hooked up to my central alarm system that is centrally monitored. I also have 4 ionization alarms that are hard wired together such that if one goes off they all go off. The ionization are not hooked up to the central alarm system because they have a reputation of having more false alarms. I have never experienced a false alarm in 5 years, but that is their reputation so many experts recommend not making them hooked up to a system that alerts a central monitoring service.
More Info: http://www.nfpa.org/safety-information/for-consumers/fire-an...
As a guy who regularly rides a big red truck to people's houses after their cooking pan gets a little too hot and smokey... thank you.
In the northeast US this weekend we will be having a high temperature of zero degrees Fahrenheit in some areas. I don't want to rely on a flaky device determining if the heat should be on. What happens if the temp drops really low, like with a power failure? Did they test that?
Same can be said for smoke detectors. A lot of new construction houses have all the smoke detectors wired by electricity with 9v battery backup. One goes off, they all go off. Sure there can be device failures, but you're talking about something that has been around for a long time with a proven track record.
If anything, maybe keep the old tech devices running and use the new tech along side it to see how it works.
What's scarier is the thermostat going down at inopportune times. Last January Nest pushed a firmware update that bricked some units...right during the coldest night of the year for us. My early adopter neighbor was up at 2am rewiring his old Honeywell dial to keep his family warm.
(so there is a sense in which it isn't necessarily a smart home type of feature, it doesn't need a great deal of integration or whatever, and will work with any dumb thermostat)
*I work with commercial building automation controls, it's pretty useful tech, but nothing I would ever risk my welfare on.
Now, this is just fantastic. It's what basically every movie portrays when they want to show a security station, but it is almost unheard of.
Ionization smoke detectors have a high false-positive rate in areas like kitchens where you have a lot of particulate matter. Use a photoelectric there.
http://www.consumerreports.org/cro/co-and-smoke-alarms/buyin...
For some reason I thought it would be a good idea to get their smoke detector. One day it randomly detects smoke and will not shut the hell up about it even after resetting, replacing batteries, etc. Nest offered to replace it - I just put my old "dumb" detector back up.
I will say it's pretty damn embarrassing to buy this stuff and have it fail so spectacularly, at least my roommate wasn't here to see me seriously losing my mind trying to shut up the Protect.