Re:RapidShare is Shutting down
by throwawayaway on Wednesday February 11, 2015 @05:48PM
(#9036212)
torrents are a reasonable solution for sharing those kind of programs.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:RapidShare is Shutting down
by JoshTriplett on Wednesday February 11, 2015 @05:50PM
(#9036221)
Not really; nothing guarantees that someone keeps seeding them forever.
Re:RapidShare is Shutting down
by jsprogrammer on Wednesday February 11, 2015 @07:52PM
(#9036707)
Nothing guarantees that anything keeps serving files forever. BT at least distributes responsibility and allows anyone to easily keep the files hosted.
I've often wondered if Freenet, or a similar encrypted network file system would be a viable solution. This, of course, requires a significant number of computers to contribute full time.
Re:RapidShare is Shutting down
by jsprogrammer on Wednesday February 11, 2015 @10:05PM
(#9037139)
What's wrong with BT? It can operate encrypted and has the DHT to address/discover content.
AFAIK Freenet is basically a cache with no incentive system, so content will expire. There are some cryptocurrency-oriented storage projects but they all seem to be in way over their heads.
I think the fundamental economics for a cryptocurrency approach don't lean towards preserving obscure things that don't interest many people. Storage cost is always going to be proportional to the amount of data being stored, but income is always going to be proportional to the number of people who want the data.
In Freenet content will expire unless it's accessed regularly. If you want to make sure your files are around, just poll them every other week (which may or may not be already supported by the software), which is a simple "proof of work" scheme:
As long as you care, the files are reasonably safe to be around. When you (and everyone else) stops caring, they'll slowly disappear in favour of more popular stuff.
Re:RapidShare is Shutting down
by thisjepisje on Wednesday February 11, 2015 @05:58PM
(#9036269)
"Reasonable", not "absolutely infallible".
Unseeded torrents are pretty common, especially for less popular items.
In my experience, unseeded torrents are less common than Rapidshare links that have been removed by their user or taken down after being reported.
However, I've never gathered statistics on it, so this is purely anecdotal.
I'd expect a team like xda-developers to run a seed of their content; it's the best way to make sure it is still available.
the point is that a service like rapidshare doesn't cost the user any money (and instead, get ads). Running a torrent server is expensive, and require dedicated hardware too. You can't really seed from the webhost after all.
The user can use seedboxes, they're far from being as difficult to use as dedicated hardware. They sometimes have some free tier that I expect would be more than enough for a team like xda-developers (think 5GB). It's true that they wouldn't be able to earn money through this, though.
You can seed from regular webhosts - as long as it's a regular http query to a regular http server, not some temporary http query hidden behind several layers of interstitial ads for the premium account.