News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:An Exemption to the DMCA Would Let Game Fans Keep Abandon... by exelius on Tuesday February 10, 2015 @11:13AM (#9028043)
Many of these abandoned games are effectively orphan works. I think if anything, there needs to be a definition of "digital orphan works", because digital IP suffers from bit rot in a way traditional media doesn't.

A 50 year old book is still there, but even a 10 year old game might not even be available for purchase anywhere (and even if it is, it's probably not immediately playable on modern hardware).

Fundamentally, we need to overhaul copyright in light of the fundamental changes to intellectual property sales brought about by digital goods. I'm not optimistic that it will happen, but for a shitty game to be copyrighted for 100 years is just ludicrous. At some point, things need to pass into the public domain.

Re:An Exemption to the DMCA Would Let Game Fans Keep Abandon... by jarcane on Tuesday February 10, 2015 @11:36AM (#9028196)
My rule of thumb is, generally, "Is the creator still earning from this product," and in the vast majority of cases where gaming software is concerned the answer is no. There is a push through sites like GOG.com to put many old games back on sale, but often it's through middle-men and holding companies and I doubt a dime of some of the more obscure titles goes anywhere near anyone who actually helped create the things.

The result is assorted holding companies picking up a few extra pennies, but a huge range of more obscure works are still the domain of abandonware sites and efforts like the Archive.

Re:An Exemption to the DMCA Would Let Game Fans Keep Abandon... by furyg3 on Tuesday February 10, 2015 @11:56AM (#9028333)
"Is the creator still earning from this product" is a test that congress believes doesn't matter.

Walt is dead, Mickey lives on (with copyright restrictions)...

Re:An Exemption to the DMCA Would Let Game Fans Keep Abandon... by basseq on Tuesday February 10, 2015 @01:40PM (#9028994)
This also isn't an apt comparison, because no one is claiming that enthusiasts should own the copyright to Mario Kart.

A better comparison would be Steamboat Willie, but even that is confusing because copyright is so caught up with trademark Disney characters. IANAL, but it seems to be that Disney should be able to have exclusive ownership over Mickey the character, but not the work in which he first appeared. (Which muddies the water, I know.) Does Disney make any significant money off Steamboat Willie? (They actually might, given its culture status, I just don't know.)

Re:An Exemption to the DMCA Would Let Game Fans Keep Abandon... by smacktoward on Tuesday February 10, 2015 @02:25PM (#9029300)
An even better comparison would be if the only way Disney would let you view Steamboat Willie in a Disney-owned-and-operated facility. Like, they'll sell you a ticket or a DVD or a download, but in all cases you have to bring it to a Disney facility to actually play it back. And then one day Disney closes all the facilities, and now you have some copy of the work without any legal way to view it.

Which, if you accept the analogy, brings the situation pretty close to the one addressed by U.S. v. Paramount Pictures in 1948 (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Paramount_Pict...), which ended the practice of studios owning their own theaters and refusing to show their pictures anywhere else.

Re:An Exemption to the DMCA Would Let Game Fans Keep Abandon... by DanTheManPR on Tuesday February 10, 2015 @02:43PM (#9029393)
You can still buy Steamboat Willie on DVD. Using it as an example is sort of problematic, because it is not an orphaned work, and a lot of people don't see the problem with Disney maintaining control over it. A better example would be the many orphaned animated features from the late 20's and 30's who languish in legal limbo instead of being released into the public domain (if you can't think of any examples, that's a symptom of the problem more than anything else).
Re:An Exemption to the DMCA Would Let Game Fans Keep Abandon... by dublinben on Tuesday February 10, 2015 @05:10PM (#9030267)
>You can still buy Steamboat Willie on DVD

On an expensive (~$100), out-of-print DVD, only released in 2005. The work has been orphaned for far more of its lifetime than it has been available.

Re:An Exemption to the DMCA Would Let Game Fans Keep Abandon... by bufordsharkley on Tuesday February 10, 2015 @10:52PM (#9031479)
Well, that's the Disney Vault in action. (Which is a legitimate release strategy, and it's hard to claim that Disney doesn't generally try to keep its historical works available. I imagine it'll be re-released at some point in the future.)
Re:An Exemption to the DMCA Would Let Game Fans Keep Abandon... by nitrogen on Wednesday February 11, 2015 @12:04PM (#9033967)
...it seems to be that Disney should be able to have exclusive ownership over Mickey the character...

I have to disagree with this on cultural grounds. Part of the reason that copyright expires is to fertilize the ground from which new stories are grown. Shakespeare does not own Romeo. Dickens does not own Scrooge. To the extent that Mickey has become a part of our cultural mythos, Disney should not own Mickey.

The only reasonable expectation a creator should have after a reasonably short copyright term is protection from malicious misattribution and defamation. Everything else in the last century of IP law is implemented completely wrong, in my opinion.

Re:An Exemption to the DMCA Would Let Game Fans Keep Abandon... by zanny on Tuesday February 10, 2015 @04:57PM (#9030208)
Super Mario Kart was released for the SNES in 1992. I would absolutely argue that it should be in the public domain by now. I would also argue that Mario Kart 8 should be as well, and I'd argue you should not have copyright at all.
Re:An Exemption to the DMCA Would Let Game Fans Keep Abandon... by dingaling on Tuesday February 10, 2015 @02:43PM (#9029391)
And the actual creator of Mickey is also long dead...

Walt Disney was given a crash-course by his artists so that he could draw a passable Mickey face when kids met him and asked him to do so.

Re:An Exemption to the DMCA Would Let Game Fans Keep Abandon... by michaelbuddy on Tuesday February 10, 2015 @05:54PM (#9030466)
I'd be interested in the source for this. I can see Walt having to relearn the newer Mickey style, kids only know the movies from the past 5 years anyway, but I'm pretty sure he drew the original ones. There's a lot of evidence for Ub Iwerks's really making the Disney empire's early important innovations happen in terms of animation but it wasn't like Walt was talentless at drawing.
Re:An Exemption to the DMCA Would Let Game Fans Keep Abandon... by toxican on Tuesday February 10, 2015 @12:21PM (#9028492)
I think they define creator as Disney the company rather than Disney the man.
Re:An Exemption to the DMCA Would Let Game Fans Keep Abandon... by smacktoward on Tuesday February 10, 2015 @03:52PM (#9029822)
Which is convenient, since Disney-the-company will never die, and need not have any actual human connection to Disney-the-man-who-actually-created-the-intellectual-property. So it provides a mechanism for people other than the person who created the work or his heirs/designated beneficiaries to profit from his work forever.

Defining "creators" as actual human beings provides a useful marker for how long a copyright is useful: at some point that human dies, and then at some point later his heirs die, and then at some point later their heirs die, etc. So you can look at the question in terms of how many generations should have a monopoly on their forefathers' works. Defining corporations as creators takes that marker away.

Re:An Exemption to the DMCA Would Let Game Fans Keep Abandon... by pbhjpbhj on Tuesday February 10, 2015 @07:32PM (#9030853)
Copyright protects the works of natural persons, not corporations. It protects the individual creators when they make a work; they can of course immediately assign their rights to the company, eg by a work-for-hire arrangement, but [co-]creators are always natural persons.

http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17/201

Re:An Exemption to the DMCA Would Let Game Fans Keep Abandon... by delecti on Tuesday February 10, 2015 @12:35PM (#9028582)
Sure, but there's a difference between selling copies of something and pirating it for personal use. Maybe not legally, but in my opinion at least morally, and also you're much less likely to get noticed for doing the latter.
Re:An Exemption to the DMCA Would Let Game Fans Keep Abandon... by daktanis on Tuesday February 10, 2015 @12:25PM (#9028520)
Disney's legal team has big pockets to make sure they dont lose copyrights
Re:An Exemption to the DMCA Would Let Game Fans Keep Abandon... by firebones on Tuesday February 10, 2015 @11:22PM (#9031552)
I tried running this to ground with some old Applesoft and Integer Basic games, even going so far as to contact the original author of a particular work for which I had the Basic listing, but which had been sold multiple times across an ocean or two, and presumably resided in the possession of some rolled up big name gaming concern. (Think: 1981 through a succession of things that ended up 20+ years later in TakeTwo.)

Even then I didn't feel comfortable creating a derivative work. The creator wasn't earning money (he was paid off in the 1980s when he sold it, although it was clearly his pride and joy), and the brand of the legal derivatives faded from favor over the years due to technology improvements.

You can find a lot of these types of games in the recently-released distro of DiscoRunner [1], an Integer Basic/Applesoft Basic interpreter. I love that these games and their source is preserved, although as someone who respects IP rights of creators, I always feel a twinge when I see someone's REM statement with a copyright and their name on it scrolling by when I do a LIST command.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9026865

Re:An Exemption to the DMCA Would Let Game Fans Keep Abandon... by sehugg on Tuesday February 10, 2015 @12:26PM (#9028528)
There's kind of a circular dependency here, since several companies use emulators developed by enthusiast reverse-engineers to package their games for resale: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DOSBox#Usage
Re:An Exemption to the DMCA Would Let Game Fans Keep Abandon... by danielweber on Tuesday February 10, 2015 @01:49PM (#9029049)
Section 1201, starting with subsection (d), contains a bunch of exceptions to copyright law. The reverse-engineering section is of particular interest.

http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17/1201

It's summarized as such:

This exception permits circumvention, and the development of technological means for such circumvention, by a person who has lawfully obtained a right to use a copy of a computer program for the sole purpose of identifying and analyzing elements of the program necessary to achieve interoperability with other programs, to the extent that such acts are permitted under copyright law.

Re:An Exemption to the DMCA Would Let Game Fans Keep Abandon... by soperj on Tuesday February 10, 2015 @02:07PM (#9029175)
So this means that you can circumvent encryption for dvds/bluray to get them working on linux ect. (for Tv shows[often called Tv Programs] anyway)
Re:An Exemption to the DMCA Would Let Game Fans Keep Abandon... by schoen on Tuesday February 10, 2015 @02:49PM (#9029428)
So far the entertainment industry has not accepted the view that DVDs or Blu-ray discs are "a copy of a computer program", so they continue to deny that the §1201(f) exemption will protect you in this context.
Re:An Exemption to the DMCA Would Let Game Fans Keep Abandon... by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday February 10, 2015 @03:37PM (#9029730)
You're talking about §1201(f)(1):

  Notwithstanding the provisions of subsection (a)(1)(A), a person who has lawfully obtained the right to use a copy of a computer program may circumvent a technological measure that effectively controls access to a particular portion of that program for the sole purpose of identifying and analyzing those elements of the program that are necessary to achieve interoperability of an independently created computer program with other programs, and that have not previously been readily available to the person engaging in the circumvention, to the extent any such acts of identification and analysis do not constitute infringement under this title.
That doesn't seem particularly relevant to making a Linux DVD player, not only because it only applies to computer programs as works but because it only authorizes circumvention for reverse engineering and only applies to circumvention rather than circumvention tools. I would have thought the interesting part was §1201(f)(2):

  Notwithstanding the provisions of subsections (a)(2) and (b), a person may develop and employ technological means to circumvent a technological measure, or to circumvent protection afforded by a technological measure, in order to enable the identification and analysis under paragraph (1), or for the purpose of enabling interoperability of an independently created computer program with other programs, if such means are necessary to achieve such interoperability, to the extent that doing so does not constitute infringement under this title.
Why wouldn't that apply when you're independently creating a computer program (Linux DVD player/library) that needs to have interoperability with another program (DVD player microcode)?
Re:An Exemption to the DMCA Would Let Game Fans Keep Abandon... by Cogito on Tuesday February 10, 2015 @06:49PM (#9030693)
off topic

Just a small request, if you are going to use indentation to quote a piece of text, please insert line breaks manually.

Otherwise the text is rendered as one long line, or in some cases as full width paragraphs, which make them very hard to read even on a full size monitor let alone a mobile device.

My personal preference is to italicise quoted text, but that is up to you!

off topic

EDIT - perhaps this is something that can be improved with the new UI that is slowly being rolled out, as it really shouldn't remain an issue for comment posters.

Re:An Exemption to the DMCA Would Let Game Fans Keep Abandon... by Arwill on Tuesday February 10, 2015 @04:13PM (#9029941)
The MPEG2/MPEG4 are compressed streams of a program that generates motion images. The codecs are the interpreters for that program.
Re:An Exemption to the DMCA Would Let Game Fans Keep Abandon... by sp332 on Tuesday February 10, 2015 @11:24AM (#9028107)
I think consumers need more protections than that. A game that's only a few years old might have the servers shut down in order to force players to buy the next version. The proposed exemption would let fans set up their own servers and keep playing the old version immediately.
Re:An Exemption to the DMCA Would Let Game Fans Keep Abandon... by exelius on Tuesday February 10, 2015 @11:34AM (#9028172)
Right, but I think a patch on an existing law is maybe not enough. We need a thorough re-examination of intellectual property. I'm not holding my breath though; as long as the conversation about IP is driven by big media, rules are only going to get more restrictive, not less.
Re:An Exemption to the DMCA Would Let Game Fans Keep Abandon... by TheDong on Tuesday February 10, 2015 @11:57AM (#9028340)
> A 50 year old book is still there

Actually, not so much. The 120 years + life copyright on books means that only the good / famous books last. There are tons of books that were published pre-digital-age but are still under copyright and are just dying a slow death.

Re:An Exemption to the DMCA Would Let Game Fans Keep Abandon... by benologist on Tuesday February 10, 2015 @12:14PM (#9028441)
Their public domain status is a different issue to their preservation - books exist, are bought, traded, gifted etc centuries after they're printed, copyright or not.