I submitted this story because peervpn looks like the easiest to setup by a wide margin. No certs required and very easy to start on a new machine.
To connect to other nodes, it uses either IP(v4 or v6) or Ethernet Frames. See: https://github.com/cjdelisle/cjdns#3-connect-your-node-to-yo...
I'm working on a Django Rest Framework frontend for it, Cirque: https://github.com/jMyles/cirque, which will make this easier to visualize.
Fortunately, CJDNS works for this use case as well. It is possible to use a "tunnel" to connect CJDNS nodes via an IPv4 virtual interface or to connect to a gateway to IPv4. This way, IPv4 software can connect both to other nodes and to the outside internet.
At the moment, I believe that this is only configurable through the UDP admin interface, but this is most definitely a feature that we'll build into Cirque.
https://github.com/cjdelisle/cjdns/blob/master/admin/README....
If I use CJDNS to do this, it seems like I have a lot more steps to do. I have to copy everyone's pub key and setup ipv4 tunneling on each server?
With PeerVPN all I have to do is pick a single password and copy and paste it to each other server while only needing to change the static IP.
It's actively updated, and the software used for Project Meshnet. You can join the Hyperboria network, or just connect all of your computers isolatedly. I have it running on the computers I manage, from tiny OpenWRT routers to big servers.
I did the switch from tinc because certificates are a pain to generate and distribute, and because of security concerns: http://www.tinc-vpn.org/security/