Say that the initial offering is for 10 million shares at $20 a share. Then the price pops to $30. That $30 share price is based on a much smaller net influx of investment. It does not follow that you could have sold 10 million of shares at that price. The $20 price is a discount that is needed to make the market clear a very large number of shares, all at once. Furthermore, the pop to $30 only happened because retail investors know that the institutions buying into the IPO are reputable, long-haul investors like Fidelity, who will not be dumping the stock immediately. So if you don't have Fidelity and other reputable investors putting in money at $20, you will never get the pop to $30. And because of their size and reputation and relationships, institutions like Fidelity will be able to command discounts, like any big buyer can. The IPO-ing company generally needs Fidelity much more Fidelity needs to buy the company's stock. Thus Fidelity can command the discount.
From the article: "The first trade was 15% of all of the shares offered during the pricing."
Institutional investors "consistently flip a much larger percentage of the shares allocated to them than do retail customers."[1]
I definitely side with the companies more than investment banks in this scenario, and if you assume it was priced $5 too high, FB saw an extra $2.1B from setting the price 'too high'. Given that their price has doubled since then, I think most investors have forgiven them for their sins.
Note that the founders who sell into an IPO tend to hold onto a lot more stock than they sell, so they're not solely concerned with getting the best price at the IPO. Do you think when FB cratered after the IPO Mark Zuckerberg was smiling because he got a great price for the shares he sold?
Even Google wasn't smart or powerful enough to beat the system. They tried to do an auction instead of a regular IPO, but at the last minute large investors threatened to pull out, so Google IPOed at $85 and popped 17%.
Yes, as a matter of fact, that's exactly what I think, and I don't blame him a bit or even think that's a bad thing at all.
You're framing it as the alternative being that the stock price is the same on the first day and doesn't crater. The actual alternative is that Mark sells his shares for the depressed price.
But my point was more that the institutional investors want a low IPO price and have the power to make an IPO fail if they don't get it, the banks running the IPO want a low price to make the investors happy, and the founders selling into an IPO have the least power and also have mixed incentives about the price.
Facebook actually did okay. The underwriters had to step in to support the stock price after the IPO, which actually implies that it was over-priced. Somewhat embarrassing for the underwriters but great for Facebook!
There were a spate of companies that did actually use the Dutch auction process around the Dot-com boom (e.g. Overstock) but it wasn't popular with institutional investors[3].
If you're interested in the topic, I'd recommend Information Markets by William J. Wilhelm Jr. and Joseph D. Dowling (Harvard Business School Press, 2001).
1: http://news.cnet.com/Google-slashes-IPO-price/2100-1024_3-53...
2: http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=newsarchive&sid=ayLEX...
Sure, it can be done. But everything will be more difficult. And you'll have to do a lot more of that work yourself. And potentially mess it up. And potentially be sued when things go bad. The $ savings just turn into $ risk.
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/articles/A10478-2004Aug...
A company like GrubHub, with much less name recognition than Google, is much more reliant on a bank helping to market their IPO, and in a worse position to try an auction.
There are a lot of interests in the IPO. perceiving "leaving money on the table" assumes the most important interest is the company's balance sheet.
Institutional investors would shy away from stock that had no potential upside to it, so getting this price right to attract the right kind of buyers (long term buyers decrease volatility ) but still maximize the cash to the company needs a process to find equilibrium rather than a maximizing strategy.
Ultimately the shareholders benefit more from a positive momentum on the stock rather than optimizing the price at the moment of the IPO
In addition to that, a company's goal in any fundraising effort should not necessarily be to get-the-most-money possible, but rather to balance: (1) getting the amount of money it needs to accomplish its goals/objective over a given period of time vs. (2) the control/ownership it will have to give up in exchange for that amount of money.
There may be times where the company achieves that optimization but there is still "money on the table" which is fine since the company achieved its objective, which is the definition of success.