Taxing people who don't vaccinate their children has got to be the easiest way to pour gasoline on the libertarian fire.
I don't see why; if we can quantify the average economic cost to others of you not vaccinating your children, then by charging that to people who don't vaccinate, we are merely increasing the efficiency of the free market by removing an externality. That's about as Libertarian as you can get.
I'm betting once there is even a small tax on skipping out, most of this nonsense will vanish like smoke.