You can stop kids from entering public schools without them, sure! But how far do you want to take this?
Public schools, universities is a good first step.
Well the 0th step if you wish is to not accept their argument during discourse on equal footing. As in "it is a free country and your crazy opinion is just as valid as well established science, now let's discuss".
So treating them like crazies is important, they are to be made fun of and marginalized. Which is kind of like what this blog did.
I think the best we can hope for is that this is a fad, like macrobiotic diets or biodynamic grape farming.
This happened a bit with cults after Jonestown massacre in late 70s. A lot of cult-ish group tried very hard not to be seen as cult-ish. Because it brought bad associations.
> We need to show parents what life was like before the polio vaccine. Before measles/mumps.
The problem is if they already decided to not vaccinate unless you take them back in time, whatever you show them will just be "yeah this is propaganda you are working for 'them'" this is all computer generated.
In a way this seemingly calm and rational way to handling this is already a loosing ground. For example see how you (perhaps unconsciously) phrased this:
> our smug pro-vax point of view
Note the "pro-vax" label. That is the problem. Once you start calling everyone "pro-vax" it validates the crazies as if their point as equally valid. It should instead be "crazies" vs "non-crazies".
Nobody discusses whether we should be "pro-rape" or "anti-rape". There is nothing to debate there. Granted, it should be the same way about torture. We lost that ground. We are just discussing how effective or ineffective torture can be in intelligence gathering as opposed assuming anyone who does it is a sick criminal. I think vaccinations should be in the same domain of discourse.
So quickly pushing for legislature to restrict opting out based on "personal beliefs" is the right choice.