News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:3D Printer Shootout – $600 Printrbot vs. $20,000 UPrint S... by brudgers on Friday February 06, 2015 @08:49AM (#9008888)
Ok, I am compelled to point out that the $22,000 printer works ~8 times as fast or does 8 times as much work...depending on how you look at it. Droplets versus mugs.

    Maths
    (0.2mm/0.1mm)^3
There is not much of a premium for performance in supply costs. The premium in hardware costs is ~4.5x. A lot for a consumer. Cheap if you're racing.

What I was reminded of is commodity servers. You run the models through a cluster of three or four cheap rigs (maybe with different slicing software) to increase the odds of getting a good artifact in 8 hours and to allow taking a machine offline for tuning.

Of course eight 0.2mm resolution printers will no more create a 0.1mms artifact than 9 fertile ladies will gestate an infant in one month.

Re:3D Printer Shootout – $600 Printrbot vs. $20,000 UPrint S... by failed_ideas on Friday February 06, 2015 @10:23AM (#9009354)
Fair enough, but it's still a valid comparison for most of us looking. Is the $600 machine 'good enough' for my usage, and it looks like it will be.
Re:3D Printer Shootout – $600 Printrbot vs. $20,000 UPrint S... by brudgers on Friday February 06, 2015 @10:58AM (#9009539)
I wasn't being critical, I was being compelled. Hanselman's analysis is reasonable and not misleading. The $600 product easily solves the 95% case.

And for a consumer oriented product probably the 99.9% case since most will sit on the shelf because it's still printing and how much stuff do people download off the internet and print with their color printers these days?

The idea that we will all be making our personalized LPS (Little Plastic Shit)[1] to our snowflake's content is true. But only because most snowflakes are content without doing it as a hobby. It's Buck Rodgers cool when it's on the screen, but the reality of waiting 8 hours for maybe getting a widget only appeals to some people.

It's like raytracing silver balls above a red and yellow checkerboard. Amazing to see it come out line by line over four hours at 320x200 in 1989. Not worth setting up a Blender scene to do it in the blink of an eye today.

For most people, there are better options than doing it themselves. For a few use cases doing it yourself is the best option. And doing it yourself is a great option for people who want to do it themselves. That's the same class of people who put their recipes on floppy disks in C64 days.

Done ranting. Get off my lawn anyway.

[1] or plastic crap : https://encyclopediadramatica.se/Plastic_crap

Re:3D Printer Shootout – $600 Printrbot vs. $20,000 UPrint S... by anonbanker on Friday February 06, 2015 @01:03PM (#9010435)
Upvoted for ED link. Probably the most honest Encyclopedia ever made.
Re:3D Printer Shootout – $600 Printrbot vs. $20,000 UPrint S... by darkmighty on Friday February 06, 2015 @10:58AM (#9009547)
I don't know, do you have data to claim the printer price must scale at least linearly with cubic resolution? There are plenty of much cheaper printers out there with .1mm res. (https://www.3dhubs.com/best-3d-printer-guide)

You picked the most generous aspect for comparison but it still looks rough.

Re:3D Printer Shootout – $600 Printrbot vs. $20,000 UPrint S... by brudgers on Friday February 06, 2015 @11:15AM (#9009657)
Just because it's the internet, doesn't mean I was being critical. I was just providing some mathematical context.

I used the racing analogy in the price comparison. It's cheap to make up a margin of minutes on the fastest car. It's really expensive to make up fractions of a second.

Re:3D Printer Shootout – $600 Printrbot vs. $20,000 UPrint S... by kenrikm on Friday February 06, 2015 @01:09PM (#9010497)
You could always buy 10 of the $600 printer sure there is more overhead but the effective bandwidth is increased. Unless you just need a single cup, however you could be printing multiple cup designs at the same time and if one machine goes down you're not completely shut down.
Re:3D Printer Shootout – $600 Printrbot vs. $20,000 UPrint S... by brudgers on Friday February 06, 2015 @01:17PM (#9010548)
If you need a cup, you probably should get one made out of something food grade. In less than an hour I can do so at the thrift shop. And it's only 99 cents.
Re:3D Printer Shootout – $600 Printrbot vs. $20,000 UPrint S... by Vendan on Friday February 06, 2015 @11:05AM (#9009587)
not completely true, as there are more variables at play. 0.1mm vs 0.2mm is the layer height, but you are missing the extrusion width settings. For all you know, the $22,000 was running twice the extrusion width. In addition, just cause a printer was run at 0.2mm doesn't mean that's the smallest layer height it can do, I would expect the printrbot metal to do at least 0.1mm, if not better.
Re:3D Printer Shootout – $600 Printrbot vs. $20,000 UPrint S... by brudgers on Friday February 06, 2015 @11:21AM (#9009693)
The filiment could have been wider as you suggest. The filiment on the $600 printer could have been wider too.

My internet connection to the omniscience is down. I was just going with what's described in the article.

There's a reason that the $22,000 model costs $22,000. Margin is only one of them.

Re:3D Printer Shootout – $600 Printrbot vs. $20,000 UPrint S... by Vendan on Friday February 06, 2015 @11:30AM (#9009732)
Not the filament itself, the extrusion width. It's something that you specify in the slicer, and can vary by a bit, between hard bounds specified by the nozzle diameter of the print head. Also, consider how much of that $22,000 is "make it look pretty". They are already trying to do everything they can to make money off the thing, i.e. expensive filament and disposable build plates.
Re:3D Printer Shootout – $600 Printrbot vs. $20,000 UPrint S... by brudgers on Friday February 06, 2015 @12:38PM (#9010242)
If a part effectively takes a calendar day to print, the build plate increases the odds of an acceptable prototype 0.1%, and net revenue on the completed project will be $5001 per day, then a $5 build plate pays for itself in a properly capitalized design development cycle.

And that's only the case if other features of the system don't add any value that could offset the cost of the plate and the additional day of design labor and overhead is ignored.

All of which is to propose the possibility that there might be business cases where the machine makes sense and the possibility that everyone besides we two obvious geniuses might not be incompetent.

Re:3D Printer Shootout – $600 Printrbot vs. $20,000 UPrint S... by crisnoble on Friday February 06, 2015 @12:48PM (#9010333)
Considering the $350 printrbot simple can do 100microns, I am sure that the printrbot metal can do 0.1mm too.
Re:3D Printer Shootout – $600 Printrbot vs. $20,000 UPrint S... by yaddayadda on Friday February 06, 2015 @12:46PM (#9010313)
According to Hansleman:

> My 0.2mm print took about 7 hours

> Brandon said it took 8 hours and 22 minutes.

So in this case, the $22,000 printer took ~17% longer.

Re:3D Printer Shootout – $600 Printrbot vs. $20,000 UPrint S... by spott on Friday February 06, 2015 @01:06PM (#9010464)
To do 4 - 8 times the work... (depending on how you think about it).

In order to create a "bar" .2 mm on a side, the .1mm printer needs to lay down 4 lines, while the .2 mm printer only lays down one.

Re:3D Printer Shootout – $600 Printrbot vs. $20,000 UPrint S... by disposablename on Friday February 06, 2015 @02:35PM (#9011052)
Layer height and extrusion width are separate settings, if the extrusion width is the same, it's only twice as much head travel, not four times. Extrusion width is around .4mm on most FDM printers.

You can't really call it more work either, since the resulting volume is identical.

The only thing that's different between the two prints is Z resolution, and that's a factor of 2 difference.

Re:3D Printer Shootout – $600 Printrbot vs. $20,000 UPrint S... by mcguire on Friday February 06, 2015 @01:03PM (#9010441)
The point being that the commercial printer is doing it at twice the linear resolution.