News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Negotiators Lose Last Chance to Salvage the TPP by Caving... by valar_m on Thursday February 05, 2015 @09:11AM (#9003288)
This is a bad idea. You want to impose a tax on people when they create something? Penalizing people for innovation is the exact opposite of what copyright protection is intended to do.

If I create something, and a corporation with deep pockets wants to take it from me, they can just keep upping their bid until the tax for me to keep it would bankrupt me, forcing me to give it up? No thanks.

Re:Negotiators Lose Last Chance to Salvage the TPP by Caving... by bokonist on Thursday February 05, 2015 @10:15AM (#9003587)
A 1% tax is a little bit steep. But what if the tax was only .1%? Or maybe you make it a 0% tax for the first ten years, .1% tax for the next twenty years, and 1% a year after that?

If the tax was only .1%, the corporation with big pockets would have to raise their bid to millions of dollars in order to bankrupt you. And in that case, just take their bid and walk away with the millions!

It seems fair to me. If you want something protected by the long arm of the state, if you want to impose a burden of DMCA compliance across all of industry, you should have to pay some tax to pay for that service.

Re:Negotiators Lose Last Chance to Salvage the TPP by Caving... by yuubi on Thursday February 05, 2015 @11:23AM (#9004021)
> You want to impose a tax on people when they create something?

The proposal seems to suggest the tax applies to those who want the government to help them exclude others from using their creations, which isn't quite the same thing.

Re:Negotiators Lose Last Chance to Salvage the TPP by Caving... by dredmorbius on Thursday February 05, 2015 @10:55AM (#9003844)
With the stipulation that it's a graduated tax which applies only to extensions, I think it's a fine idea.

Your first 7-14 years are free, a modest fee for the next 14 year extension. Then they start rising steeply.

If the work's worth the extension, you can continue to file. If not, it lapses to PD.

And you only get so long regardless -- 56 years should be long enough for anybody.

Re:Negotiators Lose Last Chance to Salvage the TPP by Caving... by mikeash on Thursday February 05, 2015 @01:48PM (#9005044)
I like the idea of an exponential increase. $1 for the first year, then double it for each subsequent year. If you don't want to pay a $1 then it probably doesn't deserve protection. If you can't afford $2047 over ten years then maybe you don't need a decade of protection. You don't even need to put in an explicit limit, since the available money on the planet will present a natural one eventually.
Re:Negotiators Lose Last Chance to Salvage the TPP by Caving... by dredmorbius on Thursday February 05, 2015 @05:13PM (#9006502)
Yes, though the overhead of requiring annual extensions might be a bit much.

The pre-1976 scheme required a filing and fee, though it was relatively modest. All non-registered works were public domain, and the circle-C symbol (or phonogram cicle-P) and notice were required.

I really wish we'd go back to something more like that.

Re:Negotiators Lose Last Chance to Salvage the TPP by Caving... by mikeash on Thursday February 05, 2015 @09:54PM (#9007530)
It could be adjusted pretty easily. For example, do it every five years, and multiply by 100 each time, or whatever seems to make sense. Heck, if you're worried about people who aren't aware of the requirements getting screwed, have automagic and free copyright for the first five or ten years, then start requiring filing.
Re:Negotiators Lose Last Chance to Salvage the TPP by Caving... by ColinDabritz on Thursday February 05, 2015 @09:45AM (#9003430)
Interesting. I feel that "intellectual property" already penalizes people for innovating. It supports the original creator directly, but it prevents all the other innovators from creating more work in the same direction that is inspired by the first. Perhaps the tax helps balance this value?
Re:Negotiators Lose Last Chance to Salvage the TPP by Caving... by valar_m on Thursday February 05, 2015 @10:46AM (#9003792)
What we're talking about is a system in which individuals and small startups are at a disadvantage by design. The closer you are to missing your rent, the easier it will be for me to take your work.

I agree that IP law is harmful. But I don't think the solution is to penalize innovation while further tilting the playing field toward large corporations.

Re:Negotiators Lose Last Chance to Salvage the TPP by Caving... by bediger4000 on Thursday February 05, 2015 @09:42AM (#9003415)
I don't know - it seems to make sense to me. The copyright holder is paying a tax so that the state protects the monopoly that's granted with copyright. Seems fair to me. Otherwise, we've got the current situation where some corporations get a huge benefit by getting free monopoly-enforcement from the state.
Re:Negotiators Lose Last Chance to Salvage the TPP by Caving... by innguest on Thursday February 05, 2015 @10:22AM (#9003627)
> You want to impose a tax on people when they create something?

Interesting reaction. So you're against taxing the idea guy (or girl), but not against taxing the working people that make the idea become real?

If the copyright has value and is being protected, the copyright owner ought to pay the state for this protection in a proportional way to his work's worth.

I've never heard of the idea posited by the OP before and I must say as someone that doesn't believe in intellectual property laws (because it's not real property and ultimately unenforceable), it is a good idea that makes sense.

The idea reifies the value of the work by putting a bounty on it. If the bounty is paid the work is released. Until the bounty is paid the author of the work will subsidize its protection by paying a fraction of what they make from profits from that work. OP, where did you read this idea? It's very interesting.

Re:Negotiators Lose Last Chance to Salvage the TPP by Caving... by valar_m on Thursday February 05, 2015 @10:54AM (#9003838)
"So you're against taxing the idea guy (or girl), but not against taxing the working people that make the idea become real?"

This is a straw man. I said nothing of the like.

"Until the bounty is paid the author of the work will subsidize its protection by paying a fraction of what they make from profits from that work."

What if the author can't afford to pay? Does being poor mean you don't deserve to own the work you've created?

Re:Negotiators Lose Last Chance to Salvage the TPP by Caving... by icebraining on Thursday February 05, 2015 @11:23AM (#9004024)
This is a straw man. I said nothing of the like.

So you're against the income tax?

What if the author can't afford to pay? Does being poor mean you don't deserve to own the work you've created?

How can (s)he not afford to pay, if it's "a fraction of what they make from profits from that work"? In any case, that sounds like a poor objection to the general idea of a tax - it could simply have a minimal cutoff, like many taxes.

Re:Negotiators Lose Last Chance to Salvage the TPP by Caving... by valar_m on Thursday February 05, 2015 @02:58PM (#9005565)
So you're against the income tax?

Straw man. I said nothing of the like.

How can (s)he not afford to pay, if it's "a fraction of what they make from profits from that work"?

Because poor people don't have very much money? Maybe I'm misunderstanding the question.

In any case, that sounds like a poor objection to the general idea of a tax

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Straw_man

Re:Negotiators Lose Last Chance to Salvage the TPP by Caving... by icebraining on Thursday February 05, 2015 @04:29PM (#9006247)
If you're more interested in replying with Wikipedia links than understanding what I'm trying to ask, I don't think we can have a productive conversation.
Re:Negotiators Lose Last Chance to Salvage the TPP by Caving... by valar_m on Thursday February 05, 2015 @05:15PM (#9006514)
How am I supposed to respond? Here is what you said:

So you're against the income tax?

Control + f, "income tax"

Arguing a straw man is precisely what you did. I said I think it's a bad idea to tax copyright ownership, and you responded by claiming I'm against income taxes.

I'm sorry, but that's just an absurd way to argue. In no way did I make any statement remotely close to arguing against income taxes. That doesn't have anything to do with the topic at hand.

If you're truly interested in a public conversation, then respond to what I actually said.

Re:Negotiators Lose Last Chance to Salvage the TPP by Caving... by icebraining on Thursday February 05, 2015 @05:58PM (#9006719)
I said I think it's a bad idea to tax copyright ownership, and you responded by claiming I'm against income taxes.

I wasn't actually claiming anything. I was just asking based on your reply to innguest's post. It wasn't supposed to be an argument related to the tax on copyright. But fair enough, I apologize.

In any case, I still think you've stopped reading the second part of my post too soon. I wasn't saying you were arguing against the general idea of taxes, but against a tax [on copyright]. All I meant is, even if the tax is bad for poor people, you can simply make it only apply for people with higher incomes and corporations. It's not actually a good argument against a tax [on copyright].