News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Spending by the UK government on the siege against Julian... by Jedd on Thursday February 05, 2015 @09:01AM (#9003243)
Law is littered with unwanted precedents. They are not, generally, compelling reasons to act in a sane and thoughtful way, and rarely (especially with such obvious edge cases as this) inform future decisions.

Is there actually an arrest warrant in Sweden for Assange? It's a highly convoluted arrangement between the UK (ostensibly keen to arrest, to satisfy their Swedish colleagues) and Sweden (who wish to question).

UK's position to extradite a person from another country into Sweden would not be weakened by any actions in this particular case. There's no precedent for that kind of prevarication.

Finally, you seem to imply that Assange would rather metaphorically 'wither and rot' (asserting facts not in evidence) in an embassy, rather than wither and rot (almost definitely guaranteed to be in the near-literal interpretation in a much more restrictive US-funded establishment), with the rather ambiguous phrase of 'deal with charges against him'. The charges, which haven't technically been made by the Swedes, and, on the face of it, are a smidge dubious, aren't what he's avoiding - it's the non-made charges that would occur once Sweden shipped him off to NOT 'deal with the charges against him' likely to be levelled by the US.

Do you think Snowden, Manning, et al are 'paranoid' (quotes to reflect implied inappropriate concern for self-wellbeing).

Re:Spending by the UK government on the siege against Julian... by PlzSnow on Thursday February 05, 2015 @09:37AM (#9003390)
Assange is wanted for questioning on allegations of sexual assault. Assange is a powerful and connected person, with strong support from a considerable percentage of the population. I am glad that that does not affect the legal process, and I would never want to live in a society where it did.

EDIT: The article says "He has been in a cell, under house arrest, or effectively detained at the Ecuadorian Embassy since December 2010."

This is patently a lie. He chooses to stay in the embassay of his own volition. How can anyone take this article seriously?

Re:Spending by the UK government on the siege against Julian... by parennoob on Thursday February 05, 2015 @10:43AM (#9003767)
> Assange is wanted for questioning on allegations of sexual assault.

If this was the only neccessity, why not do said questioning over video link? This is possible – at least, in England, there is even a company that specializes in it (http://www.eyenetwork.com/specialist-expertise/video-confere...)

Re:Spending by the UK government on the siege against Julian... by PlzSnow on Thursday February 05, 2015 @11:32AM (#9004088)
Why would Sweden make an exception to their legal processes just for Assange? He's just another person wanted for questioning over allegations over sexual assault. He's not the messiah.

Anyway, as another poster said, these facts were pointed out years ago. But I understand that facts and logic are of no interest to the Messiah's disciples.

Re:Spending by the UK government on the siege against Julian... by crdoconnor on Thursday February 05, 2015 @11:45AM (#9004188)
>Why would Sweden make an exception to their legal processes just for Assange?

Because a sovereign nation has granted him asylum because they (correctly) identified the charges against him as being politically motivated.

If Sweden cannot make a very minor accomodation in response that only gives more weight to the argument that the charges were politically motivated.

Re:Spending by the UK government on the siege against Julian... by Tomte on Thursday February 05, 2015 @10:48AM (#9003799)
It's technologically possible, but not legally.

Shall we rehash all the facts again?

Re:Spending by the UK government on the siege against Julian... by parennoob on Thursday February 05, 2015 @11:25AM (#9004034)
Don't understand the patronizing tone here. For a start, the BBC Q&A I've read on this says that it's basically the Swedish prosecutors saying, "No, because of circumstances, we want him here", not "It is legally forbidden". The prosecutor saying "We want him here, and we aren't going to tell you why" doesn't exactly radiate fairness and transparency.[1]

Maybe I'm wholly mistaken, but it stands to reason that should be a legal possibility that an individual can be questioned over video link. For example, consider a Swedish invalid who is in delicate condition in a London hospital and is medically forbidden to travel.

[1] http://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-19426382

"Karin Rosander of the Swedish Prosecution Authority told the BBC on 21 August 2010 that "because of circumstances in the investigation, [the prosecutor's] opinion is that it is necessary that he is present in Sweden".

Ms Rosander said the prosecutor had not made clear exactly what those circumstances were. "At this stage of the investigation, [the prosecutor] does not want to specify," she said."

Re:Spending by the UK government on the siege against Julian... by Tomte on Thursday February 05, 2015 @12:00PM (#9004311)
If he's medically unable to travel for questioning, he cannot travel for his trial, either.

The trial which by law has to begin two weeks later, at the latest.

Really, we've had that dozens of times on HN now.

https://storify.com/anyapalmer/why-doesn-t-sweden-interview-...

http://www.newstatesman.com/blogs/media/2012/09/legal-mythol...

http://www.newstatesman.com/david-allen-green/2012/08/legal-...

Re:Spending by the UK government on the siege against Julian... by Jedd on Thursday February 05, 2015 @09:46AM (#9003434)
> Assange is wanted for questioning on allegations of sexual assault.

These questions can evidently not be asked within the embassy. (Ignoring the various, and I concede very loaded, discussions around the validity of the allegations.)

> Assange is a powerful and connected person, with strong support from a considerable percentage of the population.

Substitute 'American intelligence agencies' for 'Assange' in that sentence, and perhaps stick a 'tacit' in front of the word support, while you're at it.

To be clear, my point here is that Assange is nowhere near as powerful as any or all of the Swedish, UK, or US governments (or any of their agencies). However, world+dog understands that it's a bit more complicated than 'come and talk to us in our country about these dubious claims, oh and we can't guarantee that we haven't already arranged for you to be flown into Central America to not face charges for the rest of your life'.

> I am glad that that does not affect the legal process, and I would never want to live in a society where it did.

I am genuinely concerned about your understanding of the society/ies that you believe you're living in now.

Re:Spending by the UK government on the siege against Julian... by PlzSnow on Thursday February 05, 2015 @09:51AM (#9003463)
I am genuinely baffled by your reply. Assange is wanted for questioning for allegations of sexual assault, and you say he shouldn't have to follow due process and answer them because... because what? Because his political ideals are aligned with your own? Because of an absurd conspiracy that he will be secretly abducted to Central America?
Re:Spending by the UK government on the siege against Julian... by crdoconnor on Thursday February 05, 2015 @11:38AM (#9004139)
Assange is only wanted for questioning and has repeatedly offered to answer their questions. They stated that he must be questioned in Sweden and only in Sweden without adequately explaining why.
Re:Spending by the UK government on the siege against Julian... by foldr on Thursday February 05, 2015 @12:17PM (#9004432)
They don't need to explain why because they already have a legally obtained arrest warrant. But in any case, it's obvious why: the investigation has reached a stage where they will almost certainly want to file charges, but they cannot do that while Assange is in the UK. The Swedish prosecutor explained this very clearly:

"Subject to any matters said by him [in the second interview] which undermine my present view that he should be indicted, an indictment will be lodged with the court thereafter. It can therefore be seen that Assange is sought for the purpose of conducting criminal proceedings and that he is not sought merely to assist with our enquiries."

The kind of objection you're making also assumes Schizophrenia on the part of the Swedish authorities. On the one hand, Assange is "only wanted for questioning", but on the other hand, there's a secret plot to charge him with a crime he didn't commit and have him extradited to the US. Well, which is it?

Re:Spending by the UK government on the siege against Julian... by bhayden on Thursday February 05, 2015 @01:58PM (#9005109)
It seems to be this entire argument can be solved by looking into the number of people who have allegedly committed sexual assault in Sweden, are currently residing in the UK, and have been arrested and deported back to Sweden for questioning. If the answer is zero (or near zero), then there's obviously more to this than what the Swedes are admitting.
Re:Spending by the UK government on the siege against Julian... by foldr on Thursday February 05, 2015 @04:16PM (#9006165)
The charge is rape, and it is not particularly unusual for EAWs to be issued for rape charges. See here:

http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm201314/cmhansrd/c...

"Since 2009 alone, the arrest warrant has been used to extradite from the UK 57 suspects for child sex offences, 86 for rape and 105 for murder."

Re:Spending by the UK government on the siege against Julian... by Jedd on Thursday February 05, 2015 @10:19AM (#9003603)
Don't be baffled.

There are, at the very least, some very dubious aspects surrounding the original claims: http://www.theguardian.com/media/2010/dec/17/julian-assange-...

I guess I am suggesting that due process, in this case, should be avoided - but only because this is clearly an exceptional situation, with some profound risks for Assange and other whistle-blowers.

The idea that any change to due process should be avoided because it 'sets precedent' I think is a misdirection. There appears to be not substantial reason for Swedish prosecutors to attend London and talk to Assange directly before making their (next) decision.

To be candid I don't really understand what his political ideals are - but I am informed enough to understand that it's more complicated than the way one might explain it to a 5yo.

Re:Spending by the UK government on the siege against Julian... by PlzSnow on Thursday February 05, 2015 @11:26AM (#9004043)
I'm still baffled by your arguments. We live in a modern democratic society. Professionals in the law system examined the Assange case and decided that there was a case to answer. Just because someone on the Internet is "dubious about it" doesn't change that, and I would never want to live in a society where it did.
Re:Spending by the UK government on the siege against Julian... by droope on Friday February 06, 2015 @02:31AM (#9008043)
Obviously the Equatorian government and Assange don't feel that if he were to submit, he would get a fair trial.

I think the argument that they are making -- not that I agree -- is that the UK and Sweden are bad governments, just like when governments protect Chinese journalists and such.

Re:Spending by the UK government on the siege against Julian... by Datsundere on Thursday February 05, 2015 @03:24PM (#9005764)
guys, i found the uk government
Re:Spending by the UK government on the siege against Julian... by tptacek on Thursday February 05, 2015 @10:43AM (#9003770)
Yes, there is an arrest warrant for Assange in Sweden.

Assange is mechanically harder to extradite to the US from Sweden. Extradition from the UK requires only the approval of the UK. Extradition from Sweden would at this point require the approval of both Sweden and the UK. Both Sweden and the UK are bound by the ECHR.