News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How I won the housing market without trying by junto on Thursday February 05, 2015 @04:44AM (#9002417)
What is interesting, is that the policy makers have a financial interest in ensuring that the housing market does not crash. Therefore every time it should have crashed big time (2001, 2008), the BoE has propped it up by making sure that borrowing remained dirt cheap and the government made sure that the market stayed liquid (raising stamp duty levels for example).

Every time they do this, they just exacerbate the problem long term, which is quite simply, that the market needs a correction, and the longer they put it off, the more painful the correction is going to be (like it was early 1990's in the UK but worse).

I for one say let it burn.

Re:How I won the housing market without trying by brianmcc on Thursday February 05, 2015 @04:53AM (#9002441)
In many places in the UK, it did crash big time. Plenty of people I know even today are in homes well below their 2007 levels or have sold for painful losses. London is unusual in that many properties sell for cash, to investors, and in fact the BoE and mortgage lenders have surprisingly little influence in terms of rate changes. Not sure letting anything "burn" particularly helps anybody.

Edit: I suspect "let it burn" reflects a certain frustration, you have my sympathy if you or your family/friends are finding the situation a barrier. Facts and figures can mask the very personal cost of being unable to achieve fundamental goals in life such putting down roots for one's family.

Re:How I won the housing market without trying by awjr on Thursday February 05, 2015 @05:04AM (#9002471)
My mother just recently bought a studio flat in Wales for 31k. Prices are dropping around the country. London prices are forcing people away from living in London. Businesses are moving away. (If you are a young developer, I'd suggest moving to Bristol.)
Re:How I won the housing market without trying by deepvibrations on Thursday February 05, 2015 @05:24AM (#9002532)
I second that! Best city in the UK in my opinion- It has an amazing selection of bars, clubs and independent shops, a buzzing music scene and of course a great tech scene with plenty of meetups etc. Compared to London I would say it's much more friendly, you can cycle from one side to the other in under an hour, escape to the countryside or the coast in under an hour and you never feel trapped in a towering concrete jungle (often felt this in London!).
Re:How I won the housing market without trying by collyw on Thursday February 05, 2015 @06:50AM (#9002750)
Almost anywhere in the country is more friendly than London
Re:How I won the housing market without trying by jgraham on Thursday February 05, 2015 @05:13AM (#9002498)
The data doesn't seem to support that view [1]. The headline claim there is that average property prices across the country rose by 7% last year, with London more than double that and no area showing an annual fall.

It seems like your example of Bristol is only becoming cheaper relative to London, not cheaper in any absolute sense.

[1] https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachm...

Re:How I won the housing market without trying by brianmcc on Thursday February 05, 2015 @05:22AM (#9002525)
Agreed; in Scotland, we're now seeing steady, but not excessive, growth in volumes and prices. I'd say it's recovering, not worsening.
Re:How I won the housing market without trying by barrkel on Thursday February 05, 2015 @05:26AM (#9002540)
You'll severely limit your career and earning potential if you do that, particularly if you're not a founder or otherwise in a position to insulate yourself from pure market salaries.

Dev salaries are not high in Britain as a whole, outside of London.

Re:How I won the housing market without trying by pjc50 on Thursday February 05, 2015 @05:42AM (#9002584)
Depends on whether you measure earning potential in pounds or houses. Someone earning £50k in an area of £250k houses is being paid 0.2 houses per annum. If they can get £40k in an area of £100k houses their spending power has gone up not down.

If only it weren't so necessary to be physically present for the work.

Re:How I won the housing market without trying by barrkel on Thursday February 05, 2015 @06:25AM (#9002692)
I tend to measure things in disposable income: how much money I have left over after paying the big bills. And this is a fairly absolute measure, rather than relative to living costs, as I spend much of my disposable income on stuff that costs similar amounts no matter where I live.

50k is a mediocre salary, mind.

Re:How I won the housing market without trying by porker on Thursday February 05, 2015 @06:46AM (#9002735)
Mediocre salary???? Either you live in the square mile bubble, or you're not British.

£50k is what a senior software developer outside London gets.

Re:How I won the housing market without trying by barrkel on Thursday February 05, 2015 @09:53AM (#9003471)
That's exactly my point: UK software salaries are not high outside of London, and that if you want a good salary, you need to work in London.
Re:How I won the housing market without trying by pjc50 on Thursday February 05, 2015 @06:37AM (#9002719)
50k is a 90th percentile salary for the UK as a whole and competitive for non-London non-senior management software dev jobs.
Re:How I won the housing market without trying by barrkel on Thursday February 05, 2015 @09:53AM (#9003475)
Perhaps the context of this thread has been lost. It started out with me asserting that you get poor return outside of London.

Personally, I think there's little point in living in the UK outside of London. There's far nicer places to live if you're willing to take a hit in salary. (And no, I'm not British.)

Re:How I won the housing market without trying by pjc50 on Thursday February 05, 2015 @11:38AM (#9004140)
What places would you suggest?

My argument was a PPP and quality-of-life one, really. Moving to Edinburgh has worked out quite nicely in that regard.

Re:How I won the housing market without trying by barrkel on Thursday February 05, 2015 @10:26PM (#9007608)
Somewhere with better weather and better connections to the rest of the world.

I spend most of my money on travel, motorcycles, food and fine wine (in particular, aged fortified wines in the 3-digit price range). Food is the only one particularly affected by PPP. A typical meal out for two costs £60 to £200, depending quality and wine bought. I'll spend more on a special occasion. But living outside London, I'd have a harder time finding great places to eat. My experience from touring the UK is that there are more hearty, good value options especially as you go north, but fine dining gets scarcer.

Travel is really important to me, touring by motorcycle specifically. But the south of England is very flat, and the fastest way to the continent is a train to France. Once you land in France, you have to cross it to get to wherever you're going. Alternately, one can take a ferry and suffer excruciating boredom only marginally worse than a motorway.

Almost anywhere in central Europe would be better for biking - southeast France, northern Italy, southern Germany, Austria - or northern Spain, if I didn't want to leave the country for some of the best roads in the world. More snow in winter, mind, but I could live with that. Certainly, the roads in the UK are among the worst in western Europe, outside of Belgium and possibly Ireland - though Ireland has had a lot of investment, they've built some very odd roads.

I grew up on the west coast of Ireland. My willingness to tolerate rainy days is no longer very high.

Re:How I won the housing market without trying by brianmcc on Thursday February 05, 2015 @05:45AM (#9002598)
There are pockets outside London where demand for developers is very high. Don't be fooled into thinking it's London or nothing for the UK workforce. I'm in Central Scotland, and there's a thriving tech thing going on here.
Re:How I won the housing market without trying by lucaspiller on Thursday February 05, 2015 @10:45AM (#9003776)
In my experience jobs outside of London have a much lower earning potential. I went to university in Devon, and there are a fair few tech jobs around there, but even as a senior developer with 10 years experience I wouldn't get much more than £40k. Instead I moved to London, and was getting more than that two years after I graduated.

Sure London is more expensive, but if you don't mind commuting you can live further out of the city for not much more than the UK average - I'd imagine rents between Bristol and Reading are pretty similar, but Reading is easily commutable to London (Bristol isn't bad either, but I wouldn't like to do it every day).

There is also the question of technologies too, if you aren't happy working with legacy Java or .NET systems then you'll have a much harder time getting a job outside of London.

Also where exactly is Central Scotland (I'm a southerner)?

Re:How I won the housing market without trying by pjc50 on Thursday February 05, 2015 @11:48AM (#9004207)
Central Scotland = Glasgow, Edinburgh and places along the M8 (eg Oracle at Linlithgow). http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Silicon_Glen also includes Dundee which isn't quite "central" but has a games cluster centered on Abertay.

It's a good way south of the centre of a map of Scotland, but it's the area where people are concentrated.

Re:How I won the housing market without trying by brianmcc on Thursday February 05, 2015 @11:57AM (#9004298)
In general you're probably right. I guess it's finding the exceptions that are out there that's difficult, and as you say, for someone based in the south of England, the middle bit of Scotland is pretty obscure.

There is a body, IIRC, promoting Scotland and awareness of its growing activity in tech as a place to come and live and work. Perhaps not "Mission Accomplished" quite yet :-)

Re:How I won the housing market without trying by JimmyM on Thursday February 05, 2015 @06:09AM (#9002661)
> Prices are dropping around the country.

> London prices are forcing people away from living in London. Businesses are moving away.

Wouldn't this force prices higher across the country?

As someone living in Bristol, I have to say that there's been a (noticeable) influx of people from London, and that this is what I believe has forced local prices up to the point where many can no longer afford to stay.

Friends of mine, who are local (I am an Essex import), have scattered as far as Darwen and Bournemouth.

Re:How I won the housing market without trying by prostoalex on Thursday February 05, 2015 @01:43PM (#9005007)
> What is interesting, is that the policy makers have a financial interest in ensuring that the housing market does not crash.

Exactly. Moreover, the housing value is tied into things such as total wealth (which is why after the 2008 crash the wealth of middle-income and low-income Americans crashed, too much of it was tied up into housing equity), which then ties into economic outlook and consumer spending, which then ties into lending and all things finances.

Presidents and parliament members do get voted out when there's a severe contraction in consumer spending and generally depressive feelings about economic outlook.

Re:How I won the housing market without trying by matthewmacleod on Thursday February 05, 2015 @05:13AM (#9002499)
I don't think you achieve much by 'letting it burn,' as it were. All you do is force a large number of people into a bad financial situation – that's not good for anybody.

The market needs correction, but it needs to be well-managed. That basically means long-term house price stagnation and investment in social housing to remove the incentives for buy-to-let landlords and multiple property owners.

Re:How I won the housing market without trying by justincormack on Thursday February 05, 2015 @05:21AM (#9002520)
Property is a zero sum game. People without houses lose the equivalent in future spending as homeowners gain. So propping up a market is directly taking money from the young and increasingly old non homeowners. So not doing anything is putting a large number of people in a bad situation.
Re:How I won the housing market without trying by ptaipale on Thursday February 05, 2015 @07:03AM (#9002782)
> Property is a zero sum game

No it is not. Properties - houses - can be built. When prices go up, the incentive to build more increases.

It could be argued that land ownership is a zero sum game, because you cannot manufacture land. But even that is not quite true, as can be seen in areas where more land is claimed from sea [0], effectively manufactured. Elsewhere, new land may emerge due to land rising after the recent Ice Age [1].

More importantly, land use - zoning - is something that can be changed, and it’s where economic incentives have an impact. For instance, in UK there's a lot of discussion about building on the green belt around London. And there are other factors here than just money, of course. It could be that money cannot buy a plot to build, but a racial or cultural identity can justify constructing what eventually become new properties. This does not always happen without conflict [2].

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8940235

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Post-glacial_rebound

[2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dale_Farm

Re:How I won the housing market without trying by notahacker on Thursday February 05, 2015 @05:46AM (#9002600)
Property isn't quite a zero sum game; as the last few years have show the overall losses from a crash outweigh the benefits of lower prices and greater liquidity to people without houses (especially if the result is that people without houses can't get mortgages even after the prices have fallen)

That's not to say there shouldn't be more pressure put on property price appreciation, not to mention confiscatory levels of capital gains tax on property speculators that aren't tax-resident in the UK. But inducing a property price crash (as opposed to slowing property price inflation) would be a bad move for the economy as a whole, as well as electoral suicide in a country where the majority of the population have a mortgage or own their house outright.

Re:How I won the housing market without trying by lentil_soup on Thursday February 05, 2015 @06:25AM (#9002694)
Doesn't "losses from a crash outweigh the benefits of lower prices" depend on who you're talking about?.

For me this has to be looked at from the point of who it affects the most. A person that already has a house is much better suited to "take the hit" of property prices than someone that doesn't have one (in general terms). Obviously you have to manage it, but in the end you should strive to protect those that are more vulnerable.

Re:How I won the housing market without trying by notahacker on Thursday February 05, 2015 @09:04AM (#9003250)
People most vulnerable to house price changes are people who own the title deeds to a house and an obligation to make mortgage repayments which may end up vastly exceeding the future value of the house. And the banks which see rising default rates from owners in negative equity, repossessed houses they can't sell. And anyone whose pension fund bought the wrong tranche of CDOs. Not to mention property developers, and workers in construction industries that support it, assuming the house price fall is generalised.

People least likely to be positively affected by a house price crash include people that don't have houses, the majority of whom face considerably more difficulty and up-front expense in obtaining a mortgage in an environment of falling or unstable property prices.

Sure, there are some beneficiaries from a house price crash, just like some people make money shorting a failing company. That doesn't mean there isn't a deadweight loss, and if your conception of people who are "most vulnerable" to property prices prioritizes the welfare of those with no significant exposure to property but plenty of liquid funds and a long term investment horizon, it's a very strange conception.

Much of the world is still suffering from the after-effects of a major house price crash in the US several years later; I'm genuinely quite saddened that some people are so adamant the effects of that must have been "zero sum" they feel obliged to reach for the downvote button when HN commenters have the temerity to suggest otherwise.

Re:How I won the housing market without trying by pjc50 on Thursday February 05, 2015 @05:39AM (#9002576)
Zero sum, unless more houses are built...
Re:How I won the housing market without trying by lentil_soup on Thursday February 05, 2015 @05:24AM (#9002531)
On the other hand, the rising prices are leaving a lot of people in bad a financial situation already as they can't afford a house/rent. So "letting it burn" would benefit some people.

Also, I would imagine people in this second group struggle more than the ones that already have a house or are using it as an investment. I would expect a government to enact policies that benefit them the most.