News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ross Ulbricht Convicted of Running Silk Road as Dread Pir... by jqm on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @04:35PM (#9000048)
He seems like a smart guy and a good guy overall...(yes, I know he allegedly attempted to hire a hit-man and we can't tolerate crime etc. etc.).

It's a shame to see his entire life wasted for an (admittedly rather large) youthful indiscretion. I keep thinking there has to be a more efficient, a more just way of discouraging criminal activity.

As an aside... Sometimes it apparently doesn't pay to be overly smart. Or rather, smart enough to get into trouble, but not smart enough to avoid the dangers.

Re:Ross Ulbricht Convicted of Running Silk Road as Dread Pir... by tptacek on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @04:54PM (#9000215)
He seems like a smart guy and a good guy overall...(yes, I know he allegedly attempted to hire a hit-man and we can't tolerate crime etc. etc.)

This is one of the all-time great HN quotes.

Re:Ross Ulbricht Convicted of Running Silk Road as Dread Pir... by pencilo on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @05:20PM (#9000396)
You see he's ok because he writes code and drug laws are bad, man.

I'm disgusted by people trying to claim he is anything but a horrible person while trying to brush away the fact that he paid for people to be murdered. Sure, no one was killed, but that's only by the grace of his stupidity, and massive ego.

HN might hate the war on drugs and love people that write code and live in the valley but its embarrassing that self described smart people could fall so low as to latch on to that while ignoring the undeniable horrible things he did. He wasn't a smart guy, he wasn't a good guy, its like people didn't read the transcripts where they went through his journal detailing everything he did.

Re:Ross Ulbricht Convicted of Running Silk Road as Dread Pir... by rodgerd on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @08:21PM (#9001217)
> You see he's ok because he writes code and drug laws are bad, man.

Given that there were people arguing Hans Reiser was unfairly convicted even after he confessed to murdering his wife, and suggesting that imprisonment was a waste of his talents, I am not particularly surprised by any expression of nerd supremacism any more. Saddened, but not surprised.

Re:Ross Ulbricht Convicted of Running Silk Road as Dread Pir... by kevinnk on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @08:49PM (#9001306)
There were people arguing Han Reiser was innocent and "coerced" all the way up to when he lead the police to her body...
Re:Ross Ulbricht Convicted of Running Silk Road as Dread Pir... by rodgerd on Thursday February 05, 2015 @04:15AM (#9002342)
And even then there were people arguing he should get special treatemnt because "he's a programmer, don't lock him up with thugs, let him contribute his genius, man!"
Re:Ross Ulbricht Convicted of Running Silk Road as Dread Pir... by Alupis on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @06:11PM (#9000698)
> while trying to brush away the fact that he paid for people to be murdered

Allegedly, there's not actual evidence this actually happened... nor did the prosecution attempt to go after those charges... nor has anyone traced the actual people who were supposedly murdered (their identities don't exist -- they aren't real people), nor has anyone validated the bitcoin transactions that supposedly transferred $750,000

Re:Ross Ulbricht Convicted of Running Silk Road as Dread Pir... by pencilo on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @06:45PM (#9000864)
The evidence that he paid for murders is as damning as the rest of it, he kept the chatlogs and made diary entries about _paying to have someone murdered_, Please.

The fact that he was scammed and no one was murdered is irrelevant, completely and utterly, and only goes to show he's not as smart as he thought he was. He's still just as evil for trying and it more importantly celebrating when he was told it was successful.

Agreeing with tptacek, again, pretty sure your last statement is false.

Re:Ross Ulbricht Convicted of Running Silk Road as Dread Pir... by gnopgnip on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @09:56PM (#9001494)
Re:Ross Ulbricht Convicted of Running Silk Road as Dread Pir... by tptacek on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @06:36PM (#9000822)
That last sentence is incorrect, I think.
Re:Ross Ulbricht Convicted of Running Silk Road as Dread Pir... by jqm on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @05:26PM (#9000425)
Thank you. I'll take that as a compliment considering.

Look... I'm not trying to justify what DPR allegedly did. All I'm saying is I see some positive qualities in him. Very different from a hardened and callus mob boss. Maybe it's just youth and he would have eventually become that, but I don't think so.

People do things, but it isn't necessarily the sum of what they are.

For reference, see comment about Sammy Gravano below. By ratting out others, he served only a few years after a lifetime of crime and murder. They let him out, relocated him with enough resources to start a company, (presumably to catch some bigger fish), and he continued with crime. Because, it is what he was at his very basic. A criminal and a murder. I simply don't see that with DPR. And comparing the two cases, I don't see what I consider justice. It pains me to see this guy locked up for life. It's just a personal opinion. I don't expect the justice system to honer my feelings. That's all.

Re:Ross Ulbricht Convicted of Running Silk Road as Dread Pir... by roel_v on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @06:15PM (#9000716)
"Very different from a hardened and callus mob boss."

I don't understand ideas like this. Do you think mob bosses don't love their children? As in, that somebody who is capable of love is somehow... I don't know... less culpable? If anything, one should argue that it's the psychopaths who are truly incapable of empathy are the ones who are 'ill' !

Re:Ross Ulbricht Convicted of Running Silk Road as Dread Pir... by MichaelGG on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @06:12PM (#9000703)
Being in the unique position of protecting hundreds of innocent people from destruction by one extortionist, eh, what choice did he have?

I believe your difference with me and others on this point is that you do not see the turning over of hundreds of unlicensed medicine merchants to the hands of the USG to be destruction of innocent lives or, indeed, in any way unethical. You'd phrase it like "These HNers are literally saying murdering someone is better than turning over information on drug dealers to the authorities".

If the extortionist was going to expose the operating covers of US agents worldwide, the execution of the extortionist would be accepted by many. I fail to see much of a defensible distinction in this particular instance.

Edit: I should add I'm only referring to the kill-the-extortionist deal, none of the others (now it's up to 5??). And Ross certainly deserves blame for running stuff so poorly that he could end up blackmailed or endangering his customers in the first place. If true, it's as bad or worse than Telegram or Cryptocat, in terms of putting people in danger.

Re:Ross Ulbricht Convicted of Running Silk Road as Dread Pir... by baby on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @04:59PM (#9000256)
He does seem like a normal good guy sometimes and I guess that's what parent focused on. After all, he's kind of like us, spending a lot of time coding in front of his computer and he doesn't look that stupid.

> 09/30/2013

> Had revelation about the need to eat well, get good sleep, and meditate so I can stay positive and productive.

(excerpt from his journal: http://cdn.arstechnica.net/wp-content/uploads/2015/02/GX-241...)

Re:Ross Ulbricht Convicted of Running Silk Road as Dread Pir... by Retra on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @05:13PM (#9000351)
No, he's not stupid, he just subscribes to a "there's nothing really wrong with black market drug rings and murder" ideology. It doesn't take a genius to figure out how dumb that is.
Re:Ross Ulbricht Convicted of Running Silk Road as Dread Pir... by mike_hearn on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @08:19PM (#9001208)
> After all, he's kind of like us, spending a lot of time coding in front of his computer and he doesn't look that stupid.

He doesn't look stupid?

Ulbricht was not a smart guy. This was obvious from his various writings, examples:

http://www.forbes.com/sites/andygreenberg/2013/08/14/an-inte...

http://www.forbes.com/sites/andygreenberg/2013/04/29/collect...

He talks at length about his philosophy in a way that seems superficially intelligent, until you actually scratch the surface and discover that what he was saying was internally contradictory and had no intellectual merit.

For example:

Firearms and ammunition are becoming more and more regulated and controlled in many parts of the world. We actually had a site up called “The Armory” ... if we can find a model that works where people can get the equipment they need to defend themselves and their families despite what the state wants and often in defense of the state itself, I would be more than happy to provide that.

The Armory, lest we forget, sold bazookas and RPG launchers. The awful oppression he is rallying against here ("in many parts of the world") is usually a highly popular policy that's completely uncontroversial. From the perspective of people living in these places being able to buy sub-machine guns online and have them delivered to your door is not some kind of non-violent libertarian utopia. It's just horrible.

Just a few paragraphs later he is saying

We don’t allow the sale of anything that’s main purpose is to harm innocent people

His deep lack of technical knowledge was revealed by this sentence:

I’m not one hundred percent on this, but I don’t think it’s possible to do a DDoS over Tor

Ulbricht routinely conflated libertarianism, agorism and anarchism as if they are all the same. His knowledge of economics was as flaky as his knowledge of political systems:

There is also nothing morally wrong with [cartels]. If a cartel were to form, I would not attempt to break it up unless its members were breaking other rules. If you want an explanation for why cartels are nearly impossible to maintain in a free market environment, please read “Man, Economy and State” chapter 10, part 2, section D

I was curious what kind of economics textbook would state that cartels could not form in a free market. It turned out to be a book written by "the founder and leading theoretician of anarch-capitalism" (quote from wikipedia). The chapter he refers to is available online. It is a tedious text that contains no references to real world examples at any point. In fact the entire thing is abstract philosophical argument, without any attempt to cross-check against data, yet it purports to explain real economies.

Nobody smart would actually make such an absurd claim or cite such a text to support it.

Finally, for all you people who think Ulbricht was some heroic martyr for the war on drugs, here is what he had to say about it:

If prohibition is lifted, most people here will go away. You’ll go back to your lives and get your drugs from whatever state certified dispensaries are properly licensed to sell to you. Drug use will be as interesting as smoking and drinking .... If prohibition is lifted, and the drug industry is placed under the yoke of the state, then we won in a small way, but lost in a big way.

Ulbricht didn't actually want the war on drugs to end because ultimately what he wanted was anarchy.

Re:Ross Ulbricht Convicted of Running Silk Road as Dread Pir... by jqm on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @08:58PM (#9001332)
"I disagree" is not the same as "he is not smart". (Don't feel bad. Lots of people have trouble telling the difference.)

He got Silk Road up and running. He was a grad physics student who had authored some papers. He is relatively intelligent. Objective fact.

Re:Ross Ulbricht Convicted of Running Silk Road as Dread Pir... by rozap on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @09:19PM (#9001398)
Oh ffs. Clearly he is smarter than the average human, but he was still in way over his head. Ultimately he wasn't clever enough to achieve his goal, or even carry on his little website for very long. Context is everything, and in this context he had no clue who he was up against. Not smart.
Re:Ross Ulbricht Convicted of Running Silk Road as Dread Pir... by baby on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @11:07PM (#9001667)
I don't think saying you don't agree with him means he's stupid.
Re:Ross Ulbricht Convicted of Running Silk Road as Dread Pir... by mike_hearn on Thursday February 05, 2015 @07:59AM (#9002963)
Many of those statements aren't things where I merely disagree. They are factually false. There are plenty of examples of cartels forming in free markets without government intervention. The Silicon Valley wage fixing agreements is one recent example, but there are lots of others. It is quite, quite possible to do DoS attacks on Tor services (you don't even need the "distributed" part, but could do it anyway if you wanted to). Libertarianism is not the same thing as agorism under any definition I know of. He says in those articles he wouldn't allow weapons to be sold that were designed for use on crowds, but the Armory sold sub-machine guns. And so on.

Look, it's OK to be emotionally invested in some of the ideas Ulbricht stood for. That doesn't change the fact that many of the statements he made are flat wrong or simply contradictory.

Re:Ross Ulbricht Convicted of Running Silk Road as Dread Pir... by baby on Thursday February 05, 2015 @02:19PM (#9005259)
> the statements he made are flat wrong or simply contradictory.

and it's OK because we all do this. I always find that kind of comment a bit too harsh because we always tend to forget people we judge are just humans like us.

I'm sure you have contradictions of your own in your own lifestyle. And I'm sure you would look stupid by your non/partial knowledge of some subjects to some people... Doesn't mean that you are stupid.

Also a private journal is something non-relevant because if you have one (I do have mine) take a look at what you wrote a few weeks or months or years ago and you will see they generally look pretty stupid, or they were in the moment, or you just didn't care because you thought no one would be reading it.

Re:Ross Ulbricht Convicted of Running Silk Road as Dread Pir... by mike_hearn on Friday February 06, 2015 @07:14AM (#9008626)
Those quotes aren't from his private journal. I'd be much more lenient on him if they were. They are from interviews and public postings where he is trying to explain what the Silk Road stands for, in public. That's exactly the time when he needs to be really sure why he's doing what he's doing and have a coherent, convincing theory of it. That's what a smart person would have. But he didn't.
Re:Ross Ulbricht Convicted of Running Silk Road as Dread Pir... by researcher88 on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @09:04PM (#9001355)
President Bush gave Charles Colson the Presidential Citizens Medal. All Colson did was conspire to kill a US journalist while working as White House counsel. And conspire to firebomb the Brookings Institution and orchestrated the Watergate burglary. The guy was awarded 15 honorary doctorates and praised by so many Republicans.

Jack Anderson would possibly be dead since the conspiracy only halted when Watergate happened.

Surely there is redemption for Ross. Colson spent less than a year in prison even though the others (eg G Gordon Liddy) admtted they were planning to kill Anderson.

Re:Ross Ulbricht Convicted of Running Silk Road as Dread Pir... by tptacek on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @09:06PM (#9001363)
Chuck Colson is also not a good person. If we want to let this rest by putting Ulbricht and Colson on the same level, I'm fine with that.
Re:Ross Ulbricht Convicted of Running Silk Road as Dread Pir... by jqm on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @09:10PM (#9001374)
OK tptacek... same level as you say. So a year in prison for both and then medals. You are OK with that?
Re:Ross Ulbricht Convicted of Running Silk Road as Dread Pir... by tptacek on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @09:13PM (#9001385)
I'm not OK with honoring Chuck Colson, either.
Re:Ross Ulbricht Convicted of Running Silk Road as Dread Pir... by jqm on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @09:24PM (#9001414)
Relieved to hear that because I didn't really want to give Ulbricht a medal either.
Re:Ross Ulbricht Convicted of Running Silk Road as Dread Pir... by jqm on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @08:55PM (#9001318)
One line snark forgiven. The key word here is "seems".

He was a physics student, an eagle scout, he started a book recycling business that gave 10% to charity. He had some (however misguided) philosophical ideas. He got poison ivy picking trash out of a tree for Pete's sake. Positive qualities... and there are plenty more.

If you sat down and had a beer with the guy I guess you wouldn't think "criminal". I'm betting if you sat down and had a beer with Sammy Gravano you would be hard pressed not to think that.

Re:Ross Ulbricht Convicted of Running Silk Road as Dread Pir... by dredmorbius on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @06:10PM (#9000691)
For once we're in agreement.
Re:Ross Ulbricht Convicted of Running Silk Road as Dread Pir... by eastbayjake on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @04:53PM (#9000202)
Isn't this trial the sort of thing that "discourages criminal activity"? There were a lot of people who thought they could violate federal law under the anonymity of Tor, and now a lot of would-be perpetrators are aware that federal investigators do have the resources to find you.

They're definitely making an example of DPR, and I don't have a problem with that. Money laundering? Drug trafficking? Hiring hit men? If a New Jersey mobster had faced these charges for meatspace crimes, he'd certainly be spending the rest of his life in jail. (We can have a conversation about whether consenting adults should be able to purchase and use drugs, but there's no doubt he intentionally and repeatedly violated many existing federal laws.)

Re:Ross Ulbricht Convicted of Running Silk Road as Dread Pir... by jqm on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @05:00PM (#9000264)
Na, the Jersey tough guy would probably just rat out some accomplices and soon be living under an assumed identity in Arizona.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sammy_Gravano

Unlike DPR, this guy had a lifetime of criminal history dating back to childhood and actually did personally commit a number of murders.

Re:Ross Ulbricht Convicted of Running Silk Road as Dread Pir... by genericuser on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @05:24PM (#9000416)
Yes, and if there were a person above DPR he was willing to rat out I am confident they would let him do the same.
Re:Ross Ulbricht Convicted of Running Silk Road as Dread Pir... by WalterBright on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @05:02PM (#9000272)
The justice system should be about justice, not making an example, or sending a message, or those other things.
Re:Ross Ulbricht Convicted of Running Silk Road as Dread Pir... by eastbayjake on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @05:05PM (#9000292)
Let me rephrase that: the goal of the justice system here is to punish someone who violated some serious federal laws, but the media attention around the case has the side-effect of deterring others from believing Tor can help you commit crimes with impunity. It seems just that DPR is being treated like any mobster or gangster who laundered money earned through illegal activity.
Re:Ross Ulbricht Convicted of Running Silk Road as Dread Pir... by aidenn0 on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @06:02PM (#9000636)
I think people disagree with that. At least some of the point for punishing people for crimes is to serve as a deterrent.
Re:Ross Ulbricht Convicted of Running Silk Road as Dread Pir... by jMyles on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @04:55PM (#9000220)
> Money laundering? Drug trafficking? Hiring hit men?

One of these things is not like the others.

Re:Ross Ulbricht Convicted of Running Silk Road as Dread Pir... by TheOtherHobbes on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @05:04PM (#9000284)
>Money laundering? Drug trafficking? Hiring hit men?

Best left to the professionals:

http://www.theguardian.com/world/2011/apr/03/us-bank-mexico-...

Re:Ross Ulbricht Convicted of Running Silk Road as Dread Pir... by FireBeyond on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @04:54PM (#9000214)
Youthful indiscretion? Come on, he's about to turn thirty.

It's not an indiscretion to spend a few years running a drug dealing marketplace and planning to find fame through publicity deals, books, movies, beyond the mere quarter of a billion dollar fortune amassed.

Re:Ross Ulbricht Convicted of Running Silk Road as Dread Pir... by jqm on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @09:31PM (#9001434)
Haven't you heard? Peter Thiel is planning to live to 120. We are now authorized to play the "youthful indiscretion" card until age 35.
Re:Ross Ulbricht Convicted of Running Silk Road as Dread Pir... by dietrichepp on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @06:31PM (#9000802)
> youthful indiscretion

He's 29, and the "indiscretion" was a carefully planned and run drug trafficking empire, with millions of dollars in profit. This isn't some college kid who got caught selling Aderall to his friends.

Re:Ross Ulbricht Convicted of Running Silk Road as Dread Pir... by baby on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @04:56PM (#9000233)
The problem is that it can be so easy and at the same time so damaging to be a "cyber criminal" that you have to impose severe sentences even if the criminals were just being young and stupid.

Now did he really do any damages by operating SR? I really don't know...

Re:Ross Ulbricht Convicted of Running Silk Road as Dread Pir... by ninguem2 on Wednesday February 04, 2015 @05:08PM (#9000311)
Your definition of smart must be very different from mine. And of good as well, but never mind that.