News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:My Gravity lawsuit and how it affects every writer who se... by tptacek on Sunday February 01, 2015 @07:27PM (#8982240)
The notion of an "original" product causally linked to the WB-produced film _Gravity_ assumes facts not in evidence.

Gerritsen alleges that the film she worked with Katja on formed a basis for WB's film by dint of Cuaron's involvement in both projects. In the earlier project, Cuaron is alleged to have been "attached" to the project. In the WB production, Cuaron and his son wrote the entire screenplay.

The film term of art "attached" doesn't have a precise meaning. "Attached" can be an indicator of someone's commitment to a project --- a spectrum from "aware of" through "interested in" through "attached" through "committed". It could also mean that the person is sponsoring the project and shepherding it through the development process.

At no point does Gerritsen allege that Cuaron's screenplay included any of Gerritsen's writing. At best, her claim is to the storyline --- the ideas --- of the WB film.

What Gerritsen is saying --- informally, in explaining her reason for deciding to pursue the case, and also in rebutting WB's claim that Gerritsen had already conceded the film wasn't based on her work --- is that she had always felt that the WB project had an uncanny resemblance to her own story, but that she didn't have a smoking gun until she discovered Cuaron has been "attached" to the earlier project without her knowledge.

The fact that the author of the book and a contributor to the punch-up of the screenplay was unaware that one of the most famous directors in Hollywood was "attached" to the project suggests that the word "attached" was meant in its more casual meaning.

But the fact that Cuaron and his son wrote a screenplay involving a novice astronaut marooned on the ISS after being made aware of a project with a similar story suggests that there's some link.

Re:My Gravity lawsuit and how it affects every writer who se... by chriscub on Monday February 02, 2015 @03:04AM (#8983177)
The important part to me is why WB says it owes Gerritsen nothing. If the case is "We admit the movie had a relationship to her work, but that doesn't matter because it was New Line's contract not WB's", there is a very big problem here.

On the other hand, if they convince a judge/jury that there was no connection between her book and the movie then fine. Case closed, go home, no worries.

The key problem here is that if a studio can do a neat little legal dance to avoid contract obligations then that is a big deal. If this is simply a matter of evidence not supporting the claims in this instance then not a big deal.

Re:My Gravity lawsuit and how it affects every writer who se... by WillNotDownvote on Monday February 02, 2015 @12:51AM (#8982890)
Cuaron wasn't super-famous in 2000. He basically had one mid-budget feature under his belt. Add in the fact that writers usually get left out of the loop on that part of the dealmaking and it's not hard to imagine he was more attached than not.
Re:My Gravity lawsuit and how it affects every writer who se... by zobzu on Sunday February 01, 2015 @08:44PM (#8982400)
Which is what the lawsuit is based upon really - that's said, the title is the same, the story is very similar, and it seems extremely likely that the author is accurate, even thus it may be difficult to prove (and easy to disprove, WB can just delete all the files where she's mentioned during the acquisition and then she just has her own word for it, emails being easy to fake and all)
Re:My Gravity lawsuit and how it affects every writer who se... by WillPostForFood on Monday February 02, 2015 @01:04AM (#8982916)
The stories are not similar at all. The similarity is the title, that both are sci-fi, and that there is a female lead. Judge for yourself:

Book: Dr. Emma Watson has been training for the adventure of a lifetime: to study living beings in space. But her mission aboard the International Space Station turns into a nightmare beyond imagining when a culture of single-celled organisms begins to regenerate out of control -- and infects the space station crew with agonizing and deadly results. Emma struggles to contain the outbreak while back on Earth her estranged husband, Jack McCallum, works frantically with NASA to bring her home. But there will be no rescue. The contagion now threatens Earth's population, and the astronauts are stranded in orbit, quarantined aboard the station -- where they are dying one by one...

Movie: Dr. Ryan Stone (Sandra Bullock) is a brilliant medical engineer on her first shuttle mission, with veteran astronaut Matt Kowalsky (George Clooney) in command of his last flight before retiring. But on a seemingly routine spacewalk, disaster strikes. The shuttle is destroyed, leaving Stone and Kowalsky completely alone - tethered to nothing but each other and spiraling out into the blackness.

Re:My Gravity lawsuit and how it affects every writer who se... by clay_to_n on Monday February 02, 2015 @01:16AM (#8982943)
Are you intentionally ignoring this claim by the author?

While my film was in development, I re-wrote the third act of the film script with scenes of satellite debris destroying ISS and the lone surviving female astronaut adrift in her spacesuit.

Re:My Gravity lawsuit and how it affects every writer who se... by warfangle on Monday February 02, 2015 @06:30AM (#8983686)
Probably. Their account was created 9 days ago and has only a few comments under it, none of which are meaningful in any sense. They're either a troll or an account owned by an Astroturf network.
Re:My Gravity lawsuit and how it affects every writer who se... by rory096 on Monday February 02, 2015 @09:03AM (#8984152)
Those are some bold accusations. I don't see how their comment history supports them being anything but a new member.

https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=WillPostForFood