This isn't to say that that state of the world is worse. It might be better! Certainly we shouldn't discount the burden it places on people to feel guilty over their debts. That's real cost to them and to society generally. But if the social norms around debt changed, they wouldn't change in a vacuum. Probably rates would go up and that's a real cost as well.
You make a perfect case of justifying that the cost of providing the lending service would be higher. However, prices are not defined by cost. They are defined, loosely, by what the market can bear. The cost is a lower limit, but nothing more. Namely, it does not define the price.
For the price of a good or service to approach cost of goods, you need very strong and constant competitive pressure. The banking market, in most countries, is not nearly competitive enough.
You don't think money lending is competitive enough? You can get loans for houses, cars and school at just a few points over the risk-free rate.
I'd say the banking market is very competitive since they are all offering the same thing, money (a commodity).
How would you feel if your parents passed away with unpaid debt? Although not legally obliged to pay it, many people do [0]. I, personally, would feel a little sadness to know that my parents had unpaid bills. Nor would I abuse the system by taking out large debts on my death bed.
[0] http://www.nytimes.com/2009/03/04/business/04dead.html?pagew...
It depends. If they owed a real human being, I would probably pay it. If it was a faceless corporate conglomerate, or a bank that reported millions in profits on the last quarter, I wouldn't bother.
Of course you want to pick priorities in what to pay and what to not pay when in difficulty.
And negotiation/consolidation is an alternative
Just keep in mind your credit score will go down the drain, and yeah, maybe you can't get another credit card to hang yourself with, which might be a good thing
I was taught by my parents, and by the books I read and TV shows I watched, that "paying your debts" made you a good person. If you don't pay your debts you're slacking. We've all heard the parables of the great person who went broke, but managed to pay his debtors later even though he legally didn't have to.
What hogwash. Lenders get paid interest in compensation for the risk that the loan might go bad. They deny credit to people if the risk is too high. That's their business. If you borrow to start a business and the business goes south, that's not a moral issue - it's built into the bank's models. Turning it into a moral issue, rather than "just bizness", is just a way for the lenders to shift the risk - that you're paying for - back to you. It's like buying insurance and then not collecting for your burnt house, because you didn't work hard enough to put out the fire.
OK, sucky analogy, but you can bet that people like Donald Trump don't worry about the morality of debt when one of their companies go broke. It's in the contract.