An open exchange of long form ideas between a network of people who each run their own blog has an important place in internet culture, but it doesn't scale very well. It was a golden age, for a time, but the aggregation model as the potential to open those ideas up to a much broader range of people.
[0] I'm actually not sure if the AP allows people to easily "follow" all stories filed by specific reporters, but it doesn't seem like it.
The main idea is consistency.
There's a consistent interface and experience to hacker news, reddit, and even facebook.
Not only that, there's a consistent community. HN is HN, reddit groups by subreddits, and Facebook is your personal social circle.
When I click through to a new blog, I have no idea what to expect, and a few bad websites ruin my expectation of all the good ones.
-- that applies to both the interface and the community. Both are foreign and unfamiliar.
On the other hand, I don't know that I'd call the blogosphere vibrant or even very interesting: Crappy mobile browers/keyboards, link aggregators, Facebook, and Twitter basically shot the web as we knew it dead for the mainstream. My intuition is that this is a natural consequence response to decentralization when the tools to gather your information into one place are poor. You wind up with link aggregators, and then comments on them, and then the link aggregators become the content. Like what's going right now in this thread, instead of a blog link bouncing around between disparate interlinked blog posts.