Kid-me would have been absolutely shocked at how many potential candy-bars/toys/etc. are being spent on adult things like rent or gas or insurance.
I think starting talk about budgeting and managing money needs to happen at the same time as kids learning about how money works. I never had a time that I knew about money but didn't know about budgeting; they went hand in hand. Because of this, I have never had any of the standard financial issues a lot of my peers had (never ran up credit card debt, always lived within my means, saved for retirement from my first job, etc).
I guess my question is more "Why NOT share this important life information with your kids early on? What is the point of keeping it from them?"
All we knew was that we were living within our means, that mom and dad made enough - but that more was always better - and that the family budget was always made to fit inside my mom's (lower) salary, just in case.
Worked out well. We knew better than to bug him for stuff. He ended up socking a bunch away. And, we still managed to learn about the value of money when we got our own jobs - as kids.
All without knowing exactly how much my parents made.
I knew where all the paperwork was kept in the house and had access to the safety deposit box where he kept copies.
Although I do understand if money is really tight, then you might not want to worry the kids.
As in real poor, not, I bought a 4 bedroom house with a huge tv and boat and now I'm worried about being laid off self induced poor, but struggling poor.
Huh? Really? That's radical? I always knew how much my mom made. Do parents really keep this from their children, the same way they keep it from other coworkers?