News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:LibreOffice 4.4, the Most Beautiful LibreOffice Ever by JadeNB on Thursday January 29, 2015 @10:36AM (#8966671)
I downvoted. If you want to use the ribbon-style MS UI, then use MS products. I am glad to have a place to go that allows me to read and edit ubiquitous Office documents without having to be part of the Office eco-system. I agree that LibreOffice probably reminds more of old than of modern Office—I use both as little as possible, so don't keep up with the trends—but so what? To put it differently, why should Microsoft automatically be celebrated for monkeying with an input regime that worked? What is wrong with 'classic' software?
Re:LibreOffice 4.4, the Most Beautiful LibreOffice Ever by k-mcgrady on Thursday January 29, 2015 @11:25AM (#8967041)
>> I downvoted.

Don't down vote people simply because you disagree with them. Just because you don't agree with their opinion doesn't mean it should be hidden from others. Use the down vote to hide comments that don't add to the discussion.

Re:LibreOffice 4.4, the Most Beautiful LibreOffice Ever by JadeNB on Thursday January 29, 2015 @05:29PM (#8969311)
> Don't down vote people simply because you disagree with them. Just because you don't agree with their opinion doesn't mean it should be hidden from others.

To be honest, I got angry and clicked the downvote arrow without sufficient consideration, then thought (since I couldn't undo it) that the civil thing to do was to explain.

Re:LibreOffice 4.4, the Most Beautiful LibreOffice Ever by anonbanker on Thursday January 29, 2015 @12:32PM (#8967585)
Your personal moderation guidelines are admirable, but as they aren't in any way in-line with the moderation guidelines of the site, perhaps you should treat them like spiritual beliefs, and keep them to yourself?

EDIT: s/like your/like/g (unintentional ad-hominem)

Re:LibreOffice 4.4, the Most Beautiful LibreOffice Ever by k-mcgrady on Thursday January 29, 2015 @01:02PM (#8967785)
Where did I mention spiritual beliefs??? As for these being my guidelines - they aren't. In my time using HN I've seen many, many people advocate that guideline. It might be useful to rethink your attitude when commenting your average karma is less than one.
Re:LibreOffice 4.4, the Most Beautiful LibreOffice Ever by DanBC on Thursday January 29, 2015 @01:53PM (#8968088)
There are a group of people who suggest that downvoting should only be used to hide comments that don't add to discussion.

PG has said that downvote to disagree is acceptable.

Can you point to anything in the guidelines or introductions or faqs about not downvotig for disagreement?

Since it's impossible to eliminate downvotig for disagreement you may as well just let it happen.

Re:LibreOffice 4.4, the Most Beautiful LibreOffice Ever by k-mcgrady on Thursday January 29, 2015 @02:17PM (#8968246)
There definitely isn't anything in the guidelines pointing towards either behaviour. I totally respect PG's opinion on it. I find though that HN fosters better discussion that other sites because unpopular opinions are just down votes - they're debated and not hidden. I could just let it happen but hopefully by contributing my thoughts on it those who down vote for disagreement will change.
Re:LibreOffice 4.4, the Most Beautiful LibreOffice Ever by anonbanker on Thursday January 29, 2015 @01:47PM (#8968046)
Yeah, I edited it, but understand I figured you were the kind of person who wouldn't barf all over a thread with your spiritual beliefs, and meant that part as a compliment.

I've advocated your same guidelines in the past, as they promote a healthy site/forum, but they are not HN's guidelines. PG has actually encouraged the antithesis of your guidelines in the past, so I'm compelled to tell you as much.

Re:LibreOffice 4.4, the Most Beautiful LibreOffice Ever by k-mcgrady on Thursday January 29, 2015 @02:19PM (#8968259)
Sure that's fine. It's definitely not part of the guidelines (as you said) but I think it's also fine for me to advocate what I think leads to better discussions. It's one of the reasons I enjoy HN. Unlike other sites there is less hive mind. Unpopular opinions are debated rather than just hidden.
Re:LibreOffice 4.4, the Most Beautiful LibreOffice Ever by anonbanker on Friday January 30, 2015 @01:49AM (#8970786)
If you're suggesting that we should, as a site, act against the guidelines and push for unofficial guidelines that promote better posting, I think this is a fantastic idea.
Re:LibreOffice 4.4, the Most Beautiful LibreOffice Ever by minimaxir on Thursday January 29, 2015 @12:59PM (#8967752)
Ad hominem attacks, however, are clearly not in-line with moderation guidelines. :P
Re:LibreOffice 4.4, the Most Beautiful LibreOffice Ever by anonbanker on Thursday January 29, 2015 @01:40PM (#8968009)
Can you let me know where I made an ad-hominem? None was intended, but I'd like to correct that record.

Edit: ah. Everyone assumed I was talking about ggparent's spiritual beliefs. Amazing how a sole personal pronoun can alter intent.

Re:LibreOffice 4.4, the Most Beautiful LibreOffice Ever by scholia on Thursday January 29, 2015 @10:51AM (#8966782)
Classic software worked just fine, in its day. I can still remember most of the classic WordStar commands. ;-)

The celebrations come when there are significant improvements, and there have been plenty of those. The (web-inspired) tabbed Office ribbon was a big one. Sorry they moved your cheese but the rest of the world isn't going to stop progressing even if you do.

Re:LibreOffice 4.4, the Most Beautiful LibreOffice Ever by pbhjpbhj on Thursday January 29, 2015 @11:06AM (#8966883)
>Classic software worked just fine, in its day. //

So, it doesn't work now?

The main question would be 'how much more productive one can be now than before?'. It would be nice if there were independent quantative studies on this - as word-processor use is a central part of most governments administrative functions I'd imagine that one can't move for the vast number of such studies ... lol.

I'm guessing that the UI changes between Wordstar and Office 2015 amount to a tiny change in the time needed both for training and useful production of word-processed documents. When it comes to spreadsheets I can see things have probably moved on - at least in speed of processing if nothing else.

I'd love to ask, of the top 100 functions used - how many weren't in office applications 5 years ago, 10 years ago? How has the average time per word in production of business letters changed (reduced?) over time and what specific [versions of] applications caused the greatest change?

Re:LibreOffice 4.4, the Most Beautiful LibreOffice Ever by scholia on Thursday January 29, 2015 @11:35AM (#8967133)
I'd love to have answers to the same questions, but it will vary a lot according to what is being done and who is doing it.

If you're just typing simple text documents, the current Word is not going to save a massive amount of time over WordStar, but it will save some thanks to spelling corrections etc. And even a few seconds per hour per worker can represent a lot of value for large organizations.

If you're doing an essay or a brochure with headlines in different fonts, double-column text, embedded pictures, math equations etc, then the time savings will be massive. Just the ability to move a pic while text flows around it provides huge benefits.

When my son was in his early teens, I watched him use Microsoft Office to create complex documents that would have taken an IBM PROFS mainframe user weeks, or might have been impossible. His homework looked more professional than IBM's corporate documents.

I guess there are plenty of workers who use Word at the same level as they used WordStar, or who reckon that (back on topic!) LO is just as good. (Yes, LO is almost as good as Word if you just want to replace WordStar.)

But are those our criteria? Should we ignore the fact that people who have open minds and a willingness to explore (like children) can quickly and easily do new things that they can't?

Re:LibreOffice 4.4, the Most Beautiful LibreOffice Ever by vertex-four on Thursday January 29, 2015 @11:25AM (#8967044)
Productivity isn't really the benchmark for LibreOffice, at least not until they're close to 100% compatible with the latest version of Office. Compatibility with everybody else's bizarre, overcomplicated, crappy files is the benchmark, and they use a hell of a lot more features than WordStar ever had.

I'd prefer to have a product with a crappy UI that can interoperate with everybody else seamlessly, than one with a great, simple UI that can't.

Re:LibreOffice 4.4, the Most Beautiful LibreOffice Ever by DanBC on Thursday January 29, 2015 @05:26PM (#8969289)
Spreadsheets are the scary bit of software -- they're used for everything. And when I say "they" I mean "MS Excel" mostly.

There are groups that investigate the risks. EUSPRIG (European Spreadsheet Risk interest Group) has some great documents. http://www.eusprig.org/quotes.htm

I don't know if anyone is testing the main spreadsheet software with fuzzer-like tools; or if there are any mass audits of spreedsheets. Both would be useful.

Re:LibreOffice 4.4, the Most Beautiful LibreOffice Ever by JadeNB on Thursday January 29, 2015 @05:23PM (#8969272)
> Sorry they moved your cheese but the rest of the world isn't going to stop progressing even if you do.

I was not complaining about progress (which, in this case, I would simply call change). I was merely responding to drzaiusapelord's complaint about LibreOffice not 'keeping up' with MS Office by expressing my appreciation for the existence of a more 'classical' alternative.

Re:LibreOffice 4.4, the Most Beautiful LibreOffice Ever by Argorak on Thursday January 29, 2015 @11:22AM (#8967010)
Upvoted. For explaining your downvote instead of just throwing it out there and mentioning a perfectly valid sentiment, even if I don't fully agree.