Re:'YOUTUBE is EVIL': Somebody had a tape running, Google
by icebraining on Thursday January 29, 2015 @10:04AM
(#8966481)
Um, last I heard, unless you pay them, Github requires you to make any code you upload open-source and publicly available.
Publicly available yes, open source no. You're free to choose whatever license you want:
You're under no obligation to choose a license. It's your right not to include one with your code or project, but please be aware of the implications. Generally speaking, the absence of a license means that the default copyright laws apply. This means that you retain all rights to your source code and that nobody else may reproduce, distribute, or create derivative works from your work.
Re:'YOUTUBE is EVIL': Somebody had a tape running, Google
by ldng on Thursday January 29, 2015 @11:45AM
(#8967210)
The requirement used to be open-source and publicly available
It is now only publicly available
Re:'YOUTUBE is EVIL': Somebody had a tape running, Google
by dagw on Thursday January 29, 2015 @10:09AM
(#8966505)
All github require for their free users is that they're OK code is made viewable to the world. Nothing about github requires open source and you're free to chose any license you want.
Re:'YOUTUBE is EVIL': Somebody had a tape running, Google
by aidos on Thursday January 29, 2015 @10:19AM
(#8966558)
By your analogy, any code you put on bitbucket would also have to be uploaded to github at the same time.
Re:'YOUTUBE is EVIL': Somebody had a tape running, Google
by nothrabannosir on Thursday January 29, 2015 @01:04PM
(#8967806)
Yeah that was not a good comparison; the problem here is that the contract applies to all music released by the artist for 5 years, not just what is uploaded to Youtube. This is vastly, vastly more restrictive than Github. Not even close.
If Github did this, they would lose everyone overnight.
That does, however, suggest to me an option (c) that Google isn't offering: Musicians pay Google to run Content Id on their behalf to simplify the takedown process. While I'm sure there are some win-wins they're missing by not offering that (possibly including Zoë Keating), I really can't fault them for that. I expect the PR and legal complications would dwarf the storm that's already here.