News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tech billionaire’s gnarly fight with California surfers o... by tptacek on Friday January 23, 2015 @12:18PM (#8935973)
Is there any other side to this story, or is Khosla really a third-tier Bond villain?

Usually, news stories that read as black-and-white as this one are spun somehow. But here I can't figure out how. Beyond it being odd for a billionaire to embark on a legally futile quest to kick people off a beach at the expense of nearly his entire reputation.

Re:Tech billionaire’s gnarly fight with California surfers o... by MiguelVieira on Friday January 23, 2015 @12:33PM (#8936073)
Here it is http://www.sfgate.com/science/article/Vinod-Khosla-blames-co...

"Khosla said he kept the beach open after the sale despite the $500,000 to $600,000 a year in costs for maintenance, liability insurance, infrastructure and other expenses. He said insurance alone was $30,000 a year, but he kept the beach open for two years even though he was losing money....Most of the beach has eroded away over the years and it is often dangerous, with sneaker waves and riptides, he said. He said only two or three people a day were visiting the beach and it was unreasonable to expect him to pay the costs to maintain public access....Khosla said he tried for three years to get a hearing with the Coastal Commission in an attempt to come up with a reasonable solution, but the organization refused."

Re:Tech billionaire’s gnarly fight with California surfers o... by mhomde on Friday January 23, 2015 @12:41PM (#8936138)
Wait I'm confused, does he own the beach or just the gate which accesses the beach? And why is he responsible and needs to be insured for people using the beach, or maintain it?

It feels like either you own the beach and can do whatever the heck you please, or you don't, and then it's not your dime nor your responsibility...

PR nightmare though, anyone made a flash-game where you try to sneak upon Khosla's beach while being hunted by him and his security guards yet?

Re:Tech billionaire’s gnarly fight with California surfers o... by mcphage on Friday January 23, 2015 @02:03PM (#8936577)
> does he own the beach or just the gate which accesses the beach?

Just the gate. All beaches in CA are public property.

Re:Tech billionaire’s gnarly fight with California surfers o... by FireBeyond on Friday January 23, 2015 @01:16PM (#8936311)
Yeah, this is disingenuous. No-one is requiring him to have liability insurance for beachgoers, and it'd be a pretty laughable attempt to sue him for any incident at the beach.
Re:Tech billionaire’s gnarly fight with California surfers o... by tankenmate on Friday January 23, 2015 @01:38PM (#8936435)
The insurance is not likely for the surf side of the beach but for the area above high tide and the access to the beach.
Re:Tech billionaire’s gnarly fight with California surfers o... by FireBeyond on Friday January 23, 2015 @03:20PM (#8937019)
I think you'd have a fairly good case that you could not be held liable for for injury that occurred on an easement (actually, scratch that, I changed my mind and IANAL... given that an easement is non-possessive, you still own the property... but at what level are you required to make it safe?)
Re:Tech billionaire’s gnarly fight with California surfers o... by MrDom on Friday January 23, 2015 @07:25PM (#8938254)
I don't know the pertinent CA laws, but in NY you can be fined for not shoveling snow off of your sidewalk and you are required to keep the sidewalk in good repair. If the sidewalk is broken and somebody trips, you can get fined by the city and/or sued by the ankle breaker. If it needs to be replaced, you're expected to do it yourself with your own money or be fined.
Re:Tech billionaire’s gnarly fight with California surfers o... by nostromo on Friday January 23, 2015 @12:26PM (#8936028)
I'll play devil's advocate and argue his position (even though it's not my own):

People hang out all day around Khosla's house. In order to access the beach, they have to cross his property. It feels like trespassing, although it's legal in this case. Sometimes they park where they shouldn't. Sometimes they are loud and disrespectful. Sometimes someone litters. Quite often people trespass on his portion of the beach, as there is no clear markings delineating public and private property. The gate that leads to the beach is clearly his, so he has decided not to open it and facilitate access anymore. Leaving the gate open at night is perhaps seen by his security staff to be inviting problems.

Now, here's my actual position: don't like surfers? Don't buy beach property in California.

Re:Tech billionaire’s gnarly fight with California surfers o... by foobarqux on Friday January 23, 2015 @12:42PM (#8936145)
Does he actually live there?
Re:Tech billionaire’s gnarly fight with California surfers o... by pavlov on Friday January 23, 2015 @12:28PM (#8936035)
He's only risking his reputation in the eyes of the public, not his peers.

Probably there are quite a few rich Californians who would be happy to see Khosla win, are backing him privately and are grateful to him for volunteering as the public villain.

Re:Tech billionaire’s gnarly fight with California surfers o... by thoman23 on Friday January 23, 2015 @12:37PM (#8936105)
If only it were clearly legally futile. When you are a billionaire, NOTHING is legally futile. You get to help make the laws. I am still pessimistically thinking he will eventually find a way to have his way.

With that being said, I'll never understand why people who have so much already would be so eager to have a little more at the expense of most of the public hating you.

Re:Tech billionaire’s gnarly fight with California surfers o... by dragonwriter on Friday January 23, 2015 @12:55PM (#8936208)
> If only it were clearly legally futile. When you are a billionaire, NOTHING is legally futile. You get to help make the laws.

In general, sure, wealth and political power do correlate pretty strongly.

In this particular case of this particular wealthy person and this particular area of politics, well, there has been a law passed directly as a result of this controversy [0], and its one that Khosla tried to stop [1].

> With that being said, I'll never understand why people who have so much already would be so eager to have a little more at the expense of most of the public hating you.

People who end up having so much often do so because they aren't the kind of person who ever is not seeking out every way to have more.

[0] http://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billNavClient.xhtml?...

[1] http://martinsbeach.blogspot.com/2014/05/khosla-hires-lobbyi...

Re:Tech billionaire’s gnarly fight with California surfers o... by FireBeyond on Friday January 23, 2015 @01:19PM (#8936327)
Mmhmm. They're threatening him with fines of $10K a day.

Oh no. Khosla is worth $1.7B. Every year this goes by costs him almost 0.2% of his net worth. In five hundred years, they'll bankrupt him.

He's earning that much a day in interest on investments alone. Why would he care?

Re:Tech billionaire’s gnarly fight with California surfers o... by dragonwriter on Friday January 23, 2015 @01:41PM (#8936450)
He probably doesn't, and any level of fine that would be reasonable to authorize in a general law would probably fail to deter him. Which is probably why a law passed last year empowers the State Land Commission to acquire a new access easement across the specific property at issue for public use, independent of whatever is already due to the public under state law, either by negotiation or condemnation if negotiation fails to secure an agreement by Jan. 1, 2016.