News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:On Artificial Intelligence by dragonwriter on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @08:06PM (#8926885)
> Furthermore, machines do not develop when left in isolation, while biological organisms do.

Biological organisms are machines.

Entities which meet the necessary requirements for Darwinian evolution (which are, approximately, that they can pass on their traits from generation to generation, have a source for variability, and have selective pressure in the environment) change over successive generations, and all kinds of machines change individually over time in response to interactions with the environment (in fact, pretty much all physical objects do.) Biological organisms obviously meet the requirements for Darwinian evolution (since that's where it was first observed and described), but there's no magic "biological sauce" required.

> I do not think artificial intelligence can arise naturally because its components are not natural.

The whole natural/artificial divide is unsound, since humans, and hence all of their products, are part of and products of nature. Nothing not-natural exists.

> Personally, I believe artificial intelligence does not require biological components, and I believe that under certain circumstances, it could develop unintentionally from a relatively advanced computer, but that is not the same as naturally.

The whole thing about artificial intelligence arising naturally is a strawman you've constructed. You've just agreed with and illustrated my argument -- which is that artificial intelligence does not require understanding intelligence.

Re:On Artificial Intelligence by dsacco on Thursday January 22, 2015 @01:34AM (#8927872)
> Biological organisms are machines.

No, I think we're arguing two different things here. I don't mean machines in the sense of a deterministic mechanism, I mean machines in the sense of a non-biological computer.

Machines do not have generations. Machines are not alive. I can simplify this: we do not yet have computers which are alive, thus they fundamentally do not operate the same way humans do in terms of evolution. This circles back to what I said about leaving machines alone to develop in an evolutionary sense - they won't, they'll die.

Machines do not yet improve themselves after a certain "age" of maturation.

The natural/artificial divide is not unsound, because artificial means something which is created by a human, and natural means something which is not. There are definitions of these terms and philosophical schools of thought that make this divide unsound, but colloquially, I don't mean those in this context.

Here is the basic point I'm trying to make - human beings arose naturally with no apparent intelligence to guide them into existence. Machines did not do so. You can argue they did because "everything is natural", but that's not my point here. They are fundamentally different from human beings and only exist because human beings existed first.

You can't compare the relationship between an Intelligent Design and human species and the relationship between machines and humans for this reason because they are the opposite. Humans apparently have no guiding force that opted to create them or guide their existence, whereas machines do - us.

That is what I mean by natural. I think an intelligence can arise naturally, but only if it follows the natural conduits that would form conventional intelligence, which is via biological organisms.

In order to replicate what happened through evolution using a completely different "container" if you will, you'd need to be able to understand intelligence completely, or at least enough to implement it.

Ultimately, intelligence never arises from non-organic components (at least not on Earth). To make it do so where it would not ordinarily happen is what I mean by artificial versus natural. And to do that is to essentially reverse-engineer intelligence itself, which would require understanding it.

I apologize if I'm still not being clear, but does this make my point any better?

Re:On Artificial Intelligence by dragonwriter on Thursday January 22, 2015 @08:40AM (#8929039)
You keep positing invalid distinction between biological and otger mechanisms. There is nothing limiting generations to biological mechanisms. Consider von Neumann's universal constructors or, for purely software mechanisms, the agents within Avida.

We do, in fact, now have machines -- in the software sense -- that have all features necessary for Darwinian evolution to operate. We don't yet have that for hardware devices, but we're fairly close, and we certainly don't need to understand intelligence do build such self-replicating hardware/software systems (though the universality of computation suggests we don't need hardware/software systems, since anything they can exhibit, pure software systems can as well.)

The problem isn't that you haven't explained yourself well, it's that your argument rests on a fundamental distinction between natural biological organisms and all other machines which does not exist.

Re:On Artificial Intelligence by p1esk on Thursday January 22, 2015 @04:18PM (#8931808)
I think you have to address the parent's argument that machines are not "alive", while biological organisms are.

Of course, first we need to define "alive", and then we should ask: can we build something that will be "alive"?

Do you consider the entities in Avida simulation to be alive? How about biological vs computer viruses? Is there a fundamental difference between them?

If we simulate a biological organism on a atomic level, together with its immediate environment, so that it behaves exactly like its real-world counterpart would, do we call it "alive"?

[dead]
Re:On Artificial Intelligence by F_Lar on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @09:08PM (#8927108)
You can "downvote" my response, but here's a challenge:

You have no idea about how your own ecology works.

You barely understand how 'society' / 'interlinked communications' work between individuals (and your social / psychological sciences are laughable).

The first thing an (unbounded) AI does is link directly into the largest power source it can find (usually a Star) and then start re-organizing QM / magnetospheres to support itself.

Hint: that causes you to die.

Re:On Artificial Intelligence by F_Lar on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @09:39PM (#8927228)
>Biological organisms are machines.

No. They're not.

First rule of dumb people not understanding evolution:

You can be lucky, you can be crappy, you can have some terrible design flaws (hello mammal eyes), but it's enough as long as you survive. Also, evolution works over POPULATIONS, which means that if 10% are ninjas, and 60% are the bog standard model and 30% are the crappy models - if your environment is 'fitted', YOU ALL SURVIVE.

Yep, even the 30% crappy ones!

Hands up who doesn't understand the difference between ADaption and ABaption!

Selection only occurs on a massive time-line or when environmental changes occur or there's a predator/prey war going on. And even then, the crappy crappy 10% can get lucky and still breed. That's why ecology / evolution is fitted over POPULATIONS, not individuals.

AI doesn't work like that, at all (once you get into the real stuff). All AI works on limited models (at the moment).

>Hint: this guy is a muppet, as shown by his attempts to "downvote" counter-arguments.

HN: land of the muppets.

>>On a more serious note, anyone actually working in the field of AI development knows this already. HN proving that... it doesn't. #Dragonswhoarenotdragons