News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:You’ll Always Miss Being in the Basement by austerity on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @08:58AM (#8923046)
> Aren't organizations built for maximizing profits inherently on a lower moral ground than non-profit organizations[1]?

No, certainly not inherently. Even if we define moral ground as the degree of altruism of motives (which is way too narrow in my opinion), non-profits do not inherently pursue altruistic goals, but rather non-monetizable goals.

But if we define it as something that the society should encourage because it's beneficial to the society then for-profits are arguably on a higher ground since they are demonstrably beneficial to people who are willingly giving them money while all some non-profits can show in their defense is abstract ideas. KKK is a non-profit.

Re:You’ll Always Miss Being in the Basement by mikegioia on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @09:10AM (#8923103)

    But if we define it as something that the society should
    encourage because it's beneficial to the society then
    for-profits are arguably on a higher ground ... KKK is a
    non-profit.
And Comcast is a company. Just because people give money to an organization and extract value from it doesn't mean society should encourage that company's behavior. Your argument makes no sense. You're saying:

    1. Moral ground is "something society encourages because
       it's beneficial to society"
    2. People give for-profit companies their money
    3. Therefore, companies have a higher moral ground since
       companies are "demonstrably beneficial to people"
How on earth do you arrive at that conclusion? You then throw an example of a bad non-profit (KKK) as I can equally give you an example of a bad company (Comcast) that takes people's money, provides a necessary service to their customers, but is by all accounts one of the worst, most parasitic organizations on the planet.
Re:You’ll Always Miss Being in the Basement by austerity on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @09:33AM (#8923215)
Have you just compared Comcast to KKK?

The reason you don't understand my argument after reinterpreting it is because you have for some reason excluded a few important words from it: "inherently", "should" (as in "should encourage") and "willingly". I am inclined to think your confusion is intentional and therefore explaining myself will be a waste of time.

Re:You’ll Always Miss Being in the Basement by mikegioia on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @01:57PM (#8924772)
Please, that's a cop out. I didn't re-interpret anything and "should" doesn't add anything to that sentence.

    "if we define it as something that the society should encourage
     because it's beneficial to the society then for-profits are
     arguably on a higher ground since they are demonstrably beneficial
     to people who are willingly giving them money"
That's a direct quote from your comment. I merely asked how you got from A to B. How are for-profits "demonstrably beneficial" given your definition of moral ground? You're stating a definition and just stating a conclusion you draw with no actual substance into how you're making that conclusion.

I challenge your statement that for-profits are "demonstrably beneficial" merely because people give them money!

Re:You’ll Always Miss Being in the Basement by yourad_io on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @09:55AM (#8923304)
> Have you just compared Comcast to KKK?

No?

Re:You’ll Always Miss Being in the Basement by yourad_io on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @09:51AM (#8923288)
> KKK is a non-profit.

Technically, yes, but definitely not what I was talking about, as I defined non-profit as an organization which isn't primarily self-interested. The KKK isn't for-profit, but it is for-power, and definitely self-interested. I also included "Sure, there's potential for evil and corruption everywhere" to avoid such a strawman argument.

> non-profits do not inherently pursue altruistic goals

They usually do. But we seem to disagree as to what a non-profit is, so for the sake of the argument, I'm talking about altruistic non-profits, not the KKK. Let's include non-power in that non-profit definition.

> But if we define it as something that the society should encourage because it's beneficial to the society then for-profits are arguably on a higher ground since they are demonstrably beneficial to people who are willingly giving them money

Willingly? In theoretical economics/free markets/etc, sure. In real life, there are monopolies, lobbying, politics and all sorts of bullshit. You are surely aware that as a consumer you're often stuck with picking the least-worst of your options. If there's one ISP serving your area and you hate them, your free will spans between 'no internet' and 'pay those scumbags'.