It's a mostly mechanical process, if you follow the recipe then the predicted outcome is the same, no matter who does the developing.
"Dodging and burning are terms used in photography for a technique used during the printing process to manipulate the exposure of a selected area(s) on a photographic print, deviating from the rest of the image's exposure. In a darkroom print from a film negative, dodging decreases the exposure for areas of the print that the photographer wishes to be lighter, while burning increases the exposure to areas of the print that should be darker"
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dodging_and_burning
Here see the part on Ansel Adams:
I spent a ton of time in the darkroom of my dad when I was a kid and it's all lots of fun but in the end what wasn't in front of the camera lens is not going to magically appear on the developed film or the prints. At best you'll end up with a derived work, at worst you're destroying a bit of history.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Derivative_work
> Subject to sections 107 through 122, the owner of copyright under this title has the exclusive rights to do and to authorize any of the following:
> (2) to prepare derivative works based upon the copyrighted work;
Developing a negative does not create 'a derivative work', since developing film is not 'interpreting' it in an original way, it for the most part is chemistry. Do it the same way twice you get the same result.
You can prove that to yourself by cutting a roll of film horizontally in half and then developing the two halves independently using the same recipe. If you do it all by the book they'll come out in such a way that the two film halves can be reconnected to give you the whole images.
And if so, just to be clear, you are claiming that there is no difference in results from someone with experience and someone "just following a recipe?".
Sure.
> And if so, just to be clear, you are claiming that there is no difference in results from someone with experience and someone "just following a recipe?".
Oh, definitely there can be a difference. But that difference will never amount to the person in the darkroom being able to supercede the copyright claim of the original photographer.
If its a reproduction of a photography, its no more original, in a copyrightable sense, than creating a forgery. Such actions might require high skill, but high skill is not what make works copyrightable.
Even to the extent that development of a film is copyrightable, it's entirely derivative of the original exposure and certainly can't be considered to subsume it for authorship purposes.
Copyright starts at the moment you press the shutter button.
From: http://www.teachingcopyright.org/handout/copyright-faq
"When does copyright start? Do I have to register the work with the government?
Copyright status is automatic upon creation of your original creative work in a fixed, tangible form. Registration with the U.S. Copyright Office is not necessary for copyright status and protection, though registration is needed in order to pursue an infringement claim in court."
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Personality_rights
Mix them with copyright by photographers (and now apparently by developers if we're to believe some in this thread) and you can feed a pack of lawyers for years.
EDIT: Toned down the snark.
As I mentioned in one of my comments they also developed the film which if not done correctly would result in images that wouldn't look the same as they do now. [1] The film without development has no creative appeal other than the appeal of a film canister.
[1] As anyone who has done photography with a darkroom knows (I have and development is part of what you get just like picture composition is.)