As to the phone number lookup examples, lists of facts cannot be protected under copyright. My understanding is that this extends to indexes of facts as well. Though there may indeed be a presentation or transformative element (which may have copyright protection), the underlying facts (and their indices) do not have copyright protection. I've seen many websites attempting to make this claim with lists, and they make it technically non-trivial to copy the data from their site, but should such a case actually make it to court, I don't think the claim would hold water.
Keep in mind also that they did more than scanning. They took undeveloped film and developed it first. (Which took effort and skill with old film). Without that development the pictures would not exist (see my updated "edit").
"I've seen many websites attempting to make this claim with lists, and they make it technically non-trivial to copy the data from their site, but should such a case actually make it to court, I don't think the claim would hold water."
This is not unusual since most things don't end up in court and what you are trying to do is attempt to scare someone into not taking a chance of infringing. Example is a few years ago we got notices to pay $650 for some images on a website we had from getty images for something that came off of a cd in the 90's (clip art) that was clearly purchased with a license. Getty had no right to do that but they "sprayed and prayed" hoping that some people would pay the $650. Of course it wouldn't hold up in court but there is no doubt that some companies (not ours) paid the $650 (or whatever the amount was don't remember). Nobody goes to court over $650 and hires a lawyer to defend etc.
When I take my roll of film to the chemist for the. To run through their machine; or I send it off to a lab; or I develop it myself; the copyright for the images still stay with me.
Why does developing the film give them any rights?
Another example that I can think of is dnjournal.com which publishes a list of domain sales which they gather primarily (but not exclusively) from easily available info from other sources (like sedo.com). So you are free to do the same from the same sources. However you can't take the list they created, that is lift it from their site, and publish it without violating their copyright.
There may of course be some other principle involved obviously but off the top the above seems possible.
Edit: Appears what I am referring to is possibly a version of "derivative" work:
https://www.legalzoom.com/articles/what-are-derivative-works...
I think this also goes under "the golden rule" meaning he who has the gold rules. The film was undeveloped so someone could argue that that act was instrumental in making the pictures able to be seen (seems like a scotus grade discussion). The original owner took the pictures but he never created the image which people see. The image was created by the person who now claims copyright. Without the developing there are no images. May not win but perhaps most importantly a leg to stand on.