News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What Doesn't Seem Like Work? by ta75757 on Friday January 16, 2015 @06:19PM (#8902436)
As (failed) physics major, it sounds so strange to hear someone claim to be good at math but not physics. To me physics is 98% math. It's a few empirical facts from experiments and then bucketloads of math.
Re:What Doesn't Seem Like Work? by Micaiah_Chang on Friday January 16, 2015 @06:49PM (#8902554)
There are some skills in physics which are sort of foreign to the math method of problem solving. (Speaking as a physics major)

For example, picking a nice reference frame in simple mechanics problems is something that a physical intuition is good for. Same with spotting symmetries in an EM problem. Also, in physics you need to have a good grasp of what to ignore because they have only a small effect on the solution or because it operates on a different scale (fringing effects, transient solutions in ODEs), which often relies on a very hand-wavey type of reasoning.

Essentially, physical intuition often does not map to mathematical intuition

I have not taken enough math to actually speak for them; this is mostly gleaned from talking with math major friends and my own speculations.

Re:What Doesn't Seem Like Work? by jules on Saturday January 17, 2015 @08:35AM (#8904299)
I majored in math and physics. The same kind of intuition that you use for physics you also use for math. In physics you may call it choosing a reference frame, in math you call it choosing a coordinate system. At least for me it's exactly the same kind of thinking. You hit the nail on the head here though:

> Also, in physics you need to have a good grasp of what to ignore because they have only a small effect on the solution or because it operates on a different scale (fringing effects, transient solutions in ODEs), which often relies on a very hand-wavey type of reasoning.

Physics is often taught in an exceedingly vague and hand-wavey way. Physics students have to learn to ignore that nagging feeling that something is not quite right. This is impossible for a mathematician. A mathematician wants to cleanly separate the math from the problem that is being solved using math. The problem specification consists of a list of assumptions, and the solution of the problem consists of 100% rock solid math. Physicists weave the two together, so that in the end it's often not clear what is actually being assumed. Furthermore, it's usually not explained based on which experiments those assumptions are justified. A counterexample is special relativity. There it's clearly assumed that the speed of light is constant, and the experiments on which that assumption is based are explained, and from there it's mostly logical deduction. In other topics that is sadly not the case. I would love a physics education where you start with the experiments and work from there, instead of saying "Bam! Here are Maxwell's differential equations. Now deduce things from that based on hand-wavey arguments". I don't mean having the students perform the experiments themselves, just describe what somebody else did and what the results were, and why that led people to believe that the laws of physics are as they are. To make time for that, we should remove the endless by hand solving of special cases of special cases. We live in the 21st century. Instead use numerical methods everywhere, which easily tackle the general case. Got n electrons with initial positions and initial velocities, and you want to see what happens? No problem.

/rant

Re:What Doesn't Seem Like Work? by gsteinb88 on Saturday January 17, 2015 @11:23AM (#8904626)
Thank you so much for this; you just described my undergraduate experience in physics perfectly, especially the endless nagging feeling that something isn't quite right -- I never managed to make that feeling go away. I ended up taking a bunch of maths courses towards the end of my undergraduate and can still remember one particular functional analysis lecture on dual spaces where I finally figured out what the hell those dual spaces in quantum were about. Sadly, this was after I had struggled through and finished the full quantum sequence.

Ironically though, I ended up drifting into the EECS department to do applied physics and I've found an environment much more similar to mathematics (and to the experiment-based approach you advocate) than to the physics department -- when you're trying to build systems rather than just solve problems, you can't just wave your hands. Instead, you have to pick apart your assumptions and figure out why you can ignore certain things and not others.

Re:What Doesn't Seem Like Work? by jpmattia on Saturday January 17, 2015 @02:37PM (#8905274)
> "Bam! Here are Maxwell's differential equations. Now deduce things from that based on hand-wavey arguments". I don't mean having the students perform the experiments themselves, just describe what somebody else did and what the results were, and why that led people to believe that the laws of physics are as they are.

It's odd that you chose that example, because there is a rich history leading up to Maxwell doing his work, then Hertz verifying it, then Heaviside refactoring the notation.

Perhaps the deeper issue is that there are only so many lecture hours in a semester for adding these details, and you gotta start somewhere.

Re:What Doesn't Seem Like Work? by pmoriarty on Saturday January 17, 2015 @12:28PM (#8904840)
Physicists seem very hand-wavey to mathematicians, and mathematicians seem very hand-wavey to logicians. If you want to learn what real formal rigor is like, study logic.
Re:What Doesn't Seem Like Work? by dxbydt on Friday January 16, 2015 @06:53PM (#8902568)
True, but a lot of chemistry is mostly math too, and I flunked organic chemistry the first time. I think its because there is some domain knowledge involved in these subjects, which you have to actually care about. I don't particularly care which element has how many isotopes and what the valency is and how many other elements it can bond with, though I did memorize the atomic weights of all the elements in the periodic table and Avogardo number and few such stats. Those things helped a little, because I was ultimately able to pass my chemistry exams just by solving the numerical stuff and ignoring the chemical stuff. I handled physics in same fashion . There's something called the distance equation, where you can express the distance travelled by particle in terms of velocity and acceleration. We had to simply memorize that and use it in problems. I forgot what it was in the exam. So I just derived it from definitions. The teacher was quite surprised, because at that stage we hadn't been taught calculus, so how did I derive it ? Well, I had solved calculus problems by myself, so I just did this - http://pastebin.com/T6PrePh8

These things helped me get by.

Re:What Doesn't Seem Like Work? by nnq on Saturday January 17, 2015 @03:30AM (#8903868)
Organic chemistry and biochemistry are very different from physics, but chemistry is a very large field and these are just a small part of it.

You should have been exposed to physical chemistry or computational chemistry or maybe even quantum chemistry or analytical chemistry, if your are mathematically inclined.

...but unfortunately they are considered very advanced topics in most learning institutions, even if one could start with them from the very beginning, instead of "classical chemistry". And more unfortunately, after the tedium of "classical chemistry", what you are presented with next are very boring aspects of "organic chemistry" or "biochemistry".

Re:What Doesn't Seem Like Work? by bostik on Saturday January 17, 2015 @05:21AM (#8904015)
Aiieee, physical chemistry. That thing approaches pure evil.

The chemistry department in the university I studied at required 4 courses of physical chemistry. The introductory course was bad enough - the course had mandatory practice sessions, where assistants were at hand to aid with the supposedly trickier bits. Each session was 1h45m straight.

5 weeks in, there was a supposedly simple exercise. When nobody at the class got even past the initial hurdles in the first 15 minutes, the assistant decided to show how it's done. He failed to finish the calculations in the remaining 90 minutes ... and he knew how the steps went.

Eventually I changed my major from chemistry to CS.

EDIT: btw, the assistant in question was a post-grad so lack of domain knowledge was not the reason.

Re:What Doesn't Seem Like Work? by delian66 on Saturday January 17, 2015 @03:03AM (#8903823)
>> I forgot what it was in the exam. So I just derived it from definitions.

Hah, I did the same :-) ... unfortunately I also forgot the conventional names, and just used 's' (for speed) instead of 'v', and 'd' (for distance) instead of 's'. My teacher did not object the derivation at all, but told me that the results are wrong, because of the letters used ...

Well, point taken - now, I try to pay extra attention and memorize idiosyncrasies like naming conventions ... it saves time when communicating with others.

Re:What Doesn't Seem Like Work? by mirchiseth on Saturday January 17, 2015 @03:23AM (#8903860)
That reminds me of a sessional (mid semester exam in India) when I got confused on speed of light being 3x10^8 m/s or 3x10^9 m/s. Strange are the ways of mind. I knew the relation between c and electric constant and magnetic constant. So derived it from that.
Re:What Doesn't Seem Like Work? by cli on Saturday January 17, 2015 @03:17AM (#8903851)
Organic chemistry is the least or one of the least math-intensive chemistry subjects at the undergraduate level.
Re:What Doesn't Seem Like Work? by analog31 on Friday January 16, 2015 @08:44PM (#8902964)
I was a math + physics double major in college, plus I was also deeply into programming, electronics, and music.

In my view, the starting point for physics is a deep curiosity about how things work. But I'm not sure that aspect of it is ever taught. Rather, it's assumed that good physics students arrive at college, having developed that instinct on their own as kids -- taking things apart, breaking things, asking questions, maybe having curious parents.

Instead, the emphasis in teaching physics is almost purely on the math. Certainly, what defines physics as a unique discipline is the interest in studying problems that lend themselves to mathematical analysis. Solving the textbook problems involves identifying the equations corresponding to the wording of the problem, then solving the equations. That's a skill, but it's not really physics.

I got through my physics courses on the strength of my math skills, but was extremely fortunate to have picked up the empirical half of physics on my own, through my hobbies, and from the curiosity about nature that my parents encouraged. But if someone lacks that background, I could see them being good at math, and maybe getting a good way through school physics, but never really getting physics as an end unto itself.

Re:What Doesn't Seem Like Work? by MarkPNeyer on Friday January 16, 2015 @06:44PM (#8902528)
i was a physics major, too. the student in our year who was best at math had trouble with the "hand wavy" stuff we'd do. "well, this term is basically zero, so we'll just remove it" and then she'd pull her hair in frustration, like "how can you just do that? how is it still valid?"

it wasn't enough to tell her "well it still gives us the valid results" - she had to be able to interpret every portion of an expression and then make intuitive sense of it.

at first i was annoyed with this habit of hers, but eventually i started doing it to. for a lot of really math-minded people, hand waviness is anathema, and physics was full of "2 + 2 = 5 for sufficiently large values of 2, so we'll just assume that to make things easier"

Re:What Doesn't Seem Like Work? by _pius on Friday January 16, 2015 @07:21PM (#8902676)
"well, this term is basically zero, so we'll just remove it" and then she'd pull her hair in frustration, like "how can you just do that? how is it still valid?"

I've tried to teach friends with that hangup and found it difficult. Those people weren't good at math, though. I feel like with mathematicians, you should just be able to explain with limits.

Re:What Doesn't Seem Like Work? by sedachv on Friday January 16, 2015 @07:45PM (#8902779)
> I feel like with mathematicians, you should just be able to explain with limits.

Assuming the limit exists without actually proving the sequence converges is going to produce total junk. Jaynes spent a good portion of Probability Theory illustrating this.

Re:What Doesn't Seem Like Work? by _pius on Friday January 16, 2015 @07:48PM (#8902794)
I'm just talking about using the concept of limits as a teaching tool, not assuming a particular limit exists.
Re:What Doesn't Seem Like Work? by sedachv on Friday January 16, 2015 @08:40PM (#8902954)
Yes, this is why the mathematicians are pulling their hair out! You can't just drop terms when you feel like it.
Re:What Doesn't Seem Like Work? by TeMPOraL on Saturday January 17, 2015 @09:31AM (#8904374)
I feel that the right approach (at least it worked for me) is to tell the matematician - "see, this term is very close to zero for all practical inputs we can see in real life (proof of which will be left as an exercise for you), so - as you can see from the structure of the equation - we can safely drop it without introducing any significant error to the end result. Yes, the result will be a little bit less accurate; no, no one will notice. And if you happen to encounter a high-energy (or whatever) problem, you can always go back and use the full equation". Explicitly accepting that each handwave introduces errors and imprecision but that sometimes those errors are below what we can measure (or care about) should be acceptable enough for a math-minded person.
Re:What Doesn't Seem Like Work? by enjo on Friday January 16, 2015 @06:26PM (#8902462)
Physics is applied math and I think that is an important distinction.
Re:What Doesn't Seem Like Work? by sedachv on Friday January 16, 2015 @07:51PM (#8902809)
^ This. I ended up majoring in pure mathematics as an undergraduate after finding out that applied mathematics courses had too much material to memorize after finding out that physics courses had too much material to memorize. Pure math was so much easier.
Re:What Doesn't Seem Like Work? by phkahler on Friday January 16, 2015 @08:08PM (#8902864)
You and the person who started this thread seem to think that way. I find there is just as much to memorize in math. fields, rings, groups, and all sorts of things. Oh and those greek letters. I like math and physics and stuff but I never thought there was significantly less memorization in math. Calc 2 techniques of integration and then DiffEq seemed like a lot of special cases that had unique solutions we had to remember.
Re:What Doesn't Seem Like Work? by sedachv on Friday January 16, 2015 @09:03PM (#8903018)
> fields, rings, groups, and all sorts of things.

Each of those is just a definition and a handful (literally like 5 or 6) of axioms. If I memorized the axioms and a few key theorems I could usually derive everything else in the homework and on the exams. Most mathematical objects have very similar structure and the rest is just maps (morphisms) between them.

> Oh and those greek letters.

That's actually a very valid point. It took me a few years after graduating to realize how much myself (and I suspect many other students) are hampered by not knowing the notation well enough. Most people just assume you (and they) know what it means and never think about the actual definition and ambiguities. Even not being able to pronounce Greek letters definitely makes you less able (or at least less confident) to reason with them.

> Calc 2 techniques of integration and then DiffEq seemed like a lot of special cases that had unique solutions we had to remember.

That's the applied math part of calculus. The pure side is just "here's a compact/open/whatever set, prove for any point in it this property holds." Then you find out no one cares about either and it's all just numerical algorithms.

Re:What Doesn't Seem Like Work? by peterjancelis on Friday January 16, 2015 @09:49PM (#8903173)
> Most mathematical objects have very similar structure and the rest is just maps (morphisms) between them.

Is there a book covering this topic that you can recommend?

Re:What Doesn't Seem Like Work? by aesc on Saturday January 17, 2015 @04:08AM (#8903936)
Conceptual Mathematics is a good introduction to category theory (which is all about objects and morphisms) and especially well suited for self-study: http://www.amazon.com/Conceptual-Mathematics-First-Introduct...
Re:What Doesn't Seem Like Work? by sbrother on Friday January 16, 2015 @11:06PM (#8903373)
I'm going through this book right now, and I'm a pretty big fan so far: http://www.amazon.com/Introduction-Category-Theory-Harold-Si...
Re:What Doesn't Seem Like Work? by sedachv on Saturday January 17, 2015 @02:36AM (#8903784)
W. Keith Nicholson's Introduction to Abstract Algebra covers a lot of different topics in mathematics from an algebraic perspective.
Re:What Doesn't Seem Like Work? by ValentineC on Saturday January 17, 2015 @12:44PM (#8904894)
Relevant xkcd: http://xkcd.com/435/
Re:What Doesn't Seem Like Work? by s-phi-nl on Friday January 16, 2015 @07:32PM (#8902724)
Note that he says "I wasn't particularly good at history or physics" (emphasis added), not "I was not any good at physics." As other comments point out, there is enough to physics besides math that someone (who was good at math) could easily do well in physics without being considered exceptional.
Re:What Doesn't Seem Like Work? by S4M on Saturday January 17, 2015 @07:44AM (#8904230)
Funny you should say that. During my undergraduate, I got almost fired from my University for being one of the top students at maths and one of the worse in physics - it was in France, a bit different than in the US.

I recall that a physics chapter would start by "we take the Maxwell equations as [complex formulae]..." and for the life of me I wasn't able to understand them, or see where the teacher took that from.

On the other hand, maths seemed more logical, and even now - almost 15 years later - I can correctly recall my undergraduate maths classes, because I have them so well ingrained in me, because I could understand how various ideas connected to each other.

Re:What Doesn't Seem Like Work? by dilap on Friday January 16, 2015 @06:49PM (#8902557)
a lot of it is just cultural approach. math people tend to like to rigorously define everything they're doing, and work from there. physics is more like "what can we make up and fudge and twist and bend and then get the right answer." there's a lot of people who aren't as comfortable working in that less-defined context.

some of this is maybe inherent to the aim of physics, some of it is just physics machismo culture, and could be better, imo.

(i was a physics and math major at oregon.)

Re:What Doesn't Seem Like Work? by digikata on Friday January 16, 2015 @07:36PM (#8902745)
I don't think it's just cultural. Ultimately in physics you are often faced with a pile of observations from nature that you have to make sense of. Vs math, where you usually have a mass perfectly defined err.. well math that you're trying to build forward upon.

I think the best advances in both math and physics are made with people with an excellent grasp of when to move forward with existing constructs, and when to start shaping new ones...

Re:What Doesn't Seem Like Work? by dilap on Saturday January 17, 2015 @01:19AM (#8903640)
totally agree -- some of it is inherent to the endeavor of physics. but some of it is just hazing...
Re:What Doesn't Seem Like Work? by nichochar on Saturday January 17, 2015 @12:35AM (#8903550)
I disagree so much!

Math in physics (at least most of the physics I have done, which covers classical 19th century stuff mostly) is just a tool, if you can take a shortcut, take it! If you can approximate and cheat, do it! What matters in physics is the path from observation to modeling. Math is but a tool.

Now I agree that the math gets rather solid, but it's nothing compared to real math at an equivalent level.

I think my experience is particular because in France where I studied, you study both in parallel very intensively. So the math in physics always kind of seems trivial to you... But still my best physics teacher taught me that it was way more about the "feel and model" than the "exactly prove" that mathematics consists in.

Gosh I miss those days :)

Re:What Doesn't Seem Like Work? by Iftheshoefits on Friday January 16, 2015 @06:39PM (#8902503)
Math is certainly required to understand the theory and to synthesize experimental observations into a working model, but I wouldn't put it at more than 50-60%. Most of the math is fairly basic relatively speaking, even at the highest levels of physics.
Re:What Doesn't Seem Like Work? by soup10 on Friday January 16, 2015 @06:47PM (#8902545)
Relative to what lol. What other applied field has more advanced math?
Re:What Doesn't Seem Like Work? by Iftheshoefits on Friday January 16, 2015 @07:13PM (#8902641)
I don't know about other applied fields but I was referring to the field of math itself with that remark.
Re:What Doesn't Seem Like Work? by sedachv on Friday January 16, 2015 @07:47PM (#8902786)
Economics and quantitative finance.
Re:What Doesn't Seem Like Work? by ArkyBeagle on Friday January 16, 2015 @10:41PM (#8903298)
I didn't get that far in math, but in physics classes after Junior Physics Lab , I once or twice questioned the assumptions. There's always a theorem you don't know about.

There is a lot to math.

Re:What Doesn't Seem Like Work? by deeviant on Friday January 16, 2015 @06:41PM (#8902512)
I would say math is necessary but not sufficient to be successful in physics. Also, if somebody has the aptitude but not the drive, failure can certainly be an option.
Re:What Doesn't Seem Like Work? by tim333 on Friday January 16, 2015 @09:19PM (#8903081)
There's a lot of physics that isn't maths - more visualising how stuff works. Feynman's quite interesting talking about it here https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=obCjODeoLVw
Re:What Doesn't Seem Like Work? by UrMomReadsHN on Friday January 16, 2015 @09:19PM (#8903080)
I enjoy math and I hate physics. :)