News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bitcoin revealed: a Ponzi scheme for redistributing wealth by IgorPartola on Friday January 16, 2015 @01:27PM (#8900626)
While I agree about the speculators, they are not the reason BTC is hard to use as a currency. Rather, BTC is the reason BTC is hard to use as a currency. Let's see here:

- BTC tends to fluctuate a lot. I could buy a pizza with it today, or a car tomorrow, or a house in a week. Therefore, I am going to think twice about buying a pizza today.

- Tax implications of BTC are complicated. If you have never owned BTC, and this year decide to buy it to experiment with it, now you have additional paperwork to file about it. If you buy it via a BTC ATM, or some other cash method, you now have to keep track of all the records. (Presumably, places like Coinbase, etc. do this for you, I haven't checked). This is not insurmountable, but that's different than taking $20 out of an ATM and buying a slice of pizza.

- BTC is hard to acquire. Yes, yes it is. Coinbase requires a multi-day verification process.

- BTC is hard to keep secure. To do this properly, you have to know how to create an encrypted cold storage wallet and how to keep your computer safe so that when you unlock it, someone doesn't grab the wallet while you are using it. This is hard. It's so hard that intelligent people with domain knowledge get it wrong. I don't expect someone who is not a "computer person" to just get it. Coinbase and such are great for the "not computer persons", but are not secure (as in, you need to use 2 factor auth + strong password, which most people do not do; it's also not secure in that if someone does get into your account, you are done for. There is no reversal/insurance).

- BTC is weird when you are spending money. With fiat currency, I go on Amazon, punch in my credit card number, hit "buy" and viola! my order is all set. Theoretically, my credit card can get rejected later, but in practice it doesn't happen; if it does, I am familiar with the process. With BTC, I am suddenly shown number of confirmations, have to wait for minutes to know if my order went through, etc. Imagine buying Google IO tickets with BTC: by the time my confirmation comes through, someone else already paid with a faster method and got my reservation. (I know they recently changed it to a queue/invitation system, but my point stands for lots of purchases where the quantity is limited).

- BTC is weird to spend, again. If my BTC is in an encrypted cold storage wallet, as it should be, I now have to defrost it, decrypt it, push the BTC somewhere, then wait. Oh, and for some modes of spending, I then have to transfer BTC again, and wait again (localcoin for example).

So, where will BTC go from here? Well, I think it'll continue being a specialized currency. It's not great for buying pizza, and I don't think ever will be. It is great for transferring money in/out of restricted jurisdictions, or from person to person without leaving an obvious trail. That part works well. If you are a Snowden-type whistleblower and need your friend to get you money, this is as good a way to do it as any. Or if you are my grandfather who cannot get his money out of Ukraine due to the banks "not having enough USD on hand" to wire his balance to a US bank. Or if you want to make an anonymous donation. BTC is basically a faster and more secure version of stuffing cash into envelopes and mailing it.

Re:Bitcoin revealed: a Ponzi scheme for redistributing wealth by juliangoldsmith on Friday January 16, 2015 @01:51PM (#8900811)
1. That is due to speculation.

2 & 3. Those are basically due to Bitcoin being so new. Governments don't really know how to deal with it yet.

4. That's true, though there will likely be a product that will solve that in the future (i.e. a USB key that contains your wallet and signs transactions for you).

5. The waiting for a confirmation is more a limitation of the service. There's no reason why Google IO wouldn't be able to reserve your ticket once it received the transaction (within a couple of seconds) and then give you the ticket once there was a confirmation.

6. You use a cold storage wallet to hold the bulk of your funds, then transfer them to a hot wallet as needed. (So, keep your $5k in BTC in your cold wallet, and transfer $500 to your hot wallet every week or something.) Decrypting a hot wallet shouldn't be much harder than entering a password.

Re:Bitcoin revealed: a Ponzi scheme for redistributing wealth by ssharp on Friday January 16, 2015 @03:13PM (#8901372)
All of these solutions are still worse than just using a credit card.
Re:Bitcoin revealed: a Ponzi scheme for redistributing wealth by ingler on Friday January 16, 2015 @01:36PM (#8900688)
> BTC is hard to keep secure.

It's very easy to secure.

Create keypairs offline. Print keypairs. Send coins to address(es). Store paper wallet in safe place.

Re:Bitcoin revealed: a Ponzi scheme for redistributing wealth by pdx on Friday January 16, 2015 @01:49PM (#8900802)
Your mindset represent a trend that is rampant in the bitcoin community, and is a huge drag on bitcoin, in my opinion.

The mindset being that you're securing your life savings.

That mindset is prevalent in the bitcoin community, because many of them indeed hope that their bitcoin IS their life savings. They hope for the day when their bitcoin has appreciated to the point that it's a significant asset, worthy of significant pains to protect it. From that perspective, your mindset it rational and correct.

The problem is that when you advocate such complex storage and use methods, you are advocating unnecessary complexity for the people you are attempting to sway to bitcoin. The normal person who wants to send $50 to his mother in the Philipines, or wants to have $100 on his phone to buy beer and hotdogs with, does not need such complexity, and will quickly run the other way when bombarded by it.

Any normal person who looks in to bitcoin, is bombarded with crazy ideas that the self appointed bitcoin experts claim he must must jump through.

    * Use multiple addresses for privacy.  Nobody should reuse an address.
    * Use offline storage
    * Generate your addresses on computers not connected to the internet
    * Use a trezor.
    * Use a deterministic wallet
    * Don't use coinbase or circle, or the government will track you
This barrage of advice, which does indeed make sense for aspiring bitcoin millionaires and criminals, doesn't make sense for normal people, but nobody tells them that. Instead, they tab their browser over to facebook and resume their day, secure in the knowledge that bitcoin is not for them.

If you insist on making bitcoin the domain of nerds, only nerds will use bitcoin.

Re:Bitcoin revealed: a Ponzi scheme for redistributing wealth by ingler on Friday January 16, 2015 @01:55PM (#8900847)
I'd never claim to be normal, but I'm neither a bitcoin millionaire nor a criminal.

If Bitcoin is "too hard" to figure out for someone, they probably shouldn't use it.

Re:Bitcoin revealed: a Ponzi scheme for redistributing wealth by IgorPartola on Friday January 16, 2015 @02:21PM (#8901028)
And Bitcoin is too hard to figure out for 99.99999% of the population, which is why it'll never reach mainstream adoption?
Re:Bitcoin revealed: a Ponzi scheme for redistributing wealth by ingler on Friday January 16, 2015 @05:49PM (#8902260)
Probably so. It still doesn't take away from Bitcoin's underlying usefulness.
Re:Bitcoin revealed: a Ponzi scheme for redistributing wealth by umanwizard on Friday January 16, 2015 @01:42PM (#8900739)
This is still a huge hurdle compared to fiat, which is: Put in bank.
Re:Bitcoin revealed: a Ponzi scheme for redistributing wealth by ingler on Friday January 16, 2015 @01:46PM (#8900776)
All currencies and value systems have their own inherent strengths and weaknesses, depending on how and where they're being used. Bitcoin is no different.

The all or nothing thinking when it comes to currencies reminds me of hearing people talk about religions.

Re:Bitcoin revealed: a Ponzi scheme for redistributing wealth by galactus on Friday January 16, 2015 @01:47PM (#8900786)
Very impractical if you want to use bitcoin as currency
Re:Bitcoin revealed: a Ponzi scheme for redistributing wealth by ingler on Friday January 16, 2015 @01:49PM (#8900799)
Security isn't ever easy. Sacrificing convenience is an easy trade.
Re:Bitcoin revealed: a Ponzi scheme for redistributing wealth by jrochkind1 on Friday January 16, 2015 @01:56PM (#8900863)
> Or if you are my grandfather who cannot get his money out of Ukraine due to the banks "not having enough USD on hand" to wire his balance to a US bank.

I'm guessing the exchange rate for ukranian currency to bitcoin (and then to USD) is not such to make this a particularly useful thing to do. But maybe?

Re:Bitcoin revealed: a Ponzi scheme for redistributing wealth by IgorPartola on Friday January 16, 2015 @02:26PM (#8901057)
In this particular case, it's mostly a problem of not actually being there physically to perform the transaction. The solution of "stuff it into an envelope and mail it" would actually work out incredibly well here, except it will never make it.