Also I personally like the look. The edgyness may indeed not appeal much to girls - but I'd say it's definitely geek-compatible.
It's like me claiming that star shaped eyeglasses are not in fashion, because I don't see people wearing them, and you ask me to prove it. I can't prove it, but it just seems to me to be correct.
Only now we are starting to see nice phones with nice software with slide-out keyboards.
An interesting point is implied - that men are more resistant (or less sensitive) to suckiness than women. That's something to debate.
Haven't tried the N82, but I had a series of E-series phones and all shared a tendency to crash, of being slow (starting many programs took several seconds, booting took up to two minutes - mind you: more than Windows does on a desktop PC) and having a generally confusing interface.
I had a Palm Centro briefly and despite its limited software, it was one of the best QWERTY phone I ever had. I look forward to the launch of WebOS phones here in Brazil.
I also assumed we were talking about QWERTY phones like this Motorola unit. I understand the Nokia S-60 series interface is less confusing on a simpler keyboard and the N8x series is among the best media phones you can buy.
I suppose it's mostly fashion. Flip phones seem rare these days, for example.