News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Motorola Droid hands on by maxklein on Monday October 19, 2009 @06:44AM (#889817)
I just need to look at this picture (http://www.boygeniusreport.com/gallery/handsets/motorola-dro...) to know that it's going to be another flop. Two things I believe someone should tell these companies:

1. Don't save on your casing

2. Girls don't like slide-out keyboards.

The killer android phone will look like the razr and be pretty expensive.

Re:Motorola Droid hands on by davidw on Monday October 19, 2009 @06:57AM (#889823)
The thing about Android is that eventually, there will probably never be a phone that is as beautiful as whatever iPhone's doing, but that there can models for everyone's tastes. Something like this for the geeks, a slick, slim clamshell like you say, and all kinds of others.
Re:Motorola Droid hands on by roc on Monday October 19, 2009 @09:54AM (#890043)
Which is/was the same philosophy behind Symbian and Windows Mobile.

Suffice to say, that flexibility comes at non-trivial cost.

Re:Motorola Droid hands on by fpgeek on Monday October 19, 2009 @11:05AM (#890182)
First, Android is already light-years ahead of Windows Mobile.

Second, from what I've seen of the SDKs, Google is doing quite a bit (most notably with their manifests) to maximize the reach of the platform (e.g. netbooks, automotive systems, set-top boxes) without unduly burdening cross-device portability.

Re:Motorola Droid hands on by gaius on Monday October 19, 2009 @07:19AM (#889844)
What is the data underlying point 2?
Re:Motorola Droid hands on by moe on Monday October 19, 2009 @07:33AM (#889863)
Seconded. The sidekick was pretty popular with girls, for all I know.

Also I personally like the look. The edgyness may indeed not appeal much to girls - but I'd say it's definitely geek-compatible.

Re:Motorola Droid hands on by maxklein on Monday October 19, 2009 @07:57AM (#889887)
I know about 200 girls. 0 of them have slide-out keyboard phones. It's not a very significant number, but it's enough for me.

It's like me claiming that star shaped eyeglasses are not in fashion, because I don't see people wearing them, and you ask me to prove it. I can't prove it, but it just seems to me to be correct.

Re:Motorola Droid hands on by rbanffy on Monday October 19, 2009 @08:19AM (#889917)
I think just about every phone with slide out keyboard is either Nokia Symbian (they suck) or Windows Mobile (sucks beyond what polite language can describe)

Only now we are starting to see nice phones with nice software with slide-out keyboards.

An interesting point is implied - that men are more resistant (or less sensitive) to suckiness than women. That's something to debate.

Re:Motorola Droid hands on by perokreco on Tuesday October 20, 2009 @12:49AM (#891785)
I have a Nokia Symbian(N82), and it is amazing, would never trade it for an Iphonee. I don't see why you would make such a blanket statement about them.
Re:Motorola Droid hands on by rbanffy on Tuesday October 20, 2009 @05:53AM (#892110)
"I don't see why you would make such a blanket statement about them."

Haven't tried the N82, but I had a series of E-series phones and all shared a tendency to crash, of being slow (starting many programs took several seconds, booting took up to two minutes - mind you: more than Windows does on a desktop PC) and having a generally confusing interface.

I had a Palm Centro briefly and despite its limited software, it was one of the best QWERTY phone I ever had. I look forward to the launch of WebOS phones here in Brazil.

I also assumed we were talking about QWERTY phones like this Motorola unit. I understand the Nokia S-60 series interface is less confusing on a simpler keyboard and the N8x series is among the best media phones you can buy.

Re:Motorola Droid hands on by gaius on Monday October 19, 2009 @08:04AM (#889897)
I know at least 2 girls with Nokia N95s, so that disproves that then :-)

I suppose it's mostly fashion. Flip phones seem rare these days, for example.

Re:Motorola Droid hands on by maxklein on Monday October 19, 2009 @08:15AM (#889912)
It's more than that. Slide-out keyboards are a geek thing. Teen Girls like things that are dainty, and nobody ever used that word to describe a slide-out keyboard. Teen girls grow into women who want feminine things, and bulky phones with slide out keyboards are rather masculine.
Re:Motorola Droid hands on by gaius on Monday October 19, 2009 @09:11AM (#889990)
Teen girls around here like full-sized BlackBerries.
Re:Motorola Droid hands on by roc on Monday October 19, 2009 @09:51AM (#890036)
As with fashion, maybe it's regional? Aside from those using iPhones (and my Grandmother) every woman I know has a slide-out keyboard. (Mostly Sidekicks, Navigators, enVs and the like)