News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bitcoin crashes over 25% in 24 hours, under $180 by honeybooboo123 on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @03:52AM (#8885053)
I don't own any bitcoins, but felt like pointing a couple of things out.

Whatever shreds of interest your bank gives you will be way, way less than the inflation you're experiencing. In other words, your money's purchasing power keeps decreasing even if you're getting some interest on it, ie. you're losing your wealth.

Bitcoin doesn't experience inflation like that, so it should be a better store of value than your fiat currency. I said "should" because bitcoin has been in a speculative bubble, and just came down even more. Right now it's still just a speculative asset, but it could serve as a stable currency.

Your card is irrelevant.

Transaction fees are not extortion. They're a massive skimming operation inflicted on the masses, because the masses have no choice but to eat them. Thank your state-maintained bank cartel for that.

Re:Bitcoin crashes over 25% in 24 hours, under $180 by redthrowaway on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @04:13AM (#8885127)
There are no grounds to say that BTC should be a superior store of value. Aside from its very public history of being an absolutely abysmal store of value, it also has no central bank tending its value, as fiat currencies do, and no substantial trade denominated in it, which is what gives fiat currencies value in forex markets. It is solely a speculative vehicle. It sucks at commerce and it sucks at investment.

Bitcoin's sole value as a currency lies in its ease of use as a back-end for transactions. It's not a bad intermediary for transactions between people using different currencies, provided the third party transaction service has legal, fast, and cheap ways to convert to and from fiat in both countries. But then, it's not so much a currency as a transport layer with added uncertainty.

I've yet to see a compelling case for BTC as anything but TCP/IP for dollars or a wayback machine for anything you want. It's bad for savings, god-awful for investment, and useless for [legal] commerce.

Re:Bitcoin crashes over 25% in 24 hours, under $180 by honeybooboo123 on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @08:36AM (#8886091)
>> Aside from its very public history of being an absolutely abysmal store of value

You're talking about something different now. Namely the effects of all the speculation, and for example governments figuring out if Bitcoin poses enough of a threat to them that they need to make it illegal, and so on. Will they shut it down? Will they not? Will they first make some money with it, and then shut it down?

The point is that the wild fluctuations in Bitcoin's price you see are not proof that it's not a good store of value. It could well be, after stabilizing, if it ever does.

A good store of value is something that could serve as a good medium of exchange too, like gold for example. Gold was used as money for ages, exactly because its characteristics made it suitable for that. It can't be printed by pressing a button somewhere, it's divisible, durable, and so on.

Bitcoin has some of the same characteristics, and that's why it might well become a widely used medium of exchange. I bet something like it will.

Central banks are not actually helping you. If you have a sound currency, it can't be printed, and central banks can't meddle with it.

You see, printing a currency devalues it. If the pool of currency in circulation grows faster than the pool of wealth it can be exchanged for, then the currency loses some of its value relative to the wealth available.

>> Bitcoin's sole value as a currency lies in its ease of use as a back-end for transactions.

Fiat currencies' sole value lies in the fact that governments force us to pay taxes in them. Otherwise we'd all be using a sound currency instead, because it would be in our self-interest to do so.

Re:Bitcoin crashes over 25% in 24 hours, under $180 by derefr on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @04:31AM (#8885204)
I think you're attacking somewhat of a weak-man: the people saying Bitcoin as it is valued right now is any sort of store of value (and there are, indeed, such people) are obviously slightly insane.

But in a long-term sense—an imagined future where all the speculative value has gone out of Bitcoin and it is now just "worth what it is worth"—it would make a fairly good store of value, in exactly the same way gold would if we knew exactly how much of it there was to mine out of the earth, if some property of the (never-changing) extraction process meant that it was only able to be mined out at an exactly inverse-exponential rate, and if it were very easy to handle the resulting gold in 0.00000000001g pieces.

Re:Bitcoin crashes over 25% in 24 hours, under $180 by redthrowaway on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @05:01AM (#8885324)
A store of value must be such over any given timeframe. If the balance in your savings account is worth $100 today, $50 in three months, $150 in six months, and $75 in a year, then it is a terrible store of value -- regardless of whether it's worth $200 two years from now.

Similarly, talking about imagined futures is not a convincing way to defend a currency as a store of value. If you have to posit that your money will still be there iff A, B, and C are true, then you're not going to park your money in that particular stall.

Re:Bitcoin crashes over 25% in 24 hours, under $180 by derefr on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @05:11AM (#8885360)
I'm not saying people should be putting money into Bitcoin now because they should assume A, B, and C will be true.

What I'm saying is that there's no reason to assume that you won't see Bitcoin's value stabilize e.g. ten years from now, and Bitcoin become a useful store of value from that point forward.

Or, to put it another way, just because the Bitcoin that exists today is a bad store of value, doesn't mean that "Bitcoin is a bad store of value" is an immutable fact about Bitcoin. It could just be a fact about today.

Re:Bitcoin crashes over 25% in 24 hours, under $180 by redthrowaway on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @05:24AM (#8885407)
Well, sure. PHP could also become a nice language to code in. Neither outcome seems likely, given what we've seen in the past.
Re:Bitcoin crashes over 25% in 24 hours, under $180 by justincormack on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @05:06AM (#8885343)
It is worth nothing in that case. Why bitcoin not dogecoin or anything else? There is no special intrinsic value in bitcoin over the others, so there is still an infinite amount that can be made.
Re:Bitcoin crashes over 25% in 24 hours, under $180 by jasonisalive on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @05:30AM (#8885427)
Bitcoin because it was first. Bitcoin because it has the community, the attention, the history - in other words, the network effect. Bitcoin because it's not a clone. Bitcoin because other people choose Bitcoin. Etc. etc. Bitcoin because it has the initial gravitational advantage, and mass begets mass in the formation of stars.
Re:Bitcoin crashes over 25% in 24 hours, under $180 by tribaal on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @03:58AM (#8885076)
> Your card is irrelevant.

My card is very relevant.

If someone steals it, they can use it but it doesn't impact me in any way except having to wait for the new card to come.

If someone steals my bitcoins, it means they have a copy of my private key, and there is nothing I can do about it. Zich. Nada.

Transaction fees pay for this insurance (among other things, but still).

Re:Bitcoin crashes over 25% in 24 hours, under $180 by dingaling on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @07:45AM (#8885860)
> If someone steals it, they can use it but it doesn't impact me in any way except having to wait for the new card to come.

Unfortunately this is no longer the case in Europe with cards activated under 'Verified by Visa' ( and presumably the Mastercard equivalent ).

If an VbV card is used and passes authentication then it is assumed that the cardholder authorised the transaction and they are liable.

Re:Bitcoin crashes over 25% in 24 hours, under $180 by tribaal on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @08:03AM (#8885931)
Ah, sure, if they use my card with the chip and PIN then I'm liable. Same if an online purchase is validated by 3dsecure, since that would mean that they somehow got my password on top of the physical card and personal details.
Re:Bitcoin crashes over 25% in 24 hours, under $180 by leni536 on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @04:22AM (#8885171)
You can have multiple wallets though. You can have a really secured wallet, maybe signed with a smart card (is it possible? If yes then it's pretty much impossible to steal, unless someone steals it physically.) and have a less secure wallet on your smartphone. Your smartphone plays the role of a "regular wallet" and you only have minimal amounts on it (like what you need for daily purchases).
Re:Bitcoin crashes over 25% in 24 hours, under $180 by kijin on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @04:39AM (#8885236)
Sure, but that takes a considerable amount of time and mental energy to set up and maintain. If possible, most people would just outsource the whole operation to some third party so that they can forget about it and get on with their lives. Of course, the third party would charge a fee for the convenience that they offers to their customers...

...and that's how you get a bank.

Re:Bitcoin crashes over 25% in 24 hours, under $180 by tribaal on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @04:35AM (#8885221)
That's where my original comment of "I don't see adoption becoming anything more than anecdotal" comes from :)

I don't think the benefits of bitcoin outweight having to maintain (multiple) private key's security.

Re:Bitcoin crashes over 25% in 24 hours, under $180 by hueving on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @04:37AM (#8885229)
And what happens when you lose said wallet?
Re:Bitcoin crashes over 25% in 24 hours, under $180 by vacri on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @01:36PM (#8888097)
Or the smartcard develops a hardware fault?
Re:Bitcoin crashes over 25% in 24 hours, under $180 by leni536 on Friday January 16, 2015 @03:16AM (#8897733)
Well I'm a bit late on the questions but here is my suggestion:

For the really secure wallet you program two (or more) cards with the same key in case one of them is lost or craps itself (then throw away the private key). They are protected by a PIN code so they brick themselves after 3 subsequent wrong tries. If you lose one of the cards then you get two new cards, program them with identical private keys (clearly it is different than the previous one) then transfer all of your money to the new wallet.

It's really hard to be your own bank, but it is possible. The beauty of bitcoin that you don't have to trust any third party, but it's really hard manage properly.

I would be surprised if anybody used this scheme, I don't have any bitcoins either. If I jump into the bitcoin business I'm sure I will adopt this scheme.

Re:Bitcoin crashes over 25% in 24 hours, under $180 by sanswork on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @03:59AM (#8885084)
>Bitcoin doesn't experience inflation like that

Bitcoin inflation is at 10% per year right now not even considering the dropping price.

Re:Bitcoin crashes over 25% in 24 hours, under $180 by davidw on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @04:26AM (#8885183)
> the inflation

Not a lot of that going around the developed world at this point in time, though, is there?

Re:Bitcoin crashes over 25% in 24 hours, under $180 by pjc50 on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @04:56AM (#8885299)
There is a "cost per transaction" in bitcoin as well: https://blockchain.info/charts/cost-per-transaction

It costs a certain (very high!) amount of real electricity to process a block. This plus an incentive has to be paid to miners. Miners have to pay for their electricity in real local currency. Therefore for every transaction block processed either someone "buys in" ~$10 worth of bitcoin or the outstanding value of all bitcoin drops by that amount.