Look at the services built too. Mining companies and exchanges. Tell me how those are going to draw in new users?
Not really. Often, it is merchant solutions like BitPay or consumer services like Blockchain.info or Xapo that are funded. Most interesting in my opinion is blockstream. Mining tends to be privately funded outside the VC-ecosystem.
Blockchain raised a silly amount of money for a platform that most people in the community have lost faith in due to repeated security failings.
That's a remarkably bold claim. Citation definitely needed.
You will need to define the "community", and then provide a source for "most". I don't see how you can possibly do that, since both data points are lost in the murky fog that is the world of Bitcoin
"source" the few weeks a month or so back where every second post was about how evil or bad or stupid blockchain.info was and no one should use them anymore. It was around the time the problem was discovered with their keygen and when someone was regularly sweeping coins from wallets on the service.
You haven't even counted them. You're providing no real data.
There's no way that it justifies your stark claim that "most people in the community have lost faith in Blockchain.info".
Why do you feel the need to enhance your argument with exaggeration and unsupported assertions?
Almost 10% of the comments in this thread are by you, and they're filled with numerous bold claims of fact.
Are all those statements "observations of sentiment", too, or was it only this one?
If I use exact numbers they tend to be facts I can source you. If I use vague terms it is because I don't have the numbers or it is a sentiment claim.
I've had a look through my comments here and don't really see too many bold claims at all. Do you have any specific ones you want an answer for?
So you're boldly claiming that the company has lost over 50% of its community support. That's an incredibly damaging statement. And you're basing it on shamefully weak evidence.
If you really wanted to be vague, then the appropriate word might have been "some". So you could have said "Some people in the community have lost faith in Blockchain.info". But that wouldn't have sounded as impressive, would it? It would sound like you don't know what you're talking about and you don't have any real proof. So you went with the bold and confident "most".
> Do you have any specific ones you want an answer for?
Frankly, after this discussion, absolutely all of them, because you seem to be prone to exaggeration, to put it mildly.
>Frankly, after this discussion, absolutely all of them, because you seem to be prone to exaggeration, to put it mildly.
Well go ahead and copy any paste any of the ones you are unsure of here and I'll reply.
I said "all of them", but who has time for that? Just take another statement of yours as an example:
>"2014 Was meant to be the year of Bitcoin" based on the claims of all the leading people in the bitcoin world outside of Gavin.[1]
"All" the leading figures in the Bitcoin world, except one, said 2014 would be the year of Bitcoin? Really?
I'm sure "some" of them said that, or some kind of bullish statement of that sort, but even if you'd claimed that, you'd still run into an argument about who are "the leading figures" anyway.
It's the way you frequently employ these sweeping generalizations and broad exaggerations to support your arguments that makes me more and more inclined to discount any statement you make.
Probably some of what you say is true. But basically you seem to spew out assertions without checking them. You have a terrible habit of stating your opinions as facts. I suspect you may even be twisting the facts to better support your claims, in the heat of an argument. So how can I trust you? I don't have time to sort out the truth from the half-truths and exaggerations.
All of who except for Gavin(and almost never Garzik) have at points claimed it would be the big break out year. That it was going to the moon this year, $XX,XXX coins, that big investors were arriving any day now, etc.
The problem you seem to have is that you are a literalist and are unable to understand when someone uses broad words in conversational English to imply meaning instead of specifics.
I'm confident most people can understand that when I say "all the leading people" that I mean "the majority of the most well known influencers".
>So how can I trust you? I don't have time to sort out the truth from the half-truths and exaggerations.
How can you trust me? I think its clear that you cannot as you seem to want to take everything I say literally.
people throw at money at anything.
Yes, Bitcoin was probably hurt by the mania surrounding $1000. Had it gone to $180 from $30, without the spike, there would be calls of tulip mania instead.
Is it too early to build applications on top of Bitcoin? No, I don't think so, some wants to be in early. But to call "the year of" on what amounts to beta software and VC backed startups is a bit much.
No one cares what version the software is and that you would think anyone does is one of the problems with the Bitcoin community. Bitcoin had its chance to impress the general public and get them on board when it had all its media attention this past year and it failed.
Neither is node.js, yet tons of successful startups run on it.
For years, Gmail was still "beta". If it had a major security leak, "it's beta" would mean little. It would still qualify as a failure.
It will get them off the ground. Then they will need to start rewriting a backend pipeline in something fast and predictable.
I have very mundane needs, and I've never figured out a compelling case for me to use bitcoin. In general, it's always been more trouble than convenience.
I know there are people with exotic needs, but I think the majority of people are more like me.
Now, imagine you're poor, your family lives abroad, and a $20 fee on a $500 transfer is indeed a big issue.
There are usability concerns (a bitcoin ATM to deposit money and have it sent to an address would be nice) but the use case of near-zero, same-day money transfers is enormous. In the affluent western world it's strange to imagine that someone could depend on your speedy transfers and that even an extra $20 would go a long way.
I needed to send some money overseas and I looked at bitcoin for exactly the same reasons that you described. However, I found that sending the money via bit coin would take longer and wind up costing me more in transaction fees than just using transferwise. While the actual bitcoin transfer itself was free and instantaneous, there were multiple days of waiting and percentage fees to convert from or to fiat currency at each end of the transaction.
This is why bitcoin is doomed to fail.
It might not be bitcoin, but in 20 years do you think no cryptocurrency will be in widespread use?
Is it being used presently by lots of people on low incomes to transfer money? What if they do and it drops 10% on the day? How would they acquire it easily? How would they exchange it easily and quickly for their local currency?
I'd love to see a digital currency which actually competes in a meaningful way with the convenience of digital cash, but Bitcoin is nowhere close. It has serious issues with volatility, speculation, acquisition, storage and lack of regulation/insurance, all of which mean I wouldn't touch it in its current form.
Bitcoin isn't better for remittance. Actually moving the money has never been the expensive parts of remittance it is giving people a way to receive money on the other side and compliance. The current bitcoin remittance companies advertising lower fees are doing it entirely by ignoring compliance and that will work great until they have any volume and then they will be shut down.
I've heard people say "BTMs save money on not needing a store" but do you think if an automated machine was doable WU wouldn't have replaced most of their partner branches by now?
I'm American and have lived overseas for several years and the currency exchange rates in combination with the 10-20 USD fees are a constant annoyance. And an annoyance for my startup which operates in USD but does business in several countries. It badly affects margin for smaller payments.
I'm a big Amazon Prime customer and I do a lot of purchase for family and friends for delivery in the US. I don't dare use my overseas credit card to pay for it, but if Amazon were to accept BTC I could pay from where I live. That would be very valuable to me personally.
I'm interested in bitcoin because it takes control away from traditional choke point exchange bank and also could serve as a 'world currency' of sorts. I also think that it would make possible a lot of cross-border sales that currently face real practical impediments.
Wouldn't the incredibly volatile currency exchange rate of Bitcoin also cause problems? It is not immune to this as it is free floating against other currencies.
I'd love to see a world-currency which does away with existing credit card companies and transfer fees worldwide, but Bitcoin is not suitable, and I suspect if we see one emerge it will quickly be regulated and taxed by governments like all other means of storing wealth.
> 2014 was meant to be the year of bitcoin
You obviously base this off price alone. If you look at startups based around bitcoin or the blockchain, if you consider that regulatory clarity has or is being provided by most major economies, if you look at transaction volume, feature developement etc then 2014 was a good year for bitcoin.
>Mining companies are closing left, right, and centre, and bitcoin exchanges are shutting down for more profitable ventures.
One cloud mining service (CEX.io) has suspened cloud mining operations. What other mining companies have closed? The hashrate has fallen recently but if lots of mining companies(as you suggest) have closed we would have expected a much larger drop.
As for exchanges shutting to pursue other more profitable ventures, this is 1 exchange (Vault of Satoshi) not a huge exchange by anyones metrics. You said exchanges (plural) which others?
>Unlike the previous bubbles this one was in full sight of the general public with constant media coverage. It's gone to $1000 had most people(in western nations) learn about it and respond almost unanimously with 'Meh'.
The general public may have, investors and people that understand tech have not responded in that way at all. If you asked the general public about the internet in 1990 they would have said meh!, those same people now bank online, shop online and communicate online. Do they care about the internet? No, but at the same time could they bare to be parted from facebook?
Bitcoin will become widely used and adopted, whether consumers know they are using it or not is another matter.
Transaction volume is a ridiculously bad metric to judge growth. You want to prove growth get coinbase and blockchain.info to release MAU figures. They won't of course for obvious reasons.
>One cloud mining service (CEX.io) has suspened cloud mining operations.
HASH profit, PETAmine, Hashie, Coins-miner are the first few I found after a quick look for more names for you.
Also Cointerra for mining equipment.
>As for exchanges shutting to pursue other more profitable ventures, this is 1 exchange (Vault of Satoshi) not a huge exchange by anyones metrics. You said exchanges (plural) which others?
The other company I was thinking of was Delta Financial. Not an exchange.
>The general public may have, investors and people that understand tech have not responded in that way at all.
Except they have. Look outside of bitcoin forums for the general feelings towards bitcoin some time. It is almost universally negative especially in tech and finance circles.
?If you asked the general public about the internet in 1990 they would have said meh!, those same people now bank online, shop online and communicate online. Do they care about the internet? No, but at the same time could they bare to be parted from facebook?
Luckily though we have the internet now which has accelerated the spread of new ideas and products on it. We're not dealing with a pre-internet world anymore so comparing them is silly.
>Bitcoin will become widely used and adopted, whether consumers know they are using it or not is another matter.
If consumers don't know they are using it then there is no reason for it to be used. You think banks can't speed up their transfers to be instant if there is any pressure without using bitcoin?
I think you don't understand. People had no need of the Internet until applications such as online banking, online shopping etc were available to them. They didn't come pre installed on the Internet and whilst they wrre being developed most Internet users were people who got involved with it because it was cool new technology. Your mum and dad only got it when it had already become a mature technology.
Bitcoin doesn't have that because most people don't care about what it does better and do care about what it does worse.
6 years into the experiment including an entire year regularly in the news and still almost no one cares and the userbase appears to have actually shrunk this year from an estimated peak of ~1-2m to an estimated 500k. And even that 500k is considered generous.
>Your mum and dad only got it when it had already become a mature technology.
I appreciate your condescending tone and trying to imply that I'm a child. But I've been on the internet and programming since 95 and while far from the earliest user I was a lot closer to them than most people. I'm well aware of days when online banking wasn't a common thing. And the fact that the idea of it and online shopping didn't spread fast because we were largely in the pre-internet(it existed but had limited adoption) world then.
$5M USD in Bitcoin sales is pretty astonishing, actually.
EDIT: 1/5 of $15M is still pretty astonishing. I expected something around 250K in BTC-denominated sales.
Even worse, it's not counting the loss of the value of bitcoins. Lots of people dumped bitcoins on overstock when it was worth much more than $200. They need to convert those bitcoins into cash to pay taxes, rent, etc.
Overstock lucked out by not doing more business in bitcoins because they would have lost even more due to the drop in bitcoin price...
"as far as the general public was concerned" :) Yeah, they were too busy watching the big bottom Kim and losing their home.
"(Overstock the poster child which at one point was claiming serious expectations of $15-20m in bitcoin sales ended up with a 5th of the lower end of their claim)."
Did you see how poorly Amazon did? They're a much larger and better store. No coins on Amazon.
"Mining companies are closing left, right, and centre, and bitcoin exchanges are shutting down for more profitable ventures."
As are oil companies. So goes the world. Isn't linear let alone vertical. Two steps forward...
What would those, 'more profitable ventures' be? You of course don't say because those miners aren't good for anything else.
"I don't think Bitcoin is dead or even close to dead but I'm pretty sure we've seen its peak."
If you're pretty sure, you would say why, but you don't. Apparently cirucular logic is big on the HH. That and or Tourette's.
They are the ones that matter when you're trying to promote a new currency. And yes they don't care.
>Did you see how poorly Amazon did? They're a much larger and better store. No coins on Amazon.
I don't understand what you're trying to say here?
>What would those, 'more profitable ventures' be? You of course don't say because those miners aren't good for anything else.
For Vault of Satoshi it was apparently streaming video.
>If you're pretty sure, you would say why, but you don't. Apparently cirucular logic is big on the HH. That and or Tourette's.
I've said why. You are throwing out a lot of personal insults here to cover up the fact that in all your posts you've added zero content. You've attacked things that people have said without providing counter points and insulted them to mask your lack of content.
Mining companies are closing left, right, and centre, and bitcoin exchanges are shutting down for more profitable ventures.
I don't think Bitcoin is dead or even close to dead but I'm pretty sure we've seen its peak.
Unlike the previous bubbles this one was in full sight of the general public with constant media coverage. It's gone to $1000 had most people(in western nations) learn about it and respond almost unanimously with 'Meh'.