News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Please admit defeat (HTTP WG) by debacle on Tuesday January 13, 2015 @04:18PM (#8882656)
On the one hand, any HTTP 2.0 spec that still has cookies is a travesty.

On the other hand, I think we need to get some input from dissenters other than PHK (not that I don't agree with him).

Re:Please admit defeat (HTTP WG) by gsnedders on Tuesday January 13, 2015 @04:59PM (#8882912)
This is by design. The aim for HTTP/2 was always a new messaging scheme for HTTP/1.1 semantics. Basically, any HTTP/1.1 message can be converted to an HTTP/2 message (and this can be done by intermediaries); the only headers not expected to be supported in HTTP/2 are those that fall into the category of connection control (e.g., Connection).

From the charter:

> It is expected that HTTP/2.0 will:

> * Retain the semantics of HTTP/1.1, leveraging existing documentation (see above), including (but not limited to) HTTP methods, status codes, URIs, and where appropriate, header fields.

> * Clearly define how HTTP/2.0 interacts with HTTP/1.x, especially in intermediaries (both 2->1 and 1->2).

Quite probably a more radical, new version of HTTP, that drops message compatibility would be a good idea — but that's a lot harder to design and harder to deploy. As the old adage goes, "we believe in rough consensus and running code" — we have running code for a new message serialisation, and rough consensus for it. We should accept just that as done.

Re:Please admit defeat (HTTP WG) by debacle on Tuesday January 13, 2015 @05:01PM (#8882919)
So if HTTP 2.0 is a superset of HTTP 1.1 then why the hell can't they just leave it as SPDY?

Which goes back to PHK's argument about the IETF getting caught with their pants down.

Re:Please admit defeat (HTTP WG) by __david__ on Tuesday January 13, 2015 @04:54PM (#8882885)
Honest question: if you don't have cookies, then where do you keep your state?
Re:Please admit defeat (HTTP WG) by debacle on Tuesday January 13, 2015 @04:55PM (#8882892)
In the session, where it belongs.
Re:Please admit defeat (HTTP WG) by gazrogers on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @06:12AM (#8885551)
How do you link the browser to the session, if not with cookies?
Re:Please admit defeat (HTTP WG) by youngtaff on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @09:42AM (#8886478)
You create a session identifiers as part of the protocol but that then breaks the semantics being compatible with HTTP/1.x

I think it will come and I think PHK's ideas a really interesting just that it's a step too far right now.