News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FCC urged to investigate Verizon’s statements on utility ... by rayiner on Tuesday January 13, 2015 @03:13PM (#8882257)
You have to put the telecom debate in the proper historical context. It's not some sui generis issue. It's part of a broader debate about how much involvement government should have in regulating services. There was a time when the government told trucking companies how much they could charge for a shipment. The overwhelming trend since then has been to deregulate industries if possible, or replace heavy-weight regulations (rate setting, etc) with lighter-weight ones. Full-on Title II represents 1970's-style regulation that neither party wants to go back to, which is why the debate is between no action at all or "Title II with heavy forebearance."

People talk about regulating telecom like the power company, but the trend over the last 30 years has been to deregulate the power companies as much as possible.

NB: The UK example is a poor one. British Telecom was originally a government entity, and was "privatized" under agreements that made clear that they would be subject to constraints. In contrast, since 1996, the telecoms have invested tens of billions of dollars in capital under the premise that the industry was deregulated.

Re:FCC urged to investigate Verizon’s statements on utility ... by slantedview on Tuesday January 13, 2015 @03:21PM (#8882323)
Regulation, in this and many cases, is a way for the government to ensure that companies don't use the privileges granted to them by the government (such rights to lay cable lines) as an anti-competitive tool - which they naturally will try to do. The privileges have to come with restraints - else bad things happen.
Re:FCC urged to investigate Verizon’s statements on utility ... by rayiner on Tuesday January 13, 2015 @03:26PM (#8882354)
The premise of your contention is false. Websites like Ars have perpetuated this misconception that the cable companies have exclusive rights to put wires in the ground.[1] But I have not been able to validate this idea with my research. Every franchise agreement I've read makes clear that it isn't exclusive.

Which is exactly how Congress chose to deal with the possibility of companies abusing exclusive rights to put wires down on public rights of way--by making it illegal for municipalities to give them exclusive privileges.

[1] E.g. http://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2013/08/snubbe.... Ars talks about how Baltimore's franchise agreement with Comcast "effectively makes the company the exclusive cable television provider in the city." (Quoting the Baltimore Business Journal). If you actually read the 2004 franchise agreement, it clearly says it's not: http://www.baltimoregrassrootsmedia.org/PublicAccessTV/Franc... ("City hereby grants to Franchisee, subject to the terms and conditions of this Agreement and the Franchise grant ordinance, a non-exclusive Franchise with the right, privilege and authority to construct, operate, repair, maintain, and reconstruct a Cable System on, over, under upon, across, and along the Public Ways within the Franchise Area in accordance with the City's specifications and this Agreement.")

Re:FCC urged to investigate Verizon’s statements on utility ... by belorn on Tuesday January 13, 2015 @04:21PM (#8882681)
In your research, how many other companies has built a Cable System in Baltimore? If its non-exclusive only on paper, and in practice a monopoly, what actually effects does it have on quality, service, and price?
Re:FCC urged to investigate Verizon’s statements on utility ... by rayiner on Tuesday January 13, 2015 @04:35PM (#8882769)
You're changing the goal posts. We were talking about companies using "privileges granted to them by the government (such rights to lay cable lines) as an anti-competitive tool." Comcast is a near-monopoly here in Baltimore (though, I'm one of the lucky ones who has FiOS that Verizon managed to sneak in when the city wasn't looking), but it's not because they abused their privileges.

Ars makes it seem like Comcast bamboozled the city into signing an exclusive franchise agreement, but in reality nobody else wants to build here for the same reason Google didn't want to build here. Large parts of the city are a burned-out husk, a quarter of the population is below the poverty line, and it's unacceptable in the eyes of the city for anyone to just build-out to the parts of the city that might be able to afford fiber service.

Re:FCC urged to investigate Verizon’s statements on utility ... by belorn on Tuesday January 13, 2015 @05:19PM (#8883003)
My goal posts is not to vilify Comcast as a company in bed with government, but to find an explanation to why there is a near-monopoly. If a company has poor service, bad quality, and high prices, there should be competitors that are willing to earn revenue by competing with better service, better quality and lower prices. This is basic theory of the market, and as it goes, only government intervention allows for a monopoly in that environment.

So what is it. No person willing to fund a company in Baltimore? No investors willing to spend the same price as Comcast, or less if a smart founder can out-perform the past production cost?

If you can explain the monopoly without invoking government intervention, I am all ears.

Re:FCC urged to investigate Verizon’s statements on utility ... by rayiner on Tuesday January 13, 2015 @05:44PM (#8883137)
First, you said the issue was: "companies ... use[ing] the privileges granted to them by the government (such rights to lay cable lines) as an anti-competitive tool." Now you're saying the issue is: "explain[ing] the monopoly without invoking government intervention." Do you not see how those are two different contentions?

The Ars Technica narrative is that we need to regulate the telecom companies because they abuse their privileges to keep out competitors. But what's keeping out competition is, e.g., Baltimore forcing companies to build fiber service to the 25% of the city that's below the poverty line as a pre-condition for building anywhere in the city. It's Bill de Blasio turning FiOS deployment into a civil rights issue.[1] It's not clear to me how these requirements are the result of telecom companies abusing their privileges. And it's not clear to me how the solution to a problem created by over-regulation is imposing even more regulation.

I'm not a anti-regulation type. If a telecom company is digging under roads in a way that's hazerdous to public safety or the environment, that should be regulated. But this is an issue that turns mainstream liberals into Nader-ites espousing thoroughly discredited regimes like Title II. For god's sake Kushnick thinks the government should be in the business of telling companies what prices they can charge. As someone too young to remember the 1970's, it comes across as insanity.

[1] http://www.speedmatters.org/blog/archive/new-york-mayor-bill... ("If you can’t afford to feed your family by the end of the month, you can't afford $75 a month for the broadband service. And that's what we have to fix.")

Re:FCC urged to investigate Verizon’s statements on utility ... by shkkmo on Tuesday January 13, 2015 @09:21PM (#8883910)
> If you can explain the monopoly without invoking government intervention, I am all ears.

>> But what's keeping out competition is, e.g., Baltimore forcing companies to build fiber service to the 25% of the city that's below the poverty line as a pre-condition for building anywhere in the city.

The original, specific contention (exclusive cable laying rights) may be untrue according to you.

Does that matter whether the government is enforcing the monopoly through excesive coverage requirement or through limiting cable laying rights? The government is still helping to enforce a monopoly.

I think the argument is that the telecom companies need to be regulated because they're a monopoly. So... government is helping to enforce a monopoly

Re:FCC urged to investigate Verizon’s statements on utility ... by rayiner on Tuesday January 13, 2015 @10:46PM (#8884165)
> Does that matter whether the government is enforcing the monopoly through excesive coverage requirement or through limiting cable laying rights?

The original contention was not that the government is helping to perpetuate the monopoly, it's that the cable companies were using special privileges in an anti-competitive way. There's no special privileges, and if you look at e.g. Verizon's tussle with Baltimore, they're not the ones lobbying for excessive coverage requirements.

I don't know why the solution to government policies that discourage competition isn't getting rid of those policies.

Re:FCC urged to investigate Verizon’s statements on utility ... by fnordfnordfnord on Tuesday January 13, 2015 @06:07PM (#8883221)
>But what's keeping out competition is, e.g., Baltimore forcing companies to build fiber service to the 25% of the city that's below the poverty line as a pre-condition for building anywhere in the city.

Why is that pre-condition supposedly preventing companies from building infrastructure? It's not as though the City has also demanded that they operate at it a loss, merely that they build out service to the entire city as opposed to building service out to the choicest bits. And, isn't that exactly what a city government ought to do?

Re:FCC urged to investigate Verizon’s statements on utility ... by rayiner on Tuesday January 13, 2015 @06:34PM (#8883323)
See the math here: http://bits.blogs.nytimes.com/2008/08/19/a-bear-speaks-why-v....

It costs you $1,000 just to pass a house, even if they don't subscribe, and you have to maintain that infrastructure too. If 40% of passed houses subscribe (Verizon has been struggling to hit that number for years), you pay $2,500 per house that does subscribe. This is the "uptake ratio" and a fiber provider lives and dies by that number.

Build-out requirements tank your uptake ratio, because you spend a bunch of money passing houses where people can't afford to subscribe. It increases how much you need to make on all the other houses to recoup your costs.

But your other subscribers don't give a shit about your costs. They're willing to pay, e.g., $100/month for triple play, and they don't care if your per-house cost is $2,000 or $4,000. If you raise your prices to recoup your costs, they'll just stick with the incumbent, again tanking your uptake ratio.

A small ISP may be willing to ask for a $10 million bank loan to wire up a yuppie neighborhood like Fells Point, with the prospect of seeing how it goes and building out from there. Nobody will ask for a $250 million bank loan to wire up the whole city of Baltimore.

Re:FCC urged to investigate Verizon’s statements on utility ... by belorn on Tuesday January 13, 2015 @08:32PM (#8883731)
I do not take it that Comcast is charity, so either they made a horrible deal and lost significant amount of investment, or the narrative is lacking some details. I personally doubt we will find a $250 million investment in Comcasts books regarding the city of Baltimore however, as I find there is simpler narratives that would match in how cities like Baltimore gets fiber into peoples homes. It would also explain why some cities has has semi-monopolies and others don't.

A city that wants fiber has the obvious choice to subsidize the investment of a large ISP, say Comcast, thus severely reducing the investment cost. The permission to build is of course non-exclusive, but the subsidizing is not. Once built, the ISP gained a government granted advantage, and thus a monopoly is born.

Alternative, a city can create a government bid for administrating and building a city fiber network. On paper, this mean that the city owns the fiber, and the ISP that builds it has to sell access on equal ground with competitors. The ISP do still get an advantage in operation knowledge, some payment for doing the administration, and first mover advantage. This tend to result in healthy, if somewhat constrained, competition.

Ars Technica narrative talk about how the cable division paid little or no construction costs. That is very different aspect than if the permission to construct, operate, repair, maintain, and reconstruct a Cable System is non-exclusive.

Re:FCC urged to investigate Verizon’s statements on utility ... by rayiner on Tuesday January 13, 2015 @10:42PM (#8884152)
> A city that wants fiber has the obvious choice to subsidize the investment of a large ISP, say Comcast, thus severely reducing the investment cost. The permission to build is of course non-exclusive, but the subsidizing is not. Once built, the ISP gained a government granted advantage, and thus a monopoly is born.

Cities don't subsidize cable companies. Indeed, they extract concessions from them. E.g. every time Comcast re-ups the contract in Wilmington, DE, where I used to live, they have to kick in a random couple of million to government programs.

> Ars Technica narrative talk about how the cable division paid little or no construction costs.

Who cares what division within the ISP paid the construction costs? At the end of the day, the money came from the company's paying customers, not the municipalities.

Re:FCC urged to investigate Verizon’s statements on utility ... by belorn on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @07:17AM (#8885748)
If that is true, we will see Comcast try to sell off its losses in the coming years, and if that fails, go bankrupt. No company, no matter size, can keep a failing investment indefinitely.
Re:FCC urged to investigate Verizon’s statements on utility ... by rhino369 on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @07:58AM (#8885916)
The thing you are missing is that the first mover is not making a bad investment. They get 100% of the willing customers.

A second mover really only has a chance of getting 50% of the market. But it still has to build a network that services 100%.

A third mover really only has a chance of getting 33%, but has to service 100%.

The first mover doesn't get subsidies, they just get 100% of the market. The second mover likely can't be profitable. The first mover will match or beat their prices.

Re:FCC urged to investigate Verizon’s statements on utility ... by tesmar2 on Tuesday January 13, 2015 @06:45PM (#8883371)
They can if they want to, but it seems that is would stifle startups. I guess that is why Google is insisting that cities NOT have that premise with Google Fiber.
Re:FCC urged to investigate Verizon’s statements on utility ... by fnordfnordfnord on Tuesday January 13, 2015 @05:27PM (#8883055)
THE PRICING OF POLE ATTACHMENTS http://www.phoenix-center.org/pcpp/PCPP34Final.pdf

It's a wacky wacky pricing scheme to get space on poles and in utility rights of way.

Re:FCC urged to investigate Verizon’s statements on utility ... by deciplex on Tuesday January 13, 2015 @11:54PM (#8884390)
If a city reserves the right to grant other parties the right to lay down the cable in the future, but never actually exercises that right, they have effectively given Comcast an exclusive franchise.
Re:FCC urged to investigate Verizon’s statements on utility ... by driverdan on Tuesday January 13, 2015 @05:50PM (#8883158)
That may be the intent of regulation but what ends up happening is that companies shape the regulation in a way to benefit the incumbents and push out competition.

The government should stop granting companies privileges and let the free market work.

Re:FCC urged to investigate Verizon’s statements on utility ... by xnull1guest on Tuesday January 13, 2015 @07:36PM (#8883538)
I absolutely acknowledge that bad regulation is a problem, and wish more liberal minded folk would as well. But the problem is again not a binary one: the 'free' market also favors monopolies and incumbents and without a system of punishment and enforcement it is fact (historical and current) that companies will do everything in their power to externalize costs, fix their own success and seek rent.

So it's more a matter of creating 'good' regulation and designing markets (think cap-and-trade) that meet all criteria. It's not easy and you are right to be skeptical of industry's current role in designing its own regulation.

Re:FCC urged to investigate Verizon’s statements on utility ... by fpgeek on Tuesday January 13, 2015 @09:35PM (#8883952)
People talk about regulating telecom like the power company, but the trend over the last 30 years has been to deregulate the power companies as much as possible.

And it's not like anything has happened since then that has made people rethink power company deregulation, too: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_electricity_crisis