News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Experts pledge to rein in AI research by amelius on Tuesday January 13, 2015 @08:34AM (#8879644)
Why not do the same with all of technology?

Why do shareholders of big corporations profit from science in a grossly non-proportional way, while more than 50% of world's population has to live on under $2 a day?

It is time for the world's greatest minds to start thinking about how to fix capitalism, because it seems to be seriously broken.

And we need it fixed more than we need e.g. iPhone 7.0, or Google Adwords 2.0.

Re:Experts pledge to rein in AI research by blfr on Tuesday January 13, 2015 @09:34AM (#8880065)
Coming from a formerly communist country, I have a severe distrust towards "great minds" with some radical fix for capitalism.

Actually, we should start treating social fixes like we do technical rollouts. Prove it on a small scale somewhere first, and then carefully expand.

This seems like common sense. Yet for some reason changes in policies tend to be sweeping, national or even international.

Re:Experts pledge to rein in AI research by kylebrown on Tuesday January 13, 2015 @10:20AM (#8880341)
Clinical medicine is a better analogy than technical rollouts. But you're right, modern development economics argues that social fixes (policies) should be empirically driven using evidence-based randomized control trials.

Esther Duflo has pushing this approach at the MIT Poverty Action Lab. The main insight is to reject grand generalizations and broad theorizing. Sitting in an armchair pondering how to "fix capitalism" is unlikely to lead to useful lines of thought. Society is too complex a system, cause & effect relationships can be highly localized and context-dependent; formulaic thinking just leads one down ideological rabbit holes.

Re:Experts pledge to rein in AI research by FrojoS on Tuesday January 13, 2015 @10:32AM (#8880417)
Well, in an old school way thats already whats happening. We have many countries on this planet (UN recognizes about 200) and some of the most modern are actually a collection of smaller states organized in a federation. USA, Germany, Switzerland etc.

In fact, you guys had the unfortunate role to find out how well USSR style (I assume) communism works.

Re:Experts pledge to rein in AI research by mseebach on Tuesday January 13, 2015 @09:18AM (#8879955)
Re:Experts pledge to rein in AI research by delinka on Tuesday January 13, 2015 @10:21AM (#8880353)
If "shareholders of big corporations" aren't going to see the monetary benefits, then why would they even pursue the research?

Put another way: if the financial beneficiary of increased efficiency is NOT they who invested, why would those investors make the investment?

Re:Experts pledge to rein in AI research by amelius on Tuesday January 13, 2015 @10:30AM (#8880404)
Perhaps you missed the word "non-proportional" (=disproportionate)
Re:Experts pledge to rein in AI research by delinka on Tuesday January 13, 2015 @10:44AM (#8880485)
I don't think I did. What's a proportionate distribution? Proportionate to what and for whom? The whole "market" or "system" of innovation is driven by "disproportionate" distribution. If people don't have the potential to get rich creating a New Thing or Efficient Method, what's to encourage them to even consider Something Better?
Re:Experts pledge to rein in AI research by amelius on Tuesday January 13, 2015 @06:10PM (#8883229)
> If people don't have the potential to get rich creating a New Thing or Efficient Method, what's to encourage them to even consider Something Better

Let me give an example. In academics, as pointed out here before, smart young people have to survive for a long time on relatively low pay, and without a real prospect of making a lot of money in the long term. In other words, they do this work because they like to do it, and/or for idealistic reasons.

If we can (somehow) change the system such that smart and idealistic people get in charge instead of greedy people, that could be a step forward.

Again, I'm just giving an example, to show you my line of thinking. I don't claim that this is the correct approach.

Re:Experts pledge to rein in AI research by delinka on Friday January 16, 2015 @09:40AM (#8899129)
"In other words, they do this work because they like to do it, and/or for idealistic reasons." I'd like to see a study on this. In my experience, this is not the case.

My peers and I, while in college, did this work because one day it would pay off. If we'd been told that our pay would always be meager, and still continued to do the work, perhaps one could attribute it to idealism or simply liking the work. Most likely, however, we'd have relegated the work we liked to hobby status while we pursued something that would pay better.

Re:Experts pledge to rein in AI research by tljr on Tuesday January 13, 2015 @09:07AM (#8879886)
Wow. Went strait to 11 there didn't you. Though I must say, I can't disagree with any particular point.