This is probably the one single point I've seen completely overlooked in every men vs. women debate.
As someone who's been in management, I can't count how many times senior executives who were male wanted to promote a woman to a more senior role, only to have other senior women disagree to such an extent, it caused a scene. This is probably one of the more interesting dynamics in this conversation which is often brushed aside.
One of my colleagues once made the comparison how men are always in the "alpha" mode. Always trying to be top dog, always trying to outdo their peers for the top roles. He said this is just as prevalent with women, and most people never see it because women tend to be more, shall I say more "backstabbing" than their male counter parts.
I doubt there's an easy fix here. My take is that there's a larger aspect not addressed in the article: women simply aren't socialized to be socially aggressive. The same way women often won't negotiate salary and then we wring our hands over women's salaries. How about of instead changing everything to suite these women, we encourage them to be more socially aggressive? Its not like these things are pleasant or easy for men either. I feel like if I didn't learn how to act this way, I wouldn't be competitive at my job. The same way I see loads of shy male techies who never speak up and don't contribute much and don't end up promoted or appreciated. I think its a skill that can be learned and things like "oh I'm INTJ, oh I'm a woman, etc" are excuses. Why aren't some people motivated to learn the proper social skills? As a previous shy person, I know that this is just a learn-able skill.
I don't think we need to make meetings longer and "nicer" and if we did, it would just lead to resentment and fleeing of talent to company B where that talent can thrive without a lot of politically correct baggage holding them back. Now company A is a bunch of quiet milquetoast types unable to engage in argumentation and eventually not be competitive against a more aggressive company.
Lastly, a lot of the more quiet people I've worked with are so because they just don't have a lot of good ideas. They're bureaucrats and desk jockeys or are ultrafocused on their little niche of the world and add the same things over and over regardless of context. Yeah, the TPS reports might be slow to load, but this isn't the time or place for it, yet the TPS manager has literally nothing else to add. Maybe those without much to add should be quiet.
The Harrison Bergeron-ing of all things really isn't the way to go. I really wish more people understood that.
The article makes the point that women are socially penalized when they are aggressive. It's not a lack of socialization into aggressiveness, but rather an active socialization into passiveness.
So the system doesn't work for women, nor for minority groups, nor for many men. Doesn't that suggest that we should be trying to fix the system?
In my experience values drive law more than law drives values. Marijuana has been illegal for some 40 years (or more!) in the US but that didn't make everyone think it was bad. And now the fact that so many people are unconvinced that marijuana is bad is changing the laws and it's being legalized all across the US.
Critical theory is fine but "trying to fix the system" implies that there is some method by which the system can be fixed other than "everyone has to just grow up" since I don't foresee an "everyone must grow up" law being terribly successful.
EDIT: Let me state that I don't necessarily think the current state of affairs is OK, just that it's a fairly intractable problem that won't get solved quickly. I can figure out what's wrong with my car and install replacement parts. I can figure out what's wrong with society but there aren't any replacement parts.
The USSR is also a good example, especially with women's rights. There was a top-down equality decree without any sort of legitimate social movement. In practice, women in the USSR, outside of propaganda, were treated poorly and once the USSR fell, Russians just naturally fell into their deep patriarchal views which are mainstream there. If anything, women have it worse in modern Russia because of the USSR's heavy handed idealistic decrees.
But that doesn't have to be the end of the story. Some of the challenges that women face in the workplace can't be solved simply by those women. I think that was a major point of the article. There are common subconscious biases that businesses would be well served to address. That doesn't have to mean that businesses treat anyone like victims. It means they aren't necessarily maximizing the value of their human resources. I don't think there's a single optimum strategy for running business meetings, but we should certainly better understand the advantages and disadvantages of different approaches.
There are biological factors at work here too - the hormonal balance in a man versus a woman (testosterone, etc) leads to widely divergent levels of observed aggressiveness in almost all contexts (social, physical, etc).
EDIT: I edited my reply to clarify some points just as you responded. I have now addressed your first question, and your second question is based on a misunderstanding due to poor wording on my part.
EDIT EDIT, because I seem to have triggered HN's flamewar detector and it's not letting me post anymore:
>I've been ignoring this premise for the sake of argument, but now it's time to raise an objection: Men aren't harder on other men. Both men and women are harder on women.
Yes, I do believe men are harder on men than on women in the grand scheme of life, even if I concede that men can be harder on women in business and the workplace. Men are significantly more likely to be victims of violence from men than women are, whether in public life or in war. Far more men than women are incarcerated in the United States, where they are subject to worse treatment at the hands of guards and other prisoners alike than women are. A woman being raped is a tragedy, a man being raped is a literally a joke, a timeless staple of "edgy" comedians. Fathers expect significantly more from their sons than their daughters. A young woman living with her parents after college is natural; a young man is ridiculed. Men with problems are often not taken seriously by their peers; instead of lending an understanding ear, they're told to simply "man up" and bear it. Their problems are certainly not taken seriously by the media, which claims that their problems are insignificant compared to those faced by women and that they need to "check their privilege." Perhaps it should not be surprising that men are more likely to commit suicide than women.
Some of those ideas, especially one about the expectations of fathers for a man's success, hint at another element of sexism: the patronizing way that men can expect less of women. If you agree that this element exists and sucks, then you are conceding that men are more critical of men than women. I'm not trying to sound like a "men's rights activist" or anything, but it boggles the mind how people can believe or disbelieve the same fact depending on when it suits their argument.
>>dssacco
>I have to disagree however. Most insults that men give other men attack their masculinity, which is implicitly sexist.
That's a great point historically, but in my experience it hasn't been true for a while, and the majority of middle-class men wouldn't tell a man to "stop acting like a woman" these days. When a man is told to "be a man," the subtext is not "because you're acting feminine," but rather "because you're acting childish," or perhaps "because men are not allowed to express weakness." You can choose to interpret this as "all men are sexist because they're holding men to a higher standard here," or you can interpret as "men are not allowed to do something natural that is extremely important for mental health." Yet you don't hear anyone complaining about "interalized misandry," people always manage to reframe everything negative about the male experience as a matter of misogyny. As if we aren't allowed to have our own problems unless they involve women.
Edit: I've been ignoring this premise for the sake of argument, but now it's time to raise an objection: Men aren't harder on other men. Both men and women are harder on women. This article itself demonstrates this. (It's more complex than just "being harder on." But, in the context of this article I take "being harder/easier on" to be short for "tending to respond negatively/positively to verbal contributions, regardless of the contribution's merit.")
Don't get me wrong, misogyny and bias are on that list, but I don't have nearly enough information to even reason about how much of an impact they have compared to all the others.
I have to disagree however. Most insults that men direct to other men attack their masculinity, which is implicitly sexist. When men put other men down by likening them to females or female behavior, they are putting down both men and women, but under this model I'd have to say females appear to suffer more, if only because a man can (and is encouraged) to change his behavior to align with masculine values. A woman cannot do this (or cannot easily do this) because she is ultimately perceived as female regardless of her behavior.
You can argue that men are more openly critical of other men than women, but under the model I explained above, men are overwhelmingly more critical of other women, which really gets down to another core issue - men conflating sexism with open, explicit criticism ("it's okay for me to do this with guys but not girls") and ignoring the vast underbelly that is subconscious, unexpressed (but no less acted upon) sexism.
I'm open to arguments refuting this, but this seems to be about the size of it - ultimately, many men innately regard females to be lesser to the extent that they use femininity as an insult.
These insults work both ways - males use them to encourage other males to adhere to the stereotype, but so do females (in a less direct way perhaps).
And if you would sound like one, would that be bad in any way? Really, what's the problem with that word? Caring for Men's rights is bad?
Look up Karen Straughan on Youtube. She's an MRA and very intelligent woman. She raises many good points in the current, toxic debate.
I don't mean the majorities do it intentionally. Some of them, when reminded they are interrupting, apologize sincerely. It could be deep in human's conscience.
Seen similar behaviour in many minorities (gender, race, religion, nationality)
Seems now with this additional post that you just made your original post because you wanted to play victim or start an argument, either way it isn't making you look any better and still doesn't contribute to the overall discussion. In particular as you barely waited 5 minutes before declaring yourself a victim.
That's not true at all.
I think you got down-voted because you missed the point of the comment you replied to. (I think) the point was that even if you get rid of patriarchy, you'd still have to deal with women putting each other down. I guess that's noteworthy because it's easy to forget when you read an article like this one. I am constantly amazed by how poorly we treat each other. All of us, really.
And what if "nature at work" isn't so natural? Go back 50 years and people would say that it's unnatural for 2 men to love each other.
I've seen similar comments before and even going as far as saying women were harder on women than men when moving up in a career. It's deeper and more complex than men versus women. I've heard my share of anecdotal stories from women who say the same thing, women are their harshest critique and most difficult challenge. It seems daunting, how do you even begin to change that.
"He announced to the writers that he was instituting a no-interruption rule while anyone — male or female — was pitching."
That is excellent, and sad, that we have to go back to grade school etiquette to let people find a voice. It's true though, if a team member isn't trusted to have a voice they shouldn't be a part of the conversation. If they are a part of the conversation they should have the respect of the rest of the team enough for them to shut up and listen, then respond. Spirit sticks!